Reassessing the
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
The most common idea on the left is that the USSR and the East European states it controls are some sort of socialist societies.
We, however, don't think so — never have. We have subscribed to the so-called 'orthodox Trotskyist" notion that the Stalinist states are best categorised as "degenerated and deformed workers' states" -far from socialism because of their bureaucratic regimes, but an advance on capitalism because of their nationalised economies.
We have long said that the *degenerated and deformed workers' states" formula was unsatistactory. By now, most supporters of Socialist Organiser no longer believe that the designation "workers' state" - degenerated, deformed, or whatever - makes any sort of sense.
The paper's National Editorial Board voted last Sunday to review our nominal adherence to that formula, and to open a discussion in the paper on the Eastern Bloc states. This editorial explains why. Our programme We are for workers' liberty East and West. We are for working-class self-liberation East and West. We are with the workers when they demand the right to organise and speak freely, the right to freedom for individuals and for nationalities, and the right to control economic affairs - East and West. We are with the workers when they fight for wages and conditions -East and West.
We are therefore with Solidarnosc - for its right to operate and its fight for the wages, conditions, and liberties of its members -against Poland's rulers. We are with Solidarnosc even when, as at present, its leaders call for a market economy.
The official trade-union organisations in the Eastern bloc are not real workers' unions. They are agencies of the factory managements and the government. We are therefore for trade unions in other countries breaking links with those state unions, and establishing links instead with Solidarnosc in Poland and the pioneer free trade union groups elsewhere.
We are for the democratic right to self-determination of nations, as the only basis for international workers' unity. In accord with that 80p Second edition March 1987 A Workers' Liberty pamphlet This pamphlet contains an count of the events which preceded the USSR's invasion of Afghanistan in December 1979 and a detailed examinatio of the 'Workers' State' theory o Militant which supported the Russian occupation. principle, we have opposed the USSR's military occupation of We are for: • Disbandment of the police and armed forces, and their replacement by a people's militia. • Breaking up the bureaucratic hierarchy of administration, and replacing it with a democratic regime of councils of elected and recallable workers' delegates, with freedom to form many political parties. • Workers' control in industry. Free trade unions. • Abolition of bureaucratic privileges; reorganisation of the economy according to a democratically-decided plan. • Abolition of the bureaucracy's monopoly over information; freedom for working-class newspapers, meetings, radio and TV stations, etc.
We are for nationalisation of the major means of production. But what exists now in the Eastern Bloc is no form of socialism. Nationalisation is a means to an end — working-class liberation from the economic exploitation of those who control the means of production That is not achieved when the nationalised economy and the monopolising state are in effect the property of a ruling elite whose upper layers lord it over society as the aristocrats and capitalists do elsewhere.
We advocate the replacement of the system of nationalised economy under a state-monopoly bureaucracy with a socialised economy under the democratic control of the working class.
Trotsky's approach All these positions follow from our basic goal of working-class self-liberation, and our belief - based on the evidence of the Russian Revolution of 1917, France 1968, Portugal 1974-5, Hungary 1956, Poland 1980-1, and many other struggles - that the working class can liberate itself and reconstruct society on socialist lines.
None of these positions depends OH, is affected by, precise sociological definitions of the states with nationalised economies and structures similar to the USSR's. Whatever progressive significance we attach to the fact of nationalised property — even if it is a large one — it cannot outweigh our allegiance to the living struggles of the working class.
In taking this approach, we follow Trotsky. "The primary political criterion for us is not the transformation of property relations in this or another area, however important these may be in themselves, but rather the change in the consciousness and organisation of the world proletariat, the raising of their capacity for defending former conquests and accomplishing new ones...
The statification of the means of production is, as we said, a progressivenes is relative: Is specto He bue. its proweight depends on the sum-total of all the other factors.
Thus, we must first and foremost establish that the extension of the territory dominated by bureaucratic autocracy and parasitism, cloaked by 'socialist' measures, can augment the prestige of the Kremlin, engender illusions concerning the possibility of replacing the proletarian revolution by bureaucratic manoeuvres, and so on. This evil by far outweighs the progressive content of Stalinist reforms...
In order that nationalised properly in the occupied areas, as well as in the USSR, become a basis for genuinely progressive, that is to say socialist levelopment it is necessary to overthrow the Moscow bureaucracy"
We also follow the Trotskyist movement of 1948.
"It will be necessary to continue this revolutionary class struggle consistently and uninterruptedly in the case of the occupation of any given country by the Russian army, even though the revolutionary forces clash with the Russian army, and also in spite of the military consequences which this might entail for the Russian army in its operations against the imperialist military forces. In any case, the use of military means remains subordinated to the necessities of the revolutionary class struggle of the proletariat in whatever countries it may be. Thus, our defence of the USSR remains identical in all cases with the continuation of the revolutionary class struggle..." "Deformed workers' states"' After 1948 the Trotskyist movement went off the rails. It lost its the agency of socialist instead Politics. clear focus on the working class as Often it looked •LO raguely-defined process of worl revolution'. Vorking-class actior was desirable for this process to go forward rapidly and healthily but the world revolution could very well progress without or despite the working class.
Undeniably, this wavering of focus accompanied the Trotskyists' codification of a new analysis of the Eastern Bloc states, as "degenerated and deformed workers' states". We have accepted that codification, but dissented from the conclusions that most of its adherents have drawn from it.
Trotsky, right up to his death, "degenerated workers' state"s He regarded the USSR a considered that its nationalised and planned economy, created by the workers' revolution, defined it as a form of workers' state - a society beyond capitalism - but that economic base was combined in a contradictory and unstable structure with the totalitarian rule of a vicious bureaucracy, "different from fascism only in more unbridled savagery" • The bureaucracy had all the vices of a ruling class, but had not yet demonstrated the stability and substantial historical role of one.
Such an attitude did not lead Trotsky to waver in any way in his political focus on working-class self-liberation.| In 1945-9 the Trotskyists saw the basic economic forms of the USSR those which had for Trotsky defined it as a sort of workers' state established in many other contries. Political regimes similar to the USSR's were also established in those countries. If the USSR was a degenerated workers' state, then these countries must also be some sort of workers state. They could not be called "degenerated" because they had been bureaucratic police states from the start. So they were "deformed" workers' states - states in which Stalinist political formations or the USSR's army had created as much as survived of 'the conquests of October 1917', together with a Stalinist regime.
On the face of it, this conclusion need not lead to any weakness in liberation liberation into vor inates sells states designated *degenerated and deformed workers states". If it means that we call the workers' anti-bureaucratic revolution there 'political" rather than "social", then as Trotsky explained back in 1939 - the difference is in terminology rather than programme. Perspective The Trotskyists in 1945-51 were in part influenced by Issues broad historical perspective. If the Stalinist states were "degenerated then the following perspective could and deformed workers' states be deduced.
Capitalism must be in extreme decay: that was why post-capitalist states had been created even under bureaucratic leadership and therefore in such aberrant forms. The aberrant forms were inherently and acutely unstable. A world of collapsing capitalism and unstable aberrant bureaucratisms put workers' power on the agenda as SOON as the necessary political leadership came forward In 1939 Trotsky had written: *The historical alternative, carried to the end, is as follows: either the Stalin regime is an abhorrent relapse in the process of transforming bourgeois society into a socialist society, or the Stalin regime is the stage of a new exploiting society Now the alternative was posed not only for the USSR but also for Stalinist states covering one third of the world.
If these were not workers' states, then what were they? They must be new exploiting societies, and new exploiting societies undeniable dynamism. Capitalist development was leading not to socialism but to a new revived form of capitalism (state capitalism) or to a new form of exploitation (bureaucratic collectivism). Where did this leave socialists? As helpless utopians?
Some Trotskyists in 1945-51 did try to formulate "state capitalist" or "bureaucratic collectivist" analyses. But they dealt unconvincingly with the issues of historical perspective. Most of them became hopeless sectarians.
The name-tag theories But what in fact did the mainstream of the Trotskyist movement achieve with the codification of the "degenerated and deformed workers' state" thesis in 1951 at the Third World Congress of the Fourth International? Not a coherent theory with a grip on reality. They achieved only a name-tag "degenerated and deformed workers' state" behind which ›ver the years accumulated a wide ariety of different theories What the "workers' state" nametag signified was the acceptance of the Stalinist states as in some way Prameressive the description and Within that analysis differed widely in both detail and implications.
For Ted Grant, of what is now the Militant tendency, a nationalised economy was ipso facto workers' state, no matter how or by whom it was created. For Michel Pablo and Ernest Mandel, the deformed workers' states were nationalised economies created by some sort of working-class agency - by the USSR's state authority in Eastern Europe, SOT by dissident Stalinist parties in Yugoslavia and China which were in fact deformed workers' parties" For Joseph Hansen, the "working-class" character of the agency in Yugoslavia and China was defined by the mass pressure on the Stalinist parties — although these parties re mained Stalinist. they had been forced to go further than they wanted.
None of these theories was satisfactory. Grant's theory implied Students march through Pragu that workers' could be created without, despite, agains it, or in the absence of a working cla: ss. It pointed Trotskyists towards supporting such creation with out, despite, or against the working as a major if flawed step for ward towards socialism. It could be suStained only by saying that capitalism and bureaucratic co illectivism were by definition impos sible - a view Trotsky never took.
The Pablo/Mandel or the Hansen thesis could be susta lined only by gross illusions about the nature of the Yugoslav and Chi nese (and later Vietnamese, Cuban etc.) revolutions. These were not workers' revolutions. The s ocial base of the revolutionary pa irties was mainly peasant; the pa irties were heavily bureaucratised militarised; their ideology Stalinist; and, far from being F lushed against their wishes by the w orking class, they clamped down ot n the workers.
These theories were advance d by sincere and militant anti-Stalin lists. Yet they all led to softness on s iome bureaucracies, some times whether it be Grant's steadfast support for the USSR's murderou cupation of Afghanistan, or th le illusions of various parts of the Pablo/Mandel/Hansen current rent (represented in Britain today 1 by Socialist Action and Soci ialist Outlook) on the Yugoslav, Chir Unese, Vietnamese, Cuban Nicaraguan revolutionaries.
Most Trotskyists have wallc swed in confusion and vacillation glorifying a succession of Stal linist totalitarian bureaucracies from Tito through Mao to Castro and Ho , Chi Minh. One staggering fact: it w: as 20 years after Mao took power in a all of China, clamping down on the workers and jailing the Chi inese Trotskyists, before the mainst Dream of post-Trotsky Trotskyism dec tided that a political revolution necessary!
urn to page 9
----- pull-quotes -----
MARXISM, STALINISM AND AFGHANISTAN