Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Bring back the second verse

Socialist Organiser no. 374, 5 October 1988 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 788 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

onfound their politics,/ Frustrate their knavish tricks" was once the second verse of the national anthem. George Orwell reckoned they were the only words of God Save the King" that made any sense: "Not to have a national anthem would be logical," he wrote in 1943, "But if you do have one its function must necessarily be to point out that we are Goud and our enemies Bad* Dave Gelly's review (trom which the preceding information was gleaned) of "Natona Anthems of the World" appeared, by coincidence, in the independent on the same day that news of Mrs Thatcher's Island Fortress" speech to the College of Europe broke. The Ministry of War is now the Ministry of Defence and (noted Gelly) we have quietly dropped that second verse. But it's probally only a matter of time before someone suggests rehabilitating it, "Bring Back the Second Verse" would make a good Sun campaign, maybe accompanied by a call to *Put the Guts Back Into Cur Anthem!" Cetainly, it would be in keeping with that newspaper's reaction to Thatcher's College of Europe tirade:

"Once more she is saying exactly what the people think...They have no desire whatsoever to become politically involved with foreigners with whom they have nothing in common...European union is a dead duck. They can take it from Margaret Hilda Thatcher, the voice of the people."

This was not of course the unanimous verdict of the national press. The EEC has always divided bourgeois opinion, just as it has the left. Owenite Peter Jenkins in his Independent column described the speech as sounding "like a bowdlerised version of wogs! at Calais"

The Daily Mail accurately reflected the misgivings of the more thrusting sections of the boss-class as they limber up for 1992: "We can't stop Europe and get off. And we can't stop Europe and stay in. All that our Prime Minister can do, if she continues to clutch the nationalist card to her bosom, is to play a spoiling hand."

Similar sentiments were to be MAIZE ME TOMYRIE PATE S THE INDEPEN DENT Jim Denham leader ("An Untimely Offensive") although the same paper had, on the previous day, carried a more approving piece by Bruce Anderson: "Over the past few years, Britain has managed her relationships with the Community by a combination of Anglo-Saxon pragmatism and swipes with the Prime Ministerial handbag. Neither tactic should be lightly discarded: both are extremely popular with the voters.

Anderson also gave us a very believeable account of the genesis of the speech: "Mrs Thatcher's pronouncements on Europe owed nothing to Foreign Office draughtsmen. Downing Street knew that there was no point in asking the F.O. for help: its views and the PMs' are just too far apart. So yesterday's Bruges speech was mainly written by Charles Powell, the PM's Foreign Affairs private Secretary, and when Geoffrey Howe read it, she probally wished he was back in Africa."

Peter Jenkins gave a similar account: "Sheer rage was the only. aspiration of the speech...her fury with Jaques Delores, the President of the European Commission, prevailed over the advice of officials and what ought to have been her own better judgement. An important occasion which required dignity and statesmanship was used to pursue what has been for her a vendetta".

According to Jenkins, the final straw was the appearance of Delores at the TUC Congress expounding his vision of a "Social Europe" , to the enthusiastic approval of delegates: "The sight of this cunical spectacle, 1 am told, threw Mrs Thatcher fury rible to behold"

The Express, meanwhile, had obviously grasped an inner meaning to Thatcher's words, which had evaded the rest of Fleet Street: "Mrs Thatcher's speech in Bruges has dispelled once and for all the dangerous myth that she is antiEuropean". • Or maybe there had been a different speech delivered at a secret location exclusively for Express leader-writers?

It may have been interesting to have closed with the Morning Star's coverage of all this, but I'm afraid I neglected to buy it on the crucial days last week. Instead we shall have to make do with the Mail on Sunday's resident yuppie Stalinist Julie Burchill: "For the past 15 vears we have lived with the very real terror of waking up one morning as boring as the Germans, hysterical as the Spaniards or as incapable of making a decent pop record as the French..the Eurobores should stop squealing every time the Prime Minister takes a stand. A stand against having us all made into indentical, individually wrapped Euro-portions. " Perhaps Ms Burchill could be persuaded to front the "Bring Back the Second Verse" campaign...?

Scan page 4

4 LETTERS

----- pull-quotes -----

found in Thursday's Telegraph FPRESS GIAN G Daily Express

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 374

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →