Burmese coup d'etat
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Burmese Housewives Committee protesting against the Socialist Organiser no.372 22 September 1988 Page 2 Jinglees are sharpened bicycle spokes shot by catapults. They are among the improvised weapons used by Burmese demonstrators against the 'socialist' army. Such weapons are a necessity, as the Burmese army, reeling from crisis to crisis, mows down its opponents in the streets.
At least 100 people, possibly a lot more, were killed on Monday (September 19) in the latest round of violence following a coup d'etat that brought the army to power. Thousands have died since the country's dictator for 26 years, Ne Win, "retired" at the end of July. awkward questions. Since 1982, following his general approach, Militant's Ted Grant has proclaimed Burma to be a 'deformed workers' state'. Capitalism, they said, was overthrown by Ne Win— but instead of socialism, bureaucratic rule was imposed on the Russian model.
Was this system better than capitalism or not? Did it develop the forces of production more than capitalism? Was it closer to socialism than capitalism was? In Grant's theory, whatever the undeniable facts of a crippling lack of democracy in these societies, a planned economy - even a mismanaged one — was unquestionably superior to capitalism. The creation of a 'deformed workers' state' was, for Grant, historically progressive.
Yet Pat Craven, writing in Milicant (19 August 1988) proclaims:
"Despite the advantages of having a nationalised economy, the ruling military bureaucracy has proved that it is impossible to develop a backward economy in isolation and without democratic control and management by the workers"
Moreover, "it cannot be entirely ruled out that, theoretically, for the first time, a proletarian bonapartist deformed workers' state could revert back to capitalism and landlordism?!. And if it did so, Women's refuges are likely to be the next victims of the government's social security changes.
For many women who make the break from violent relationships, a women's refuge is the only place to go. On average around 20,000 women and children a year find safety in a refuge.
But their existence has become more precarious over the years. They have never received statutory funding, managing on local authority grants. As the çuts bite. so nonstatutory grant lost.
A fairly secure source of income has been from the DHSS. As refuges clearly provide 'care for women and children, they have received money from the DHSS for 'board and lodging'.
But the DHSS has changed its mind. In contradiction to research which the Ministry itself commissioned, and which found a high standard of care in most refuges, the DHSS has said that refuges provide no care at all.
So women in refuges The military coup is the third change in government since then. But Ne Win is still the power behind the throne. The army remains loyal to him.
But the cracks are showing. Hundreds of soldiers have joined antiregime demonstrations over the past few weeks.
Can the regime survive? The canital. Rangoon has heen torn apart by an escalation cycle of violence. In other cities, many have Lost their lives.
The barricades are up in Rangoon. Government employees are on general strike. Demonstrations are smaller than a week ago. «This wold he a far worse *This would be a far worse catastrophe for the workers and peasants" than any bad thing happening now.
But how can this be? Why is this "workers' state' progressive, if the workers have no power and the economy has failed to develop?
Militant's traditional criterea for "progressiveness' are demonstrably false in Burma, but they make no effort to rethink their theory.
'Reversion' to capitalism would be a 'catastrophe'. But here also is a problem. If Burma now — with all its deformations - is an advance on capitalism, surely socialists should oppose a 'reversion' - and oppose those forces fighting for it?
Why don't the Militant applaud the army of the workers' state beating down the pro-capitalist opposition? Why don't they call for defense of the nationalised property? Maybe Militant's instincts to be with the demonstrators are sounder than their theoretical skills. But surely the theory is gaping open with holes?
In fact it is bizarre to describe Burma as a workers' state. Socialist Organiser has always thought so, even before we considered the label to be questionable when applied to the USSR. But the oddities of Militant's theory do perhaps expose some of the problems with the label even in more subtle versions.
What Militant call a 'deformed workers' state' they describe as a new, progressive, form of class society. Except in Burma they have had to face facts.
will have to claim in come support and housing benefit, leaving refuges even more short of cash.
Jobs will be lost, and standards of support for women and children will fall. A quarter of all refuges get three quarters of their funding from board and lodging.
They may face closure.
Refuges have acted as a safety net for inadequately funded social services and housing.
Now the government seems quite happy to let them die - after all, family life is the most important thing, isn't it.
but the opposition shows no real signs of weakening. The slaughter following the latest coup has staved off the threat from below to the regime - but it has not abolished it.
Ne Win's Socialist Programme Party took power in a coup in 1962.
As in many Third World countries, a viciously repressive and economically-nationalist regime adopted the rhetoric of 'socialism'.
26 vears on. the economv is in tatters - even compared to nearby Thailand or Malaysia - and the regime has utterly lost control.
The oppostion's cheif demand has been for democracy and since July has shown increasing confidence. Whe former President FOS government State approved Is Gorbachev getting cold feet about glasnost?
On 28th July a decree was issued by the Praesidium of the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Federation banning all demonstrations not registered 10 days in advance, and approved by the powers that be.
A day later another decree was adopted which has only now been made public. It introduces strict penalties for people organising or taking part in unauthorised protests.
Under the new scheme anyone taking part in an unauthorised gathering can be fined as much as Teacher training Four out of every ten newly qualified teachers are not taking-up jobs in the profession.
Every year around 5,500 teachers completing their training are deciding to take jobs elsewhere.
Low pay is likely to be a Maung Maung offered general elections, this was rejected as inadequate: they wanted the government to resign and allow the formation of an alternative interim administration.
There are no major organised groups among the oppositions, although this feature is often exaggerated by it spokespeople. In its demands and rhetoric there is perhaps a similarity with the people's power' movement that overthrew Marcos in the Philippines and the democracy movement in South Korea. Students have spearheaded the street demostrations. The overall ideological tone of the opposition is moderate and Continued And it mustn't stop, whatever the outcome. Whatever the outcome, we have to carry on the campaign for socialism. And we have to carry on that campaign by organising.
I don't believe that organisation in itself solves all the problems. I know there are some comrades who think that when you get into a difficult political situation, if you only organise differently the political situation would change.
I don't believe you can divorce organisation from politics. If we had the right politics in this party at the moment, we would actually be conducting that political fight. We wouldn't be too worried about organisation. We wouldn't need to be. It's because the Party's got the wrong politics, because the leadership is organising to keep the lett wing down, that we have to fight back.
I'll conclude on this. From time to time, every movement has to rebuild itself. If it doesn't it dies. And we're at this stage now.
We've seen retreat after retreat after retreat. The Policy Review shows that the leadership is retreating even further. They've accepted the concept of capitalism.
We must fight back, not turning to the past, but creating the future. Surely that's what we're all about. We are the ones who are the future. They want to go back to old policies, which haven't worked and which cannot work. We're the one who have the vision of changing society, of creating that new society of building socialism. That's what our forefathers and foremothers in this movement started off with -that vision to change society. Our job is to carry on their work - to ensure that we bring our black comrades into the movement, make certain women comrades have their rights in every way, that there is no discrimination against gays and lesbians, that working people as a whole get the fruits of their labour. That's what it's about. Comrades, let's go from this conference determined to make a further step to build socialism.
Learn the
----- pull-quotes -----
For the "Militant' tendency, events in Burma present
CRA Women's refuges
pro-capitalist. rank and file speak out!