Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Will Gorbachev allow free trade unions?

Socialist Organiser no. 374, 5 October 1988 · scan p. 1 · about 816 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 1 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 1

ORGANISER Photo John Harris Now, N Hattersley and their eil Kinnock, Roy friends, in the Labour Party and the press, kicked up a great fuss because Benn and Heffer dared to challenge them for the leadership of the Labour Party.

It was a diversion' if not an outrage. It was an impudent refusal by the Left to accept defeat, if not downright lese majeste.

The Labour Party leadership rushed to change the rules so that it would be more difficult to challenge them in future.

But now that they have won the election, their tone has changed. The election wasn't a "diversion" after all, because it can be construed as a triumphant endorsement of everything that Kinnock and Hattersley stand for — now and in the future! This, of course, was to be expected. Kinnock and Hattersley forget what they have been saying because they want to improve on their victory over Benn The danger now is that they will feel bold and confident enough to launch a new offensive, a mopping up operation, against the left. Egg ed on by the press, the Tory press which pours such scorn and contempt on them, they will surely be Turn to Last week Mikhail Gorbachev defeated his main conservative fellow members of the leading committees of the so-called Communist Party of the Soviet Union and removed some of them from their posts of power and influence.

He had complained of entrenched bureaucratic resistance to his drive for 'perestroika' and "glasnost' (restructuring and openness). He has been complaining about it for the three years he has been in power. The whole drive towards a comparative openness originated when Gorbachev found his efforts at economic reform blocked by the incumbent bureaucrats and decided he had to try to call outside forces into the battle against them. Thus: glasnost.

Now Gorbachev has shattered his opponents at the top of the ruling elite and made himself President. He has set up a series of new committees to help run the country. He is trying to ease the deadening vicelike grip of the elite, powerful so-called Communist Party on the state and industry.

Whether or not Gorbachev's victory at the top of the ruling bureaucracy will clear out the powerful banks of resistance at the lower layers of the bureaucracy remains to be seen. Resistance to innovation at those levels of the elite has, for over 20 years, stopped initiatives from the top tor change.

How far will Gorbachev go? How far does he want to go? Is Gorbachev - as many good socialists in Britain believe - about to usher in some variant of a democratic socialist system in the USSR? How can one judge from the distance?

There is one standard of judgement - sure and clear and precise: Will Gorbachev allow the workers of the USSR to organise trade unions to defend their interests? Will Gorbachev lessen the grip of the political police, which today force the workers of the USSR to belong to state-run pseudo trade unions? These unions are in fact mere organs of the management and not trade unions at all, not at all organs of working class self-defence against the plant management and the state which backs it This is surely the test. Even in vastly oppressive capitalist systems, from South Africa to Britain to Chile, the ruling class has been forcIS ee page 6 and 7 ed to allow — more or less grudgingly and reluctantly - trade unions. In the early '20s, Lenin fought for the right of trade unions to be independent of the state in the When circumstances favoured them, the Polish working classs in 1980 broke out of the management-serving police-state unions and created the 10 million strong free trade union, Solidarnosc.

Will Gorbachev allow those workers in the USSR who want free trade unions to organise them? Will Gorbachev stop persecuting the advocates of free trade unions in the USSR, who have been hounded, though sane, into lunatic assylums and some of them into early graves for fighting for the elementary right to working class organisation?

There is not the slightest sign that he will. Gorbachev is engaged in a limited reforming exercise. He does not want to overthrow the entrenched system of privileged and undemocratic bureaucratic rule created by Stalin, but only to modernise it and render it capable of survival in changing conditions.

If the ruling bureaucrats - who lyingly say their system is socialism — allowed the workers to organise freely, the working class would soon begin to ask basic questions about the nature of the system live in, and about the right of the bureaucrats to rule over society.

That's why Solidarnosc was outlawed in Poland in December 1981, atter eighteen months of legality. Gorbachev is trying to reform the existing system.

Part of his plan is to

----- pull-quotes -----

unite the eft

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 374

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →