[Here we reprint an editorial on Palestine from…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Here we reprint an editorial on Palestine from the US Marxist newspaper Labor Action and part of an article from magazine, New International. Both were written by well known author Hal Draper. The editorial, War of Independence or Expansion?', appeared on May 24th and 31st 1948, on the eve of Israel's Declaration of Independence. 'How to Defend Israel' appeared in July 1948 after the surrounding Arab states, led by British officers, had invaded Israel.
Labor Action and New International were publications of Max Shachtman's 'Worker's Party'. Like the other material we have so far published in this series from the 'orthodox Trotskyist' current, these articles show how far the dominant 'Marxist' attitude to the Middle East conflict today has travelled away Draper's article is warped, though not quite vitiated, by the call that the Jewish nation, fighting for its life, should become the leader in a war of liberation for the Arab masses too - that Israel should take on the messianic role played by revolutionary France in Europe at the end of the 18th century, and lead a general war of liberation in the Middle East. Despite this, Draper has a firm grip on the realities. Forty years later, his article reads like prophesy.
Since the source of so much confusion about the Middle East on the left is the Socialist Workers Party, it is worth pointing out here that Draper's organistion was closely linked to the predecessor of the SWP, which sold its publications in Britain, until the American group collapsed around 1960. from its starting point.
The UN, set up with fanfare to bring peace to the world is again showing that it cannot prevent or halt war even by fifth-rate powers, such as the states of the Middle East - let alone war by the major warmakers who control its deliberations.
Compelled by the falling apart of the British Empire to recognise the independence of Palestine on paper, the UN drew a braided line through that tortured country of mingled nationality, erecting a state-boundary wall between already suspicious and jealous peoples. The Jews were assured of a state of their own - a state completely outfitted with salients, corridors, enclaves and angles sticking into the sides of the surrounding Arab world, with military lines athwart each other and commercial routes interpenetrating. The Jews cheered.
Then Washington ran out on its own partition plan and the Arab leaders in turn were encouraged to proceed with their plans to enforce a Pan-Arab landlordism. When this had already gone virtually to the point of invasion, the White House flipflopped, backtracked and reversed gear again in a precipitous recognition of the new Jewish state of Israel, again encouraging the Jews.
If meanwhile the British line was more consistent, it was consistently directed toward fomenting the Pan-Arab reaction against the partition.
As long as the two people can thus be "sicced" against each other, the shadow of imperialist domination does not leave the scene. This is the end of UN policy.
If there is to be peace at the eastern end of the Mediterranean, and if the Jews and Arabs are to live in fraternal unity, no one can look toward the United Nations or to American and. British imperialism to bring this about. If there is to be peace, it has to be made by the peoples.
Labor Action has made clear its belief that the partition of Palestine into two non-viable states was not calculated to achieve any real solution of the Palestine question, and cannot. We have reiterated that, before partition, the road to a basic solution lay only in the joint struggle by the socialist workers of the Jewish community together with the oppressed peasant masses of the Arabs to throw off the yoke of their common oppressor - British imPerialism based on the two ruling classes, Arab landlords and Zionist capitalists; and such Arab-Jewish cooperation from below could have forged a united Palestine in the fire of anti-imperialist struggle.
Now that partition is virtually an accomplished fact, this basic road only takes a different form.
There is a war on — not yet full-scale war as this is written, but not far from it. The socialist working class of the Jewish territory has chosen to follow its Zionist leadership in achieving a separate state. As Marxist socialists — that is, as the only consistent democrats — we believe in and accept the democratic right of all peoples (including the Palestinian Jews) to self-determination, to work out their own destiny as they see fit. We said this even while advising against the exercise of this right to the point of separation.
The politics from which the Pan-Arab war and threats of invasion flow is perfectly clear. - the aim of depriving the Jews precisely of this right to self-determination. There is therefore not the slightest iota of common ground between the Arab landlords' opposition to partition and our own. While we are more firmly than ever of the opinion that the Jews' choice of separatism was a mistake and a setback for the only the impossion or unity ethan Palestine by Abdullah, the Mufti or the Arab League would be a reactionary solution even more disastrous in its consequences and a violation of the democratic rights of peoples.
To recognise the right of the Jews to self-determination, if it is not merely to be a pious obeisance to a formula, requires socialists also to recognise the right of the Jews to defend their choice of separate national existence against any and all reactionary attempts to deprive them of that right, whether by Arab feudal lords or UN imperialism. That is why we demanded recognition of Israel by the government, and why our British comrades particularly must demand similar action by the Labour government -as the concretisation of the demand that the imperialists keep out. That is why we demand the lifting of the imperialist embargo on arms to the new Jewish state.
But the defense of Israel's right of self-determination against a reactionary war of invasion is only one side of the picture. Surely even the Zionist leaders do not believe that the "Palestine question" will be over if only Abdullah stops short of Israel's borders! On the contrary, it only enters a new stage. On the one hand, the Jews face the possibility of permanent guerrilla warfare, above all, such permanent national unending "border incidents", hostility with the Arab world as would make national existence a nightmare of the Jewish splinter state. On the other hand, the unreproved demands by the Irgun and Stern gang for the conquest of all of Palestine raises the same question of future relations. For the socialist working class of Palestine that question is posed in terms of the present struggle as follows:
Are the Jews - socialist workers in their majority — to wage a war of nationalist expansionism, or a revolutionary war for the reunification of Palestine from below against both the Jewish and Arab ruling classes?
Today their struggle is a war of defense in the immediate circumstance. But tomorrow their struggle will inescapably be transformed into one or the other!
Before this question can be answered, the first illusion that needs destroying is the illusion that the splinter state of Israel can "go it alone". To be sure, given Haganah military victories, Israel can succeed in maintaining its formal independence. But world imperialism. -- British, American and Russian - will remain on the scene with their fingers in the pie as long as the Balkanisation of the Middle East The present situation in Palestine, the fruit of partition and the end product of Zionist policy in the country can only continue to inflame nationalist hostility on both sides.
Even if the Arab legions' invasion is beaten back, the new state of Israel exists in an impossible economic and political situation. Its leaders will be forced to seek to fortify the stability of the new state in face of an encirclement of hatred