[port on the poll tax drawn up by…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
port on the poll tax drawn up by le Chartered Institute of Public Inance and Accounting, and comissioned to do so by the Scottish ffice, which advised that: "The ublic register will need extensive ipport files including a domestic roperty register, a record of those illy or partially exempt from payent of the community charge and her records."
ate the authority itself, through the I tax, whilst the remaining 80% I be under central government trol.
Adding together the poll tax slation with the rest of the ries' legislation on local governnt, the result will be the effective truction of the latter as a tier of ernment: council services will be ed off, schools will be allowed to t out' , entire housing estates will privatised, the bulk of council nue will be directly controlled the central government and the ers, has summed up the future local government which the des have mapped out: Plans for destruction of local democracy now complete. The governit's tanks are moving into place und every town hall. Battle will mence in the autumn. From I on local government is likely to er a series of blows from which Mill be extremely fortunate to ever. Britain will be more than a centrally managed state, with er concentrated in Whitehall."
If this second file is not computerised it will not be covered by the Data Protection Act. If it is computerised then individuals could still be barred access to it by the local authority claiming that it was a file concerned with the collection of a tax.
The poll tax Registration Officer has a duty, according to the Scottish legislation, to 'take all reasonable steps to obtain such information as is reasonably required by him' in compiling the register. The English legislation does not even include the words 'reasonably required".
Surces of information open to the Registration Officer incude: the electoral register, poll tax reisters compiled by other Registration Officers, local authority services such as the housing and library departments, and local authority records such as records of applications for bus passes, season tickets for local authority tacılities and housing ımprovement grants.
No limit is placed upon the information which local authorities can be obliged to supply to a Registration Officer: would housing departments with information on broken marriages which have necessitated rehousing have to supply this information as it would be relevant to the "joint and several liability' of such couples to pay the poll tax?
Nor are there any real safeguards on the transfer of information between different records. Only computerised information is covered by the Data Information Act and even then a local authority would merely have to declare what kind of information was being transferred rather than record each transferrance of information. And, moreover, even under the Data Protection Act, no record at all of information transfers comening the poll tax would have to be kept if the poll tax were to be comsidered a tax.
The compilation of the poll tax register reprcscnts an infa. upon (civil liberties in other as well. Given that the electoral register is used as a source of information for the poll tax register, anyone seeking to avoid paying the poll tax because of lack of money will have to keep their name off the electoral register. Only those who think they can afford the poll tax will not seek to keep their names off the electoral register where they think it is possible to do so. The poll tax thus constitutes a discouragement from exercising the right to The local canvas carried out on a door-to-door basis is a further infringement of civil liberties. In order to track down 'missing' persons or check up on 'suspect' information, canvassers will conduct personal enquiries amongst neighbours and pursue allegations of avoidance sent in to the Registration Officer anonymously. In its own document on the poll tax, the Rating and Valuation Association itself has declared that 'an expensive and intrusive inspectorate' will be required to track down the 'missing millions'.
The compiltion of poll tax registers by the local authorities would, at least theoretically, mean that the country's entire adult population was recorded on the different registers. The next logical stage, justified on the grounds of 'efficiency' would be to make the data available on the different registers transferrable from one register to another and to establish one nationwide register, to which local authorities could turn to track down poll tax defaulters.
This would be achieved by issuing every adult with a "personal identifier', an encoding of the surname, initials and date of birth. Once that had been are then not only would the basis have been estal blished t card systen the police, or Special Branch, etc., etc.) mould be in a position to monitor the -tact bof ever adult the country ly affected by the tax. In Scotland alone, for example, there are about one million married elderly women classified as non-householders and who will therefore suddenly be confronted with poll tax bills in 1989.
The majority of workers living in tied accommodation as part of their job, and therefore not currently liable to pay rates, are also women. There are currently some 177,000 nannies, au pairs and housekeepers, for example, in Britain. One union survey of workers in hotels and catering found that some 85% of women in the industry were low-paid and that a large percentage of them lived on their employer's premises.
Women workers living in tied accommodation will therefore likewise have to find extra cash for the poll tax. Employers are hardly likely to voluntarily increase pay to make allowance for the tax. And some employers (such as management committees of voluntary sector organisations) simply do not have the resources to do so anyway, due to local authorities passing on central government cuts in public spending.
Women will also be confronted with more strained family relationships as a result of the introduction of the poll tax by the Tories, the party which claims to be the defender of family life.
Ninety per cent of single-parent families are headed by a woman. 70% of single parents dependent on income suport (formerly supplementary benefit) are women. Since income support will not fully cover the poll tax, this will add to the financial problems faced by such families and increase tensions within them.
When children in these families reach the age of 18 and thereby themselves, the result will bell ter become liable for the that financial difficulties and family relations are made even worse or that the children will be forced to leave home to reduce the liability of the parent, as the responsible person" in the household, for poll tax payments.
Similar protius in family life will also occur at the opposite end of the i scale, and again primarily
Scan page 8
nother round of cuts There is a simple rule of thumb to follow for anyone wanting to work out whether they will gain or lose from the poll tax: the richer you are the more you gain, the poorer you are the more you lose.
Research by the Scottish Local Government Information Unit and NALGO found that only in the top income bracket (annual income of £25,000 or more) would a majority gain from the new system. In all other income groups there would be more losers than winners. Among those groups with the most to lose are households with three or more adults, unemployed householders, young householders aged 18-24.
This is because the poll tax is even more regressive than the rates. Under the rating system, on average, a householder with an income of £75-100 a week pays 3.7% of net income in rates, whilst a householder with an income of £300 in mone in rates. nader the polf net the former would pay more (3.9%) whilst the latter less (1.0%).
According to the government figures, 51% of households will gain and 49% will lose. About 15% would gain £2-10 a week, and the same percentage stand to lose the same amount. The government has also admitted, however, that 3 million households might face an increase of more than 50% in their local tax bills...and 1.8 million might face an increase of 80% or I In fact, the government's figures, not unusually, underestimate the number of losers. Translated into figures on individuals rather than households, 44% will gain and 56% will lose, and the number of large losers (8.3 million people) far outweighs the number of large gainers (5.2 million).
Official government estimates of the level of poll tax in different areas are open to an equally broad range of objections. The poll tax Since 1979 the Tories have repeatedly cut back the central government funding of local authority spending which, in turn, given the failure of local authorities to offer any effective resistance, has led to cutbacks in the provision of local authority services.
There have been 12 major changes in the Rate Support Grant system since 1979. The cuts in Rate Support Grant add up to a cumulative total of £22 billion. The proportion of local authority spenfigure estimated for Edinburgh by the Scottish Office, for example, is based on the assumption that every single adult in Edinburgh will be nable for the tax, will be included on the poll tax register and will end up actually paying the tax, whilst ignoring the impact on the poll tax of the replacement of non-domestic rates by a Uniform Business Rate.
Moreover, it is not just a question of how many 'winners and losers' but also of which people will be gaining or losing and how much. Viewed from this angle the nature of the poll tax as a mechanism for a redistribution of wealth to the already Wealthy becomes self-evident.
The Thatchers, who will pay rates of £61.75 per week on their retirement home replaced by a poll tax of ding funded by central government has falled from 66.5% in 1975 to Nor have the cuts become less severe over the years. On the contrary, as the Tories have become more confident, the size of the cuts has increased correspondingly. In Scotland, for example, clawbacks of Rate Support Grant of £27 million were carried out in 1981/82 and 1982/83. By 1984/5 and £17 per week, or Lord Vesty, gaining €5,000 a year from the introduction of the poll tax, are the kind of people who will be gaining — a lot. The two-adult working class family in Doncaster who will be faced with a poll tax bill twice the size of their rates bill are the kind of people who will be losing - a lot.
Losers from the replacement of rates by the poll tax are concentrated amongst those on low incomes. 60% of two-adult families with incomes of below f200 will end up worse off. Pensioner couples losing out from the poll tax outweigh those who stand to gain: 14% will lose up to 2% of their net income and another 10% more than 2% of their net income; only 3% of pensioners will see a rise in their net income of more than 2%. 1985/86 the clawbacks had increased to £90 million and £126.5 million respectively. By 1987/88 the Tories were threatening a clawback ot £202 million, unless councils cut their own spending 'voluntarily"
In central government subsidies for council housing it has been the same story; central government funding has fallen from 41.2% in Soctland in 1979 to 6.1% today and local government funding (restricted by an Act of Parliament) has fallen from 14.1% to 5.7%. Unemployed adults of preretirement age will also lose out heavily, though exact figures are not yet available.
In properties of average rateable value, a one-adult household stands to gain. Households of two adults or more will lose, with the loss increasing in proportion to the number of adults. In properties of low rateable value even one-adult households will end up worse off, and so will every other size ot household in such properties. Only in properties with medium rateable values (unless there is a large adult household) and high rateable values is there even a possibility of any household gaining from the poll tax — at the expense of those in lowrated properties.
On a regional basis, the poll Whereas in 1979 council house rents provided 44.1% of expenditure on council housing, this has now increased to 83.2%.
The total Housing Support Grant paid out to councils in Scotland fell from £371.4 million in 1979/80 to £46.5 million in 1987/88. In 1982 all cuncils in Scotland were in receipt of Housing Support Grant, however small an amount. Since then the number receiving none at all has steadily grown: 11 councils in 1982/83, 26 in 1984/85 and 34 in 1986/87. will see a shift in the burden of local taxation away from the South towards the North, Yorkshire and Humberside. The North will see the average local tax bill rise by 31%, the South will see it fall by 23%. 49 out of 50 councils faced with the biggest increases are either in Inner London or north of a line from the Severn to the Trent. Almost all the authorities to benefit from the poll tax are in the prosperous South.
Within the different regions there will also be a further differentiation between rich and poor. In Edinburgh, for example, the seven wealthiest district council wards will benefit from the poll tax, whilst the other 55 will lose out. In Strathclyde region, wealthy areas such as Bearden, Milngavie and Eastwood will make huge per capita gains, whilst poorer areas such as Glasgow, Clydebank and Motherwell will lose out badly.
Further inequalities will result from the centralised collection of the Uniform National Business Rate and its re-distribution according to how many people live in a given area. Many urban authorities will lose hundreds of millions of pounds of their income whilst industry-tree Tory commuter zones can expect to see more money pumped in their direction. In Nottingham, for example, the new system would see income from nondomestic rates fall by £13 million, necessitating an extra pound per week on the personal poll tax.
In general, people living in Scotland, Wales the North and North West in the regions with the highest levels of unemployment, will pay more, whilst people who are already well off and living in the South East can expect to gain. Inner cities, especially London, will be particularly hard hit: even single adults and people in higher rateable property in London will lose out from the introduction of the poll tax.
countancy, a 1% increase in council spending would necessitate a poll tax incrase of up to 4%, whilst large increases in spending would, because of the so-called 'multiplier effect' , demand even more disproportionately large increases in the poll tax; * if a council increased spending by 5% to cover actual costs (ie. to maintain the same level of services) but the government increased its funding by only 3% (either because of underestimating the rate of inflation or because of a deliberate cut in
----- pull-quotes -----
ninder indirectly controlled. he Financial Times, of all