Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Now, unite the left!

Socialist Organiser no. 374, 5 October 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 1,059 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

From front page tempted to go on the offensive.

The Left needs to prepare to resist it. What can we do? We can make a serious effort to unite!

We can use the limited success of the Heffer-Benn campaign to pull the left together into an effectiveness it has not known since the collapse of the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Party Democracy', seven years ago.

For - let there be no doubt about it - the Benn-Heffer campaign did have its successes. It has galvanised the lett, pulled together in common hope and in a united enterprise the committed socialists in the CLPs. It has shown that the socialist left is still a force in the labour movement - even in this era when Thatcher is so triumphant that the leaders of the Labour Party are determined to cast themselves in the shameful role of her pale pink understudies.

As Benn truly told an audience in Blackpool on Sunday night, the total electoral college vote for Benn and Heffer probably disguises and undervalues the real level of support for them - in the unions for example (see page 6 & 7)

But how can the Left unite? The left is fragmented, dwindled, wasted by defeat and by factionalism, and divided by important political differences, which range from our attitude to the rulers of the Warsaw Pact states to proposals for Northern Ireland. It is vastly easier to unite when the floodtide is with you, as it was with the left until the early '80s, than it is in a time of retrenchment and defeat such as now. How can the left be united? Can it be united!

First of all, enough of the left has to want to unite. The left has to understand that it is only our antagonists and outright enemies who benefit from the present fragmentation.

We have to adopt the goal of seeking unity in action where possible and of establishing a framework of honest and civilised dialogue Scargill attacks the policy about our differences.

The Benn-Heffer campaign and the Chesterfield movement have created some unity, but not a unity broad enough to make the left the force it might be. And the Chesterfield movement is flawed: there is no way except on the level of abstract committment to vague socialist ideals and values - agreement about ends with no possible agreement about means - that socialists who are committed to work in the existing mass party of the British labour movement can reach fruitful practical agreement with such as the Socialist Workers Party, who are, implicitly, committed to building their own labour movement side by side with the one the working class has spent well over 100 years building. No way. And the local "Campaign groups' are still very weak. hoto John Harris (IFL)

The experience of the Rank and File Mobilising Committee may be of service here. It pulled together a broader spectrum of the left than has - to our knowledge - ever been brought together before or since. It even included the very aloof exclusive brethren of Militant - though their involvement was more token than active. The Rank and File Mobilising Committee was set up on the initiative of Socialist Organiser, which conducted the initial negotiations to bring the groups and individuals together.

The secret of the RFMC was that it demanded of no participant an abandonment of its own identity. For example, the RFMC did essentially what CLPD had been doing, but on a bigger scale, drawing much bigger forces in. But there was no conflict with CLPD - indeed people like Vladimir and Vera Derer were among the earliest supporters of the RFMC project. We created a broad democratic structure in which every participant felt they could freely work.

All the 'confederations' of groups today - Labour Left Liaison, in which SO is involved, for example - are failed efforts to unite the left. So we need a new effort to unite the left.

What project, or political platform, could bring or hold the left, or most of it, together again?

Self-defence! And defence of the basic ideas of socialism against the Thatcherising forces - from Neil Kinnock to the decadent scabs of Marxism Today and the Communist Party — in the labour movement!

Defence of the Welfare state and comittment to its reconstruction and expansion by a Labour government.

Defence of the trade unions and comittment to a Labour government ripping up the. vile Tory legislation of the last seven years.

Commitment to actively support working class people everywhere in their struggle against oppressive states and ruling classes, from South Africa to Chile, to the USSR and Poland.

Commitment here and now to organise civil disobedience against the poll tax. Nothing exposes the craven legality-at-all-costs policy of the Labour leaders so sharply and pungently as their refusal to organise or endorse a drive to get people to refuse to pay the iniTony Benn quitous poll tax!

Here is an issue that could be used to drive the Tories out of office if we had leaders with guts and committment. We don't have such official leaders, so we must manage without them. We must do it ourselves.

This suggested platform is, of course, only a possible basis for unity. Others may have different ideas.

What is very urgent now is to get a discussion going on the left about the basis for a new broad unity.

The elan and enthusiasm of the Heffer-Benn campaign must not be allowed to fade away, as it will surely fade away if we don't do something to develop and preserve it.

In the weeks ahead, SO will be approaching organised groups • of socialists and prominent individuals to discuss with them what we can do to unite the Left.

The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction sex or race"

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965.

atest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 374

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →