Betrayed but not defeated Blast group of
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
and they will look for aid and comfort only towards the imperalists. Such will be the inevitable drift for these "practical politicians whose conception of statesmanship will consist of attempts to manoeuvre with the imperialist interests which hold Palestine in a net. And the price ot such statesmanship can only be their willingness to act as an imperialist outpost in the Middle East for one or the other of the contending forces, hoping for protection and support in exchange.
Behind all this is the sorry fact that Israel cannot exist as a splinter state quivering in the flesh of the Arab Middle East without constant war-skirmishing or imperialist entanglements or both. This is guaranteed both for economic and political reasons.
This is why the only road that can save the Jews from subservience to imperialism or destruction by the Arabs is a course directed toward the reunification of Palestine on a basis which will permit the two peoples to live together in fraternal harmony. Such an outcome is simply impossible on the basis of the present policy of the Israeli leadership. And it is equally impossible as long as the Arab masses are under the unchallenged domination of their semi-feudal dynasties, Landlords, effendis and militarists.
The reunification of Palestine and of the two peoples in it can take place only through a struggle from below. The conditions for such a struggle are present as they were before partition - the class struggle within Jewish society, and the grinexploitation of the Arab peasants by their lords and masters.
We believe that the main (not exclusive, but the main) responsiblity for taking the initiative in this direction lies with Jewish workers -precisely because, as the Zionist leaders boast on any occasion, it is the Jews who are the most advanced socially and culturally, because it is they who claim to be socialists, etc.
While opposing any attempt by the Arab landlord regimes to ovethrow the Jewish state and impose their reactionary sway on the whole land, it is the duty of real socialists in Israel to fight for a policy, programme and a government of the working people which can bring about such reunification instead of deepening the nationalist gulf.
The key to such a programme is in the first place the policy of the people of Israel toward the Arabs now within their own borders. Israel must demonstrate that they are fighting not against the Arab people but against the Arab dynasts and landlords who are also the oppressors of the Arab people HAGANAH Ship themselves. It must demonstrate that it seeks the alliance of the Arab masses against their own exploiters - an alliance of classes.
It can demostrate this only by sharply reversing the whole Zionist policy toward the Arab people -accepting them as equals and collaborators in the building up, not of a Jewish state but of a bi-national state. We use the term 'bi-national' (which has been used with various senses) to designate merely the aim of a state which is the home of two peoples and comports itself as such, the forms to be worked out in common agreement.
Complete equal rights to the Arabs within the state of Israel:
equality, not Jim Crow, in the Jewish-controlled trade unions; the abandonment of the economic nationalism which has reigned in the Jewish community hitherto; the constitutional and de facto guarantee of the Arabs fully recognised status as a national people - here are the elementary beginnings of such a programme in Israel which can demonstrate in action the basis for a reunited Palestine.
Only such a government in Israel could seek to stir up the Arab masses of the invading nations against their own oppressors, raising in the first place its sympathy with the demand for land to the Arab Fellaheen and the other social interests of the submerged masses of the Arab semi-feudal world.
Such a state, which appears in the Middle East not as the representative of Jewish nationalist chauvinism but of the social aspirations of all the people, Jewish and Arab, could fight for a reunified Palestine - and live.
Such a programme for a revolutionary war against the Arab feudal lords, not a war of nationalist expansion against the Arab people. Such a programme cannot be expected from the present rightist government of Israel, dominated by the Jewish capitalist class and tail-ended by the bourgeois labour leaders of the Histadrut, which in the longer run can only stumble from disaster stalemate to subservience under outside imperialism.
Such a programme demands the fight for a workers' government in Israel as the vanguard of the future United Socialist States of the Middle East.
Without such a programme all the heroic sacrifices of the Jewish people and all the military victories of the Haganah will not be able to make of Palestine anything but a death trap for the peoples and a happy hunting ground of revived imperialist influence.
the time that the workers at Liverpool and Coventry had gone back the Post Office strike had lasted for 3 weeks. At its height over 100,000 were out and every Mechanised Letter Office except Belfast had shut down. For many postal workers this was their first real taste of industrial action. For most of us it was certainly the first time we had been out on an official strike.
That a major blow-up should happen in the Post Office came as no surprise to those who work there. Industrial relations have got rapidly worse over the past few years. 65,000 days were lost last year in disputes, a fifth of the total for the whole of British industry. We are high up on the Tory's list for privatisation. What used to be a loss-making service has been turned into a money-spinner by a combination of a ruthless drive to increase productivity and a highly selective interpretation of the disciplinary code.
Despite little or no opposition at national level, branches have fought these attacks tooth and nail. Post Office workers have little fear of unemployment being in a growth industry. The UCW hasn't suffered a major defeat since 1971 and at local level have enjoyed a large measure of control on working practices. Attempts to erode this have been bitterly resisted by walkouts, most lasting only a day or two.
The major issue at stake in this dispute was the Difficult To Recruit Area Supplements (DRAS) that the Post Office wanted to pay to some offices in the South-East. Compared to pay or the length of the working week the issue was an obscure one even for postal workers, although it certainly represented an attack on the national pay bargaining structure. Perhaps that is why the National Executive chose it for a ballot on industrial action. Nevertheless, the ballot showed a 2:1 majority in favour of industrial action and when the Executive called a 24-hour strike on August 31st the response was solid.
The strike was due to end with the return of the early shift the next day. It was only when we went back North West London Pans 0 in that we found that in certain selected offices throughout the country the management had flooded the place with casual labour. Casuals are an emotive subject for UCW members. Although there is no longer a closed shop in the Post Office, 100% membership is the norm. Casuals were clearly seen as an attempt to undermine this. The management's claim of a huge backlog of mail was simply a lie. They were using the excuse of the 24-hour strike to provoke a test of strength with the union.
If the management wanted a fight they certainly got one. 14 offices walked out immediately. The action then spread as other branches joined the strike through having members suspended for refusing to cross picket lines or handle diverted mail. In some instances branches came out simply because they were asked to. When pickets from Manchester went to Derby they were refused permission to go into the office to speak to the workers there. They put leaflets calling on Derby to come out in the letter boxes and the next day Derby was out.
By the end of the first week the strike had reached its peak. The support it enjoyed was entirely due to the activities of the rank and file at branch level. To my knowledge the Executive Council did not call a single branch out. In some branches such as Manchester and Liverpool Clerical and Counter staff had also walked out even though they weren't involved with the initial dispute. It was only after the publication of the Executive's agreement on Monday September 12th that branches began going back. Some didn't need any persuading, some like in London had to be dragooned back, but a significant number still held out.
The centre of the resistance to the deal was in the North-West where the branches had voted not to return until they all did. Manchester, the largest branch in the country, threw out the management's proposals based on the deal with only 6 against in a meeting of almost 3,000. Even right at the end a sizeable minority, over 600 in a meeting of 1,500, voted not to return until Liverpool Coventry did. In Liverpool daily mass pickets were held as management bussed scabs in. The militancy of the Liverpool branch became a powerful symbol for all of us.
If our Executive Council had displayed a tenth of the energy and commitment of the rank and file the strike could easily have been won.
Not only DRAS but a host of other issues could have been settled. Instead, all their energy went into undermining the action. They failed to anticipate that management might take advantage of the 24 hour strike. Instead of keeping all the branches out until everybody had gone back, the Executive did absolutely nothing. As branches were walking out almost by the minute they even offered to suspend industrial action over DRAS. Even with over two-thirds of the membership out they refused • to make the strike national, insisting that branches should negotiate on a local level. Management of course were operating a national strategy. And then came the infamous agreement. This not only gave the Post Office what they wanted on DRAS but on casuals and diversions as well. No wonder management started quoting from it.
In the end not even the spirit and militancy of the rank and file could overcome the treachery of the union leaders. The organisation that could have brought the rank and file together, that could have developed an alternative leadership and countered the actions of the Executive, does not as yet exist in our union. Despite the fact that those of us arguing for such an organisation are still a small minority, that remains the major task for all those who have now seen our leaders for what they are.
The strike cost us three weeks* wages. We got very little in return. Yet we did not go back defeated. The management weren't able to impose their terms on us as a condition of any return to work. But they'll be back. There are plenty of other issues on the agenda. Privatisation, productivity, office closures, discipline. What is certain is that we won't have to wait another 17 years for the next big dispute.
Whether we win that or not depends on how well the lessons of this strike are learnt. Hopefully this pamphlet will be of no small help in that process.
Lessons of the Postal Strike. Available from Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London 4NA. 30 pence + 20 pence p&p.
Scan page 10
MAUS CBs (poly chlorinated biphanyls) have been much in the news late, what with ships sailing around Africa and Europe looking for a port to accept their cargoes of toxic waste, and suspicions that PCBs have played a role in the seal plague. Though Britain was one country to refuse a berth to the Karin B, it seems that PCB wastes were getting into Britain — in the cargo holds of passenger aircraft.
PCBs are organochlorine pesticides, pests. Unfortunately, they also Kill or harm other animal life. This would not be so serious were it not for the fact that they are extremely stable chemicals. They do not break down easily and hence persist in the soil.
Once inside an animal, they tend to accumulate in the body fat. As smaller animals get eaten by larger ones, the amounts of PCB increase. Thus, seals, at the top of the marine food chain, contain concentrations of PCBs up to 10 million times that of the surrounding sea water.
Effects on seals are thought to include lowered resistance to infections, possibly a factor in the current epidemic of distemper in Northern European waters.
Effects on other mammals may include sterility. Tests on mink show that at 50 parts per million (ppm) of PCB in body fat (equivalent to 1 gram in 20 kilograms) they can no longer breed.
Attempts to re-establish breeding colonies of otters (related to mink) in Norfolk seem doomed for the same reason. An otter cub, recently released into the wild and killed by a car, was found to have 62ppm of PCB.
Since it could only have got the PCBs in its mother's milk, she must have absorbed a quite massive dose in her diet. It is therefore extremely unlikely that any further breeding could take place. Elsewhere in Britain, strong colonies of otters seem restricted to areas low in PCBs.
Use of PCBs as pesticides is declining, due to protests by conservationists and health and safety ac"Maus" is a combination novel and memoir in the unusual form of a comic book. It has been widely reviewed and praised. We asked Thomas Carlyle, who is 10, to review it for us.
*Maus, A Survivor's Tale" is mainly a true story in comic book form. It is the story of what a Jewish family went through when the Nazis took over Poland in 1939.
It is the story of Art Spiegelman's father and how he winds up in a concentration camp. This true story, which Spiegelman's father told to his son many years later, is mixed in with fiction.
Art Spiegleman draws the Jews as mice, the Nazis as cats and the Poles as pigs.
'Maus' is, I think written and drawn for more mature readers rather than for children. But the author does it so well that I could picture myself being there.
One strange thing about the story is that it ends when they get put in the concentration camp. Yet you know that the author's father didn't die in the concentration camp, because he lives to tell his story.
I thought "Maus' was very good at doing what the author intended. Most people don't know much about history any more. In this book some people will learn the history of Hitler and the concentration camps.
Because it is in comic book form many more people can read it. That's the idea, anyway. It's a good idea.
The first film ever to be made in the Lapp language may not sound like something you'd queue in the cold to see. Yet Pathfinder would be worth it, if only to see that no cinema queue could ever be as cold as the Lapplanders' frozen waters.
The film recreates an old legend, in which peaceful, hunting folk who worship bears are murderously invaded by a warrior clan. A young lad skis home to find his family are dead and, narrowly escaping with his own life, goes off to warn By Lynn Fergusson Ammunition for the likes A of Stuart Bell, who believes the actual incidence of child sexual abuse is greatly exaggerated came from a new, and surprising source this week.
Psychoanalyst Juliet Mitchell, one time golden girl of the women's movement appeared on a new Channel 4 series "What is Truth' which consists of a bevy of userfriendly academics discussing the old chestnut, beloved of 1st year Philosopy courses, 'Does the real world exist, and if it does can we perceive it'!
Mitchell appeared to discuss memory - do we remember real events, or do we 're-invent' the past. In the course of her vigorous defence of the latter position she used the example of 'incest' (sic).
Most cases of father-daughter incest, she claimed, are imagined. Children's genitalia, she said, are stimulated during such innocent events as nappy-changing and bathing. Such incidents mesh with unconcious desires of girls to have sex with their fathers- and produce claims of incest.
Probably children do experience some sort of stimulation during such mundane caring activities. Children do have sexuality albeit very diferent from that of adults. In small children sexuality isn't parcelled off into separate compartments but is more diffuse, more integrated with their entire being, then a child's overwhelming desire and need for its parents will have some sort of sexual content. pp others. They are horror-stricken, and run away to the sea, leaving only the lad and a few friends to defend, unsuccessfully, their own honour.
To save an old seer, the lad offers to guide the warriors through the mountains to the coast where his people are. And so he sets off on a frozen and apparently treacherous journey. Since it's a legend, it's not giving much away to say there is nonetheless a happy ending.
Pathfinder is executed with great skill. It is an exciting story, full of tension and action, with a faint, enticingly mythical quality. It is filmed in an extraordinary cold place — endless icy wastes, deserts of snow under frigid skies. All the men have But the idea that this will manifest itself actually as a desire of the girl-child to have intercourse with her father, or will produce detailed descriptions of this, is not only utterly ignorant of children but is an example of a vulgar, literalist charicature of Freudinanism that taken from the real thing has been castigated by feminists for decades.
Incest does happen, far more regularly than anyone used to think. A young girl is far more likely to be abused by her father, stepfather or uncle than by a complete stranger.
The essentially authoritarian power-relations within the family contribute to this - a man's daughter is, after all, his property.
He feeds her, clothes her, can beat her if she's 'naughty' — is her ruler.
It is his choice how he uses that power — he can be a benevolent despot, but she's still essentialy powerless. Sexual abuse is only one step futher — it is a logical progression from our present family set-up rather than a step outside it.
Workers with abused children are unanimous that most children are simply not capable of having invented the events they describe — they simply wouldn't have been able to imagine/make up things in such detail. Most 4 year old girls don't know about anal/oral sex — or indeed any other sort - unless it's been done to them. So much for Mitchell's 'fantasies' Juliet Mitchell's quack Freudianism can only contribute to the post-Cleveland backlash. Her theorising may seem very neat in the University seminar room, but in the bedroom of an abused girl it's a different story.
ice on their moustaches. It is incredible to think anyone could live in such a place, left behind when everyone else migrated south at the end of the Ice Age.
Pathfinder is a kids' adventure yarn, possibly spoiled from some Darchts DOlL of view by Father gripaly bloodleeing, and of course by the literacy sub-titles demand of children.
British audiences tend to be rather suspicious of foreign films, expecting them either to be incomprehensible Art or unmitigated rubbish. Pathfinder should prove that even films in supposedly obscure languages can be both well-made and entertaining. It deserves to be a box-office hit.
Thursday 27th October
----- pull-quotes -----
TUFFIN YOU AR TRAITOR
LES HEARIN'S COLLUIVIN
Saturday 1st October art spiegelmen.
The first La By Edward Ellis