Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tory Lies!

Socialist Organiser no. 372, 22 September 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 1,227 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

10 pence if sold separately The poll tax will make councils more accountable. The Tories argue that only a limited proportion of users of council services pay the rates which help finance those services. In Scotland, for example, there is an electorate of 3.9 million, but only 1.9 million of the electorate are householders and thereby liable to pay rates. As the poll tax will be paid by the entire adult electorate, it will therefore make councils more accountable.

But, by this logic, MPs are not accountable either: only half of Scotland's adult population, for example, pays income tax, which helps finance central government spending in the same way that the poll tax helps finance local government spending.

It is also factually inaccurate to claim that only householders pay rates. Many of the 2 million nonhouseholders in Scotland are spouses of ratepayers and organise their finances jointly.

The introduction of the poll tax will in fact mean more central government control over local authorities and consequently less accountability of the latter to the local electorate: not only will the government retain powers to order a cut in the poll tax charged by councils (just as it can at present order a cut in rates), but the abolition of non-domestic rates and replacement of them by a Uniform National Business Rate set and collected by the government will also reduce local authority control over their own budget.

Moreover, given that the electoral register is one source of information for compilation of the poll tax register, the poll tax will act as a disincentive to exercise a limited degree of accountability through voting. Those forced through economic hardship to try to avoid the poll tax will have to ensure that their name is not on the electoral register and will consequently disenfranchise themselves.

Claimants will receive extra benefits to cover the poll tax. Either this is a lie or it makes nonsense of Tories' claims about the poll tax increasing the accountability of concils: if claimants were to receive the full cost of the poll tax in their benefits then, by the Tories' logic, they would be indifferent to the level of council spending.

The Tories attaim that income support will be increased so that claimants can pay the 20% of the poll tax which they will have to pay up from out of their fortnightly giro. But the figure which the Tories will fix as 20% of the tax will be 20% of the average poll tax nationally. So claimants in areas with above average poll taxes (ie. areas where council expenditure is higher due to above average levels of hardship) will automatically lose out.

Claimants in areas with average or below average poll taxes will also be worse off. Whilst the Tories might add on a certain amount to income support to cover 20% of the poll tax, the overall level of benefits is being cut. In 1988, for example, the Tories claimed that they had included the amount required by claimants to pay 20% of their domestic rates in income support allowances. At the same time, though, it cut the overall level of income support and slashed housing benefit. It is clearly nonsense to claim that claimants will receive compensation for the 20% of the poll tax they will have to pay whilst at the same time cutting the overall benefit level.

The poll tax will stop high spending by councils. According to Nicholas Ridley, "The Labour Party in local government, especially the extremists, always over-bid others in their promises to spend, spend spend... (and use) ill-concealed bribes in the form of higher spending and higher subsidies for those who do not have to pay the bills. The Tories argue that the poll tax will enable voters to see more clearly which councils are guilty of 'excessive' expenditure.

In fact, the 'high-spending council' is a Tory myth. In Scotland, overall annual expenditure by local authorities has declined by 0.95% since the Tories came to power. The Tories own Green Paper, Paying for Local Government, declared: *Spending in Scotland has been held virtually constant in volume terms.

Rates have certainly increased in the same period. But this is due to cuts in central government funding, not to 'profligate' spending by councils. If the Tories were to restore all cuts in funding made since 1979 then the entire population could be given a year free of rates entirely.

Moreover, even if councils were "guilty' of high spending' (ie. providing services which people need), then the democratic mechanism to put a check on them would be the ballot box. In fact, though, the Tories will be using their dictatorial poll tax-capping powers to reduce the spending of councils elected with a democratic mandate to carry out such spending.

The poll tax is an improvement on the current rating system. The current rating system certainly has its faults, But the poll tax is a negation Moreover, as has already been noted, the poll tax will not improve local authority accountability either partly because of the powers of central government intervention or partly because the Tories deliberately underestimate the numbers of those who help pay the rates under the existing system.

Finally, it is worth noting the spurious nature of the Tories' favourite example of why a poll tax would supposedly be a great improvement on the rating system: that it would end the situation of a widowed pensioner paying the same rates as the family of four wage earners next door.

Only 9% of the population live in single-person households. At most only 5% of the population are single pensioners living alone. Since rates attract Housing Benefit according to income, there are no single, elderly householders on low income who actually pay full rates. And only 9% of the population live in households of three or more working adults. In the majority of such cases the 'additional' wage earners are usually young people who soon move out to become householders themselves.

Replacing the rating system with the poll tax will be good for business. Socialists certainly have no brief to defend business interests. On the contrary, their job is to fight for an end to private ownership of the means of production. It is worth noting in passing, however, that this alleged virtue of the poll tax is surrounded by a series of Tory myths.

Research carried out by the Department of the Environment revealed that there was no direct link between the level of nondomestic rates and decisions on business location and employment, due to the fact that the rates bill constituted such a small proportion of overall turnover.

In fact, council spending, financed out of the rates, benefitted business in a number of ways: providing essential services, purchasing goods and services, increased consumption from out of the wages paid by the council to its employees, etc.

Moreover, the introduction of a Uniform National Business Rate will mean increased bills for businesses located in areas which are now relatively low rated. And since rateable values would remain different in different areas, the introduction of a Uniform National Business Rate would not result in equal rates payments for similar premises.

Hence the opposition to the Tories' proposals from, amongst others, the Forum of Private Business and the National Federation of Self-Employed and Small Businesses.

----- pull-quotes -----

POLI TAX

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 372

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →