Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The price of accepting th Tory agenda

Socialist Organiser no. 373, 29 September 1988 · scan p. 6 · George Davey-Smith · about 1,579 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

A pages of on the healt se reading the first ten new book on the health service, published by the Communist Party's publishing house, you realise that something is strange. The word "agenda" appears more often than "and" or "the", and the term "the left" is used by liffe with the same vitriol and frequency as Al Paccino uses 'fuck' in Dog Day Afternoon.

All becomes clear upon reading the acknowledgements - the book has grown out of articles which appeared in Marxism Today, house journal of fashionable, ultramodern(ist) new realism.

The gist of the book is that the traditional left has consistently advanced the wrong arguments and the wrong strategy for the health service.

Trade unionists, it seems, have been uncritical of the failings of the NHS, and have accepted what they have been given unquestioningly. All they can do is strike for more pay, or, exceptionally, take some action in unthinking defence of a service which they can't see to be the creaking, antiquated mess that it is.

Of course such people have no analysis except for *the widespread conspiracy theory that substitutes for understanding and examination on the left" The poor deluded souls who think they are fighting to defend and extend the NHS are quickly put right:

"Those socialists who think that they have a strategy that will allow us to develop a national health service out of the current dilemma are impotent, separated from power sources by their outdated assumptions and expectations. This applies not only to the ultra-left, for whom impotence a defining characteristic, but also to the mainstream"

In place of this dinosaur we require an open, participatory, innovative left which understands that conservatism has "captured the political agenda" and can move on from the fundamentalist desire to turn the clock back.

To illustrate his thesis liffe outlines three future scenarios for the NHS. These pieces of soothsaying, which take us to the year 2012 (and take up an inordinate part of a short book), are uninteresting in their own right but demonstrate the central points advanced above.

Strike action plays virtually no mole (except when the doctors ballot for industrial action) - pressure groups, consumer organisations and parliamentary lobbies being the main actors. In the most optimistic -scenario, in which a Labour-SLD coalition gets elected in 1992, the pivotal event is a remark made at a City banquet about NHS funding by Prince Charles (presumably a member of the broad democratic alliance). The bishops aren't mentioned, but doubtless they will be kept busy fighting our battles for us elsewhere.

Unfortunately, between the time the ameras ancies appeared in Marxism Toalay, and their assembiy into this book, troublesome health workers took the strongest industrial action since 1982.

Here we saw initial spontaneous strike action in Manchester spread through the country and involve many groups of workers outside the NHS. The demands were simultaneously for a better health service and for fairer pay and conditions for health service staff, and would seem to offer a model for uniting people in common cause.

However, since such action inconveniences the thesis of this book it must be down-played. In a footnote it is remarked that the action "rejuvenated those parts of the left that recognise only industrial action as genuine politics", but it was a "weak and unfocused dispute of limited impact".

Furthermore *we overestimate "It is a kind of Marxism which ends advocating policies whic are basically Tory, with a radical gloss.

the nature of the political understanding of those who work in or use the NHS'' Such misrepresentation is required to maintain the position that industrial action has no role in the future struggles for a socialist health service. This is seen to be so because strikes are sectional and generally only for more pay — and, naturalfreeze.

Such an outlook is the mirrorimage of that of some activists who maintained that the NHS strikes earlier this year should only be tor improved pay and conditions for health workers, and that to fight for defence of the NHS would only encourage the working class to put trust in the state and crush the action's revolutionary potential.

Both positions underestimate the simultaneous importance that material well-being and the popular aspects of welfarism, especially the NHS, have; and both positions would fail to optimally unite workers in their opposition to the Tories.

The strategy offered does not look promising, especially since its crowning achievement is held to be the election of a Labour-SLD coalition - and Iliffe himself shows how Labour has failed the NHS in the past.

There is no suggestion of fighting for a change of perspective within the Labour Party, however. Instead, the main planks of Tory attacks on the NHS are taken om board. After apparently dismissing the notion of infinite demand for health care, beloved of Joha Moore, essentially the same argument is advanced to explain why the NHS must set its sights lower.

Screening for cervical cancer is chosen as an example of the need to contain expenditure. Rather than extend the service and make real efforts to reach the high-risk populations who do not volunteer for screening, it is suggested that the available resources should be targetted out covering all over-35 year olds, and the demands for screening of "educated, young, articulate and sexually active women" who form a "powerful pressure group" with doctors for more resources should be resisted. This is an extraordinary position to adopt at a time when the trends in rates of early and established cervical cancer suggest that there will be a rapidly rising incidence in young women.

It is unsurprising that a policy for the NHS containing such a view should also support continued privatisation of ancillary services in the NHS. Direct charges for patients are also advocated, the much heralded participatory democracy here being seen in charging for diseases seen to be self-inflicted.

To make this seem more acceptable the first example is of the rich person skiing in Switzerland who breaks a leg and flies back for treatment. But quickly we are on to smoking:" factors. drinking and other *lifestyle This ingenious suggestion - also advanced by the Presidents of the Royal College of Medicine and Surgery to the Commons Select Committee on the Health Service — would make people suffering from poverty-related conditions such as coronary heart disease pay for the privilege.

Similarly, unless you are well behaved you can't have the benefits. of the health service. Dr. Iliffe thinks that women who don't attend for ante-natal care should receive no maternity benefit; that people who fail to prove the practice of preventive dental care should have no free dental repair work performed, and that childhood vaccinations should be compulsory.

But now we have a problem how does the participatory democracy held up as the alternative to impotent ultra-leftism deal with such situations? Who decides whether your disease is your fault and you pay for your treatment (was your heart attack because you ate one too many plates of sausage and chips or because you'd been made unemployed?) or not. When researchers disagree as to their efficacy and safety, who decides which vaccinations should be compulsory?

Any why should ante-natal care be compulsory when some studies suggest it has no benefit on pregnancy outcome?

The experts appear charge.

In itself this book is of little interest. Its significance is as a practical demonstration of where the Marxism Today strain (euro)communism leads. The much trumpetted claim to be NEW! leads back to surprisingly familiar grounds When the ritual attacks on *the traditional left", , and the pseudoacademic style, are got past. the idless ase am unemarkat he nd stil North Manchester nurses protest. mixture of liberalism and populism.

The references to Marx and Lenin stand out in this milieu. The founding principles of the NHS are hela to be communist by liffe, in that they follow Marx's dictum each according to his need" . But Marx is quietly forgotten after that, as the book goes on to advocate the need to "make different social classes function as one civil society not...hostile interest groups".

For Marx and Engels, however, *it is impossible for us to ally ourselves with people who want to eliminate this class struggle from the movement...The emancipation of the working class must be the work of the working class itself"

It is a strange kind of Marxism which ends up advocating policies which are basically Tory, with a radical gloss.

For example, in the case of feefor-service payments the policies Photo John Smith (Profile) advanced would, in practice, be worse than those currently championed by the Tories. They would achieve the exact opposite of their supposed aim of deprofessionalisation and individual empowerment, creating yet another sphere of professional control over people's well being — the decision as to whether illness is self inflicted or not.

As social conditions. such as housing, unemployment and poverty are as important factors underlying ill-health as "lifestyle" factors, liffe's big stick method of inducing people to take responsibility for their own health - through a tax on getting ill - is merely another way of redistributing misery from the better off to the worse off.

Similarly his proposals regarding compulsory vaccinations, maternity benefit being removed from women who don't attendante-natal clinics, and free dental care only being

----- pull-quotes -----

ly, the larger economic strategy for regeneration requires an incomes

BEING CRIE 15% RiSE FOR FEW 4% FOR MAJORITY THIS IS WRONG

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 373

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →