Make Labour Our Party!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
comradely' Tell that to the women who have raited in pain for years for operaons that they cannot afford to ave done privately.
Yes we do want more women in 'arliament. But not so that they an hob-nob it with our class nemies. We want women with ocialist politics who will put the ase for working class women; who rill refuse to get sucked into backapping, old pals act because they ave a base of working class women ehind them who know what they re up to and to whom they are acwing organiser and fighter for democratic changes in the party. But the idea that we can be "comradely' with someone like Edwina Curry because we are all women comes from a long tradition of radical feminism that, having no regard for class politics, has thrown many women in the Labour Party off the right track.
Women are going to have to fight hard and recruit many working class women who are also prepared to fight if they want the Ministry for Women to be more than just a talking shop.
Labour-controlled councils which have declared their commitment to women's rights therefore have a clear opportunity to put that commitment into practice - by refusing to cooperate with any aspect of the poll tax legislation. We must also link up with the council and civil service workers in NALGO and the CPSA and fight for a policy of non-implementation.
Women's sections must demand that the Labour Party nationally takes up and leads the fight against this vicious anti-working class attack. each month by post. Rates £1.50 for six months, £2.50 for a year.
Name Address Please send me 6/12 months subcription to WF. I enclose £ To: WF. Po. Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Cheques payable to Women's Fightback.
Scan page 16
Pettifor congratulating Jo Richardson at LP Women's Conference. Photo John Harris (IFL ow feminism lost its way Women for-Sochalism Analysing the Policy Reviewe Norbrick Castle Hotel Blackpool Monday=3rd October.749pm Speakers: Elean Thomas, Alice Mahon MP, Martha Katherine What has happened to women's were undoubtedly qualified. politics in Britain? Today, every bookshop has its selection of feminist books, local authorities have their equal opportunities policies, even some Tory women pronounce themselves rather than formulating theory. to be feminists.
But for the mass of women, little has changed. Feminism is respectable — yet the bulk of working the attitude of much of the '60s and class women are stuck in low paid early '70s male left. work in non-union workplaces, juggling home and family against a time when radical young people — background of declining welfare provision and increasing poverty. anything. There was a mood of opWhat remains of the women's movement of the "70s is little more than a middle class milieu, a milieu, was part of that. moreover, locked into semitheological debates over hierarchies women's movement were broadly of oppression, debates which have socialist. The movement was quite little bearing on the lives and strug- diverse in terms of ideas, but there gles of ordinary women.
What went wrong? How could that said women's oppression was the lively, dynamic movement of to do with the way that society is the "70s end up like this? organised generally and that The modern women's movement women's liberation is bound up in Britain was a vibrant radical with the struggle for socialism. movement. Women, whose expectations had been raised by access to political' summed up this idea. higher education, vented their anger Fringe Meeting Osanaor, Aladines Ginci Freewefreshmente on a society which still treated them blems as personal, but in fact these as mindless "dolly-birds', which problems are shared by women and denied them access, on an equal arise out of the condition of women basis to men, to jobs in which they in society.
In short, the early women's Women from traditional left movement fused an elementary organisations rebelled against the understanding that, to fully liberate crass sexism of their male comrades women, the world would have to be and the secondary place they were turned upside down, with a concern assigned - typing up circulars to win democratic rights for women in the here and now - equal pay, Eldridge Cleaver's often-quoted the right for women to be treated remark about the position of equally when applying for women in revolutionary struggles jobs/promotion, etc. What hapbeing 'prone' pretty much sums up pened over the tollowing years, culminating in the GLC experience, was the pulling apart of the The late '60s to early "70s were a democratic and socialist strands, complicated by the input of USoften students — felt they could do style radical/cultural feminism.
By the late 1970s, the focus of the timism, a mood that 'we can change women's movement had shifted the world'. The women's movement from demands around social issues to more personal questions around In its early days the politics of the sexuality. The slogan 'the personal is political' was turned on its head - the solution to women's situation was seen more and more by a was a unifying thread - the thread current in the movement as to be found in changing one's own lifestyle - at the extreme end by withdrawing completely from relationships with men, at the softer end by concentrating on 'personal The slogan 'the personal is growth' and development.
Oddly enough, it is in the politics Women may experience their pro- of this radical/cultural feminist current that the approach of magazines like Cosmopolitan is rooted, its on ly one step from 'the political is personal' to the go-getting, sod everyone else, approach of Cosmo woman. The ideology of sisterly solidarity dissolves into a weird version of bourgeois competitive individualism. 1978 was the year of the last ever Women's Liberation Movement conference. The split was finalised between the radical and the socialist feminists. But the socialist feminist current too had taken on much of the ideology of the cultural feminists. Capitalism and patriarchy were seen by many socialist feminists as separate systems — the struggle of women against men and the struggle of women as workers against capitalaism were to some degree seen as separable.
In the early 1980s, there was a big influx of socialist feminist womer into the Labour Party. This meshed in with the rise of the new left in the Labour Party, a left motivated by the idea of 'never again' a Labour government like that of Wilson and Callaghan, and organised around constitutional changes and the 'Benn for Deputy' campaign.
This influx of feminist women into the Labour Party had enormous potential. It raised the possibility of re-uniting socialist and democratic demands for women in a new working class-orientated women's movement. Women from outside the traditional sluggish structures and routines of the labour movement could shake up the Labour Party. A fight to force the labour movement to take up 'women's issues' could have an immense impact on the party as a whole.
This potential, however, was never realised. The debacle of the GLC played a pivotal role.
Labour's new left made a big impact in local government. Between 1978 and 1983 left Labour administrators were elected in local authorities. In May 1981 Ken Livingstone was elected leader of the GLC.
The GLC's 1981 manifesto contained explicit commitments to fight the government, to demand proper funding and services. Livingstone personally pledged the support of the GLC to any workers in struggle. But it slid away from this very soon. In early 1982 the GLC decided to obey the courts over the 'Fares Fair' issue.
Livingstone's GLC abandoned its overt commitment to the working class, to socialist politics, for a variant of radical liberalism. It turned towards women, and other oppressed groups, in search of ways of being 'radical' that did not mean collision with the Tories and the courts.
But what did the GLC do for women? Equal opportunities policies, women's committees, handing out grants to women's groups and projects was all very good — but separated off from any commitment to fight for the working class, including working class women, it became not only cosmetic, but potentially divisive.
Instead of overcoming sex-based divisions in the working class it tended to reinforce them. Equality in the workplace became a question of management-imposed initiatives rather than part and parcel of a fight to convince male workers through the structures of the labour movement. Male workers suffering from local goverment cuts were not necessarily wrong to ask 'What is this "socialist" authority doing, undermining our conditions and cutting services, and at the same time throwing money at "women's projects' ?' Meanwhile, for most women working for the GLC it was business as usual - low pay, the worst jobs — and the women in the typing pool still had to ask permission to go to the toilet.
The GLC experience decisively set back active women's politics in Britain. Equal opportunities pressure-group politics, combined with a variant of cultural feminism, has replaced real campaigns and real attempts to organıse women, particularly working class women, to fight in the here and now for their liberation.
In reality, of course, events have proved the whole project to be valueless. What use is positive discrimination in hiring, when you are cutting jobs?
The way out of this mess doesn't lie in Militant-style 'women are just workers' politics. We have to reunite the fight for democratic rights for working women with the broader socialist perspective. We need to turn to working class women, to come up with answers for all aspects of their oppression -at home and at work.
Some women have managed to do very nicely thank you out of GLC-style feminism. Most women haven't. The fight for real equality for working class women is still at square one. Socialist women in the labour movement must get out of the municipal-feminist blind alley, and turn to working class women now
----- pull-quotes -----
By O'Leary