Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

NALGO needs a serious broad left

Socialist Organiser no. 373, 29 September 1988 · scan p. 11 · about 649 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

NWRHA NALGO The Poll Tax. The Housing Bill. Cuts in local government spending. The Education reform Act. Employment Training.

These Tory policies are attacks not only on working class people but also on the jobs, pay and conditions of workers in NALGO. A real fight by NALGO members will be an essential part of any successful fightback. But NALGO's leaders still refuse to fight. It looks grim.

After last Saturday's (24th Sept) NALGO Broad Left national conference in Leeds? Well, it still looks grim. In fact, the conference was grim. Perhaps it had been publicised on page 10 of the Batley Evening Standard - certainly nowhere else. So 45 people attended (NALGO has over 600,000 members) and most were from the SWP or Militant. Grim is the word.

All the major attacks listed above - and more — were covered. But this was not a Broad Left thrashing out ideas for action, for resisting Tory attacks and building within the union. This was a Teddy Bear's picnic with squabbles. It was a quaint, caricature Broad Left — the kind which the right-wing describe.

The Militant teddies spoke of the rise and rise of the Broad Left as it engaged in new battles, attracting "whole new layers" of NALGO members (so why weren't they at the conference?). This would be reflected in the fall of NALGO's national executive to the Broad Left (the BL — ie. Militant - presently has 2 NEC members).

The SWP teddies disagreed. They said we cannot find "organisational solutions to political problems" The "political problem" is New Realism - read the TUC/Labour Party - read reformism. The answer is a "fighting alternative" - read the SWP, read socialist revolution. Attention to the union's leadership should mean attacking them for their new realism. Full stop.

pathetic, Broad Left which the right-wingers depict. For example, Socialist Organiser supporters argued — in a debate on the merger between NALGO and NUPE - that the new union should have regional structures and election of officials based on industrial groups (like Local Government, Health, Electricity) instead of geographical groupings of branches. Militant opposed this because it "puts conditions" on the Broad Left's merger policy — they don't want to argue too hard with the right-wing over trivia like union democracy! The SWP opposed it as *an organistional solution to a political problem"

It is perhaps as well that no new rank and file NALGO activists were there.

But the SWP and Militant did agree, though neither said so. They were both solely concerned with getting the Broad Left to adopt their own world outlook. They both see the Broad Left as an appendage - or potential appendage - of their own organisation. They're both wrong.

The Broad Left must be democratic, non-sectarian rank and file organisation. It must combine real grass roots campaigning with a real fight against the sell-out leaders. It must be built, but not as an electric machine for Militant supporters. It will not arise by magic from the "fight against new realism."

Socialist Organiser supporters in NALGO (SOS NALGO) will help to build a real Broad Left. Contact: SOS NALGO, c/o Nik Barstow, NALGO Office, 23 Compton Terrace, London N1 2UN. criticise it"

A campaign against amalgamation could be taken into the factories and branches. Local meetings could be held and leaflets produced. But Airlie will have none of it. After the performance of this discredited has-been (still living off memories of the Upper Clyde Shipbuilders sit-in) the Broad Left/Gazette opposition seems certain to break up. Even AEU NorthWest Organiser John Tocher is unhappy with Airlie's bureaucratic inertia and is canvassing the idea of a 'new' Broad Left that goes to the District Committees and branches. B AEU/EEPTU merger the ut with or without an TUC top brass are determined to keep lines of communication open with the electricians' leaders. This year's TUC chair Tony

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 373

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →