Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A test case

Socialist Organiser no. 371, 15 September 1988 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,887 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

This dispute is a test case and Tuffin has failed the test. Management is just probing us in this dispute; for instance they don't have an effective scab system worked out. They want to see how the union will react.

They must be happy because Tuffin has backed down. Now management will be preparing to come in harder, and next time they come for us they'll probably have a well-prepared scabbing operation and therefore they will be harder to beat.

The situation is like in 1982, when the South Yorkshire miners forced the Tories to retreat. This was possible because the Tories didn't have all their strike-breaking machinery in place. But in '84, when the Tories went looking for a fight, they did have their squads of riot police, anti-union laws and stockpiles of coal. So they provoked the miners, and went in for the kill.

The leaders of the labour movement just stood back and watched.

If the miners had fought earlier, as Arthur Scargill had argued, perhaps the defeat of 1984-5 could have been avoided.

Tuffin has done the opposite of Scargill. Postal workers want to fight now, but the union leadership have stabbed them in the back. Post Office management can now prepare for the battles of the future with more confidence. Militant-sponsored resolution that a minimum condition for a return to work should be a £20 across the board increase!

The meeting also went on for two hours before the dispute was discussed.

Even if the meeting had been better, however, 60 people isn't enough. We need hundreds if we are going to bring the Executive under the control of the members.

Casuals Half the casuals working at Mount Pleasant sorting office in London refused to cross the UCW picket lin last week.

The strikers spoke to the casuals, plaining the issues, and produced a leaflet arguing their case.

Scan page 6

Union leaders like Willis and Tuffin live in a different world from ordinary union members Gerry Question: What does *talks without pre-conditions"

mean to Alan Tuffin?

Answer: It means he can give away as much as he wants without pre-conditions.

This may sound like a sick joke, but sadly, it's a fair picture of postal workers' leader Alan Tuffin.

The question that comes to mind is how come such a shabby character can get to become the leader of a union?

Part of the answer to this question can be found by turning to the pages of last Friday's "Independent".

There we can find a profile of Tuffin ('A misunderstood mirror image of Arthur Scargill') by one Barrie Clement.

Unlike Scargill — who is universally hated by what we used to call Fleet Street - Tuffin gets a good press; well at least from the quality end of the market. Clement writes:

*The 'Postman Pat' tag hung on him by one paper during a strike over working hours before last Christmas was unfair. It was Mr Tuffin's discreet discussion with Sir Bryan Nicholson, the Post Office chairman that brought about the tinal settlement.

Almost certainly it will be Mr Tuffin's confidential conversations with Sir Bryan on this occasion -over the head of Royal Mail management — which will help to smooth the way to industrial peace...

His skill as a negotiator and his realisation of the realities of commercial life should mean that the present dispute will not develop into a life or death battle like the miner's strike."

So Tuffin has all the qualities for a top trade union official according to Fleet St: he likes backroom stitchups and understands 'the commercial life'. Now 'the realities of commercial life' is one of those strange phrases adopted by our rulers to disguise a cruder point. What they really mean is fuffin understands that the bosses have got to make a profit and the union can't stand in the way of that.

Tuffin is the kind of trade union leader that management like. He accepts the rules of the game as they lay them down.

Though he comes from the working class (Tuffin joined the Post Office as a telegram boy straight from secondary school at the age of 16) he stands between the workers and management. He sees his role as a duel one. He tries to do two different things at the same time. He is forced. to defend 'my members" while at the same time attempting to limit the demands of the rank and file to the horizons set by management according to that magic formula 'commercial realities' Now in some conditions skilful trade union officials can get away with this. In conditions of boom and expansion trade unions can win major concessions out of the employers. But, unfortunately for Alan Tuffin, the 1980s are not years of boom and expansion, and Post Office management want to modernise the industrv bv screwine as realities of much as possible out of the workforce. As one Liverpool postal worker put it:

*In car industry terms we are faced with speed ups, and Post Office management is squeezing us more and more.

They admit that the mail has gone up 25% in the last five years. With productivity deals there has been an increased pressure on the workers.

Something like 80% of the Post Office costs go on wages: hence the attack on wages and conditions"

In conditions like this Tuffin is forced to make some stark choices. He is faced with a militant and angry rank and file on the one hand who want to see some action and a determined management on the other who want see him face up to, yes you've guessed it, 'commercial realities' In this kind of situation Tuffin can loose control. The Financial Times put it quite well:

*The Union of Communication Workers Executive Council will today attempt to answer a key question which the postal strike has raised for it: who is running the dispute, the union's leadership or the rank and file?"

The same Liverpool postal worker that we quoted earlier made a similar point:

The Post Office is even beginning to sound like the old port employers, complaining about 'wildcat' strikes. They make agreements with the national officials, which then get overturned by delegates and the shop floor. In the Post Office the bosses have got a union leadership that cannot deliver."

In cooking up the present sell-out deal Tuffin has been at least as worried about how to bring the rank and file of the union under some kind of control as he has been to force concessions out of management.

He has to prove he can deliver".

In fact if anything the present *agreement' looks like a deal between management and the national union leadership to pull the militant branches of the union into line.

Tuffin has described the deal as a success but really he's been about as "successful" in the present negotiations as Sebastian Coe is likely to be in the Seoul Olympics!

Here's some food for thought for those strikers who've been on the picket lines for the last 12 days.

While you stand firm without strike pay your leader — sure of his salary because he hasn't declared a national strike — was enjoying the good life.

As the Independent put it:

"The conflict has not prevented Mr Tuffin from spending most of the week at Bournemouth... He plays squash and swims to ease the tension! It's good to relax, because otherwise tempers can become frayed'.

So Tuffin relaxes whilst his members fight. Well, he can afford to, the UCW general secretary receives a wage of at least £35,000 a year (the same as the salary of a District Head Postmaster).

Unfortunately, he's not so keen to protect the standard of living of ordinary postal workers.

Under the last deal Tuffin negotiated some postal workers lost as much as f50 a week. Tuffin didn't start off in life to be such a scoundral. But over time, the habits, the routine, the lifestyle of a modern trade union leader can bend and shape even the best individuals. Union leaders start to behave and think like the managers who they spend more and more of their time with. Their first loyality becomes the union machine from which they derive their status, position and livelihood - rather than the flesh and blood human beings who make up the union in the real world.

Even principled left wingers can become right wing bureaucrats if they take up positions and responsibilities in the union machine without possessing clear political ideas or without being willing to subject themselves to rank and file For instance during the Basingstoke postal workers strike of 1983 over the victimisation of Socialist Organiser supporters and UCW branch official Alan Fraser it was officials with a left reputation John Taylor and Gerry Casey who broke the strike.

So how do we stop this happening? How can the rank and file take control of the union?

The first step is for the rank and file to organise and campaign for democracy and fighting policies in the union.

All oficials should be elected for definite terms (no more than two years) - Tuffin-is elected for five. And all officials should be subject to recall at any time. Full time officials should be paid the average wage in their industry.

Union policy making bodies and delegations to the TUC and Labour Party should be made up of elected lay members only.

It's important for the left to challenge for the leadership of the union. There is nothing inevitable about left officials moving right it depends on the extent the rank and file can control these officials and on their having a clear political commitment to fighting for the in terests of working class people. Pickets confront pa WO I'll never forget that day we got our own back: me and Hyacinth on the walks next door to each other. For some reason all the blokes used to grab Hyacinth. All the women got their share of bum-pinching and breastgrabbing, except those of us who fought back. But Hyacinth seemed to cop for the lot. Perhaps because she let them get away with it. They used to make you feel like, if you didn't go along with it, you were a prude or a kill-joy — "can't take a joke". Hyacinth didn't want that saying about her. So she blushed and giggled and struggled. But she never said, "Divide and rule" is the motto behind the Tory Government's drive for privatisation.

Through privatisation they can chop up big. public-sector strongholds of trade unionism into separate enterprises with separate employers and separate negotiations.

Tory anti-union law will then ban workers in those separate enterprises from actively supporting each other. Sectors that the Tories want to cut back can be isolated and exposed to the cutting edge of the The first steps in privatising a public enterprise are to squeeze up profitability - so that it will be saleable - and to chop it up into separate sectors which can then become separate private enterprises.

The Tories have already taken those first steps with the Post Office. Work rates have been speeded up and wages squeezed so that it is now the most profitable postal service in the world.

----- pull-quotes -----

leaders how to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 371

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →