Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Get your copy Socialist Organiser no.371 15 September…]

Socialist Organiser no. 371, 15 September 1988 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,299 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Get your copy Socialist Organiser no.371 15 September 1988 Page 8 Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism.

We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.

Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles world-wide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalitiesin the Stalinist states against their own Ulster cops did shoot to kill The Tories needed to keep pressure on the NEC. We won't go back to work till all the offices in S.E. London have got adequate return to work agreements. And we won't handle any mail redirected from offices in dispute.?

Scan page 9

HAUSKEVSE DUDEN The last 40 years A number of facts are unmistakable from the evidence of the Last 40 years, central to clear assessment of the struggles in the Eastern Bloc, yet obscured by or difficult to reconcile with the "deformed and degenerated workers' states" codification.

1. The position of the working class in the command economies is generally worse than in the market economies. Low rents and food prices, and fairly full employment, do make the poorest in the Eastern Bloc better off than the poorest in he West. Yet average working-class iving standards are lower, even at he same level of general industrial development.

Work conditions, despite the luggish pace of work in many Eastern Bloc factories much of the ime, are worse. And — centrally -he ruling bureaucracies repress all ndependent organisation by the vorking class.

South Korea is a society based on uthless exploitation and brutal epression: yet it has allowed some penings for trade unions to levelop against the odds. North Corea has allowed no such openTrotskyists have let the goal of working-class self-liberation be obscured by the goal of national economic development, because that national economic development is where the "workers' states" are supposed to display their superiority over market capitalism. Some command economies have indeed developed industry fast.

But so - since 1945 — have many market economies. The command economies can certainly show no general, clear superiority over the market economies in developing the forces of production. Indeed relative stagnation in the USSR and Eastern Europe is now the starting point for Gorbachev's reforms.

The command economies are not a stage beyond capitalism in developing the productive forces. Rather, they have emerged from underdeveloped capitalist societies with a big load of pre-capitalist or colonialist dross, and done broadly the same work as capitalist development.

A cooperative commonwealth — a nationalised economy planned under workers' democracy - will produce more efficiently and distribute more equally than any market economy ever can. We have have been stably self-reproducing organisms. If we do not call them "ruling classes", it can only be on a technicality.

Although sometimes when in power the bureaucracies seek to recruit individuals from the working class, the core of these bureaucracies is certainly not a segment or a product of the working class. They come from the middle class. Perhaps nowhere is this seen more plainly than in Afghanistan, where a very large part of the middle class military and technical intelligentsia tried, in the 1978 coup and after, to transform themselves into a bureaucracy on the USSR model.

Trotsky spoke of the Kremlin bureaucracy as balancing between its social and economic base and the pressure of capitalist imperialism. Such a view is no longer tenable.

The USSR is the second world power. In Vietnam, China and elsewhere the bureaucratised revolutionary forces were able to defeat the old order and beat down the working class simultaneously. Even while they were revolutionary against the old order, they were simultaneously counterrevolutionary against the working castes, medieval estates and classes"

Today the USSR has in Eastern Europe an empire with over 100 million people. You can deny that the USSk is imperialism only by saying that imperialism is only the form of monopoly-capitalist imperialism described by Lenin, and nothing else. And that would be to deny the existence of the Athenian and Roman, the Spanish and Ottoman empires, or indeed of the British Empire for all but 70 or so years of its 300-year life.

The conflict between the US and the USSR is chiefly about competition for spheres of influence and control, rather than a dispute of market economy versus nationalised economy.

Pessimism?

One other fact of the last 40 years puts things in a different light. In the 1930s Trotsky saw capitalism in an impasse. The productive forces had ceased to grow. The working class had ceased to grow, and was being eroded by mass unemployment. The USSR, however, was developing. Call the USSR a new exploiting society, and you said that the contradictions of capitalism led not to socialism but to that new form of exploitation.

Since 1945 capitalism has grown enormously - faster than ever before. The working class has greatly expanded. Dozens of new countries have industrialised. Seen from the perspective of 1988, the USSR's growth in the 1930s looks not like a bold stride beyond capitalism, but like something essentially parallel to the industrial growth of Japan in the same period, of several Latin American economies in the '30s and "40s, and of many Third World countries since 1945.

In the first place, this makes nonsense of the idea that "deformed workers' states" develop because of the utter impasse, decay and collapse of capitalism. Look at South Korea, Taiwan, Malaysia and Thailand, and it is hard to argue that China, Vietnam and North Korea could not have developed any further on a market-capitalist basis.

In the second place, it does away with the argument that to call the Eastern Bloc new exploiting societies is to commit ourselves to pessimism about the prospect for socialism, or to abandon it altogether. Whatever we call the Eastern Bloc, we have lived through 40 years of expanding capitalism. A "new exploiting society" may have grown - but the numbers and potential of the working class have grown also.

Post-1951 Trotskyism In the polemics gathered together in the book In Defence of Marxism Trotsky insisted that the discussion on the class nature of the USSR could not be about labels only. It was and had to be essentially about the perspectives implied in the different name-tags.

On the level of name-tags, the post-1951 Trotskyists were extending Trotsky's theory of the USSR — as a degenerated workers' state in which the bureaucracy was in agonising contradiction with the nationalised means of production -to new "deformed workers" states". This did not square with the facts. The post-1951 Trotskyists tried to ignore or define away many facts; but the facts took their revenge.

The post-1951 Trotskyists retained Trotsky's name-tag. But in fact they threw out his theory and perspective. Under the name-tag, what they described was a new form of society in which the nationalised economy was the creation of the bureaucracy. The bureaucracies -this wouid come through unmistakably despite efforts to present them, or some of them, as segments of the working class -were essentially new ruling classes. And they had the mission of developing backward countries for a whole historical period.

The "orthodox Trotskyists" who continued to mouth Trotsky's formula about the degenerated workers' state were actually describing the sort of new Turn to page 10

----- pull-quotes -----

Britains death squad exposed!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 371

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →