Putting across the arguments
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
ruggle West Midlands are out. management accept that the strike is solid in Scotland.
Tony Benn calls on the Labour Party leadership to give full backing to the strike. * Tuesday 6th September Strike continues to escalate. 60 out of 80 MLOs now out. At least 75,000 UCW members on strike. It's revealed that the government are using scab haulage firm TNT to distribute benefit cheques. * Wednesday 7th September Tuffin calls for public inquiry into Post Office management. NUR executive urge railworkers not to work with casuals handling scab mail. * Thursday 8th September Strikers at Mount Pleasant in London receive threats from management that unless they sign an agreement to work normally, ie. handle scab mail, they will be spale.
The strike is still spreading. Belfast is now the only MLO still working. Tuffin leaves the TUC to "take control of the strike centre in London".
3 casuals sacked in Chester for tampering with the mail. Secret talks continue between Tuffin's hatchet man Alan Johnson and Bryan Roberts, Personnel Manager, Koyal Mail letters.
Backlog rises to 100 million items. Driver and vehicle licensing centre in Swansea threaten to lay off 1,000 i strike continues.
Labour's frontbench employment spokesperson finally gets round to intervening in the dispute. He writes a letter to Lord Young and Norman Fowler asking them to hold an inquiry into Post Office 77argm-t Friday 9th September Union and management continue secret talks at a secret venue. Post Office talk of ta basis for agreement'. Tuffin talks of "progress".
Meanwhile 2 pickets hospitalised in Liverpool as police attack picket lines. Mass meeting of over 1,000 in Preston votes unanimously to continue the strike. * Saturday 10th September Talks continue. * Sunday 11th September UCW Executive and management working out final details of the deal. Postal service virtually at a standstill. Strike is at its strongest. 150 million item backlog. * Monday 12th September The dirty deal is signed.
Tuffin describes it as a very successful agreement indeed — if not a victory — for the arguments we have been In reality the deal leaves UCW members in a worse situation than before the one-day strike on 31st August. (For details of the deal see article).
* Tuesday 13th September Branches up and down the country vote to stay out. Even in Leeds where workers go back they also pass a vote of no confidence in Tuffin and the Executive.
Branches still out include: Liverpool, Manchester, Preston, Chester, York, Hull, Glasgow, Coventry and London. * Wednesday 14th September More branches go back with local agreements. Great confusion. London District Council can't reach an agreement on a return to work so London stays out.
Liverpool rejects local deal and organises mass picket of local Post Office headquarters. Manchester votes virtually unanimously to continue strike. * Thursday 15th September The strike is weakening. London goes back. Micky Hogan, of the LDC, shrugs his shoulders and tells angry strikers at ECDO: "It's one of those things". Romford, the North West, Newport and Cardiff stay out. Glasgow and Hull also go back. * Friday 16th September 75 out of 80 MIOs are now back. Romford joins them. Royal Mail manager Cockburn attacks the Liverpool UCW branch for "the worst industrial relations record in the industry". Liverpool and the bulk of the North West stand firm. * Saturday 17th September 600 postal workers join the strike in South Wales after suspensions following refusal to handle scab mail redirected from Cardiff and Newport which are still out.
Oldham and Hull vote to go back.
Talks continue in Liverpool and Manchester. Tuffin's hatchetman Alan Johnson takes charge of the negotiations * Monday 19th September Cardiff and Newport go * Tuesday 20th September Mass meeting in Manchester of 1,500 narrowly votes to go back. There is a lot of anger in the meeting at the idea of leaving Liverpool t0 fight alone. Stockport, which already has a deal, also goes back.
Coventry and fice started with the 24 hour strike on September 1st, Socialist Organiser supporters in Manchester have produced seven issues of a strike bulletin for local UCW members.
Over 5,000 copies of the bulletin have been distributed, read and discussed on the picket lines.
At a Socialist Organiser public meeting in the first week of the strike, a Manchester postal worker explained the role of the bulletin: It allows the rank and file to organise and argue how the strike can be won.' Another striker told us on the picket line: "This bulletin is the only thing that tells us what is happening We wouldn't know a thing otherwise. Your bulletin tells the truth?
In the first bulletin we argued for a national strike: 'Our action is spreading, with branches up and down the country bringing their members out. By the end of the weekend more than a third of the UCW's membership in the Post Office nationally had joined the strike.
*The action we're taking is official — our Executive Council have told the press that last Wednesday's action is continuing. But what are they doing to resolve the dispute? Alan Tuffin says it's up to individual managers to sort things out at a local level. Wrong, Alan! These people are just acting under orders from Post Office HQ and behind them the Tory Government.
"Strikers from Liverpool are lobbying the national strike committee on Monday demanding they make the strike national. We agree — pull out every UCW member in the Post Office. If the Executive aren't pepared to do this then we in the branches on strike will have to do it ourselves.
By Friday 9th, when our third bulletin came out, we said the strike was no longer just over casuals: 'Any return-to-work settlement must be put to a mass meeting of those on strike. It must include the removal of all casuals and the scrapping of DRAS and any other schemes that divide up the membership.' Bulletin No.4 warned of the threatened sell-out: "The only reason we can think of for the Exec reluctance to keep us informed is that they're scared of us finding out what they are doing."
It argued for the rank and file to gees ike dancestery that bonCardiff, etc. should take the lead in calling a national meeting of rank and file members to discuss how we are going to do this. Otherwise the Executive will continue to do just as they please, no matter what the views of the membership might be.
Bulletin No.5 was given out at a mass meeting on Wednesday 14th and called for rejection of the deal: *The return-to-work agreement that is before us today is completely unacceptable. We should throw it out. As far as DRAS goes, the 'agreement' leaves us in a worse position than before the strike. Through rank and tile action we've put massive pressure on the Post Office. Yet the Executive want to throw all this away."
It argued how the strike could be kept solid: 'If we do vote to reject the agreement the big danger is that we'll be isolated with other branches going back. To stop that happening we've got to get together with other branches that vote against the deal. We've got to send pickets out to keep the strike solid. No-one goes back till we all do!
*Along with other branches that stay out we should set up a joint Socialist strike committee. We've seen that we can't rely on our Executive -t's time we started to rely on ourselves.
Many of the strikers who spoke it the meeting argued points fron our bulletin. Only six voted to return to work. A motion of 'no confidence' in Alan Tuffin was carried unanimously.!
By Friday 16th, strikers in many other parts of the country had beer orced back to work. In Bulletin No.6 we argued how the strike could still be won: "The branches in the North West have already met once to decide a common line. Those meetings should now be happening every day. Both the management and the Executive would like to see us stuck out on our own. The North West branches must start organising pickets to go to offices outside the region. The message must go out — if we're still out so should they be.' Bulletin No.7 was produced for a meeting on Tuesday 20th. *The only agreement we can expect is one that involves the withdrawal of casuals from both Letters and Parcels, and prevents management diverting mail as and when they please. Even that would only be a victory sorts; the DRAS issue that we first came out over seems to have gone well and truly out the window.
The bulletin explained how the Manchester strike had been left isolated: 'A week ago there were 100,000 of us out on strike. Now, apart from a couple of branches in South Wales, there is only uS, Liverpool and Stockport. The Post Office's plan right from the start was to divide us up.
"The Post Office's plan worked, but only because our Executive Council let it. After the 24 hour strike they should have told management that either we all return to work or none do. They didn't. When the overwhelming majority of branches came out again they should have made the strike national. They didn't.
Then they negotiated a deal that not only gave the Post Office everything they wanted on DRAS, but also gave ground on the issues of casuals and diversions.' We argued again for the striking branches to call a national rank and file meeting.
The mass meeting voted narrowly for a return to work, not defeated, but sold out!
The bulletin Producers in Socialist Organiser supporters Manchester is a model of how socialists can relate to strikes, drawing on the experience of socialists in a number of workplaces throughout the country, who produced fortnightly bulletins for their own. workplaces.
It involved many UCW members (meeting in a pub near the picket line to discuss its contents) and trained socialists outside the Post Office in the ideas and techniques of relating to the day-to-day problems and issues in the strike.
As Bulletin No.6 put it: 'Our strike should be getting the full acive support of the Labour Parts and TUC leaderships - but they've been nowhere. That needs changing the whole labour movement needs shaking up from top to bottom. We need leaders that really are in touch with the grassroots, and a rank and file organised to keep its leaders in check.
*With that sort of labour movement our strike could have been long won by now. And that sort of movement could defeat the Tories, and give a better alternative than any Labour government we ve seen. up to now. That is why Socialist Organiser exists - to work to transform the labour movement so that our struggles can win and so that it can win a real democracy and freedom for ordinary people.
1988
----- pull-quotes -----
By Since the action in the Post Of-