Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Choice in childbirth

Socialist Organiser no. 371, 15 September 1988 · scan p. 2 · about 1,308 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Ferguson Midwives get a rough deal. Over the years they have been downgraded from being the experts on childbirth to being little more than handmaidens for (generally male) obstetricians.

Over recent years there have been some moves back towards giving midwives more of a role!

But is the tide changing? Two recent cases involving midwives suggest so.

—Jilly Rosser has been struck off and is unable to practise as a midwife. No mother or child has suffered at her hands - indeed, at her hearing there was a large lobby of women and babies who had been attended by Jilly Rosser. The action she has been struck off for could well have saved a mother's life.

During an apparently normal home delivery, a mother began haemorrhaging. The nearest hospital was minutes away. Jilly Rosser calculated that it would be quicker to ferry the mother to hospital in her own car than to wait for the local obstetric "flying squad' to arrive. This broke the rules. Jill? Rosser was struck off.

The second case concerns a midwife working for Croydon Health Authority, Christine Warren.

Croydon's policy is to have two midwives in attendance at home births. In February this year Christine Warren arrived at the home of one of her patients who had just gone into labour. She rang the second midwife, but labour proceeded more quickly than expected, and as the second midwife arrived so did the baby.

Ms Warren was suspended the following morning, and in June sacked for "gross misconduct', Such events seem rather ironic when we look at the state of maternity services and the experience of many mothers who go through the hospitals' consultant-controlled reproduction line.

A national newspaper recently reported the case of a woman who gave birth in a hospital toilet because the powers-that-be refused to believe that her labour was as advanced as she said it was.

Many women either receive anaesthesia they do not want, or are unable to obtain epidurals at night because an all-night anaesthetist service is not available. Cases of unnecessary inductions, caesarians, and episiotomies done for the consultant's personal convenience, or to fit into hospital timetables, are rife.

The weight of reputable medical research now says that flat-on-theback labour is not only inefficient, but can cause more trauma to the baby - lack of oxygen and the like. Still most hospitals offer no alternative, unless you really push for it (no pun intended).

Choice for women disrupts set hospital routines. Unfortunately, childbirth is not something which can be confined to hospital timetables. More midwife involvement and autonomy undermines consultants' power. Consultants who step out of line can be victimised, ostracised and miss out on promotion - just remember the case of Wendy Savage.

Women need more choice in childbirth. Not the sort of choice exercised by 'Mother of the Year' the Duchess of York, in her private champagne-suite hospital, not the choice advocated by Thatcher and Moore, but choice dependent on democratic input to a properly funded NHS maternity system. The EEPTU are now out of the TUC. How should socialists and rank and file electricians respond? What's the best way to beat EETPU leader Hammond and the scab business unionism he represents?

There are two possible responses: to stay in the EETPU and fight Hammond from within or to support the breakaway pro-TUC electricians under the EPIU.

Although the prospect of being free from Hammond may appear attractive to a few rank and file electricians, a breakaway union is not the best way to fight at this stage.

The vast bulk of EETPU members, who are by no means hardened scabs, will remain with the union. Meanwhile the EPIU breakaway will be just too small and weak to pose a serious alternative to Hammond.

Formed on the first day of this year's TUC Congress, the EPIU (Electrical and Plumbing Industrial Union) is top heavy and lacks a ranch closed by Hammond - march HamI Vapping. Photo: lan Swindale an Sv BI Rigby Tom and on the basis of already existing rank and file organisation.

The problem is that the EPIU clearly doesn't have the strength to do this, except in a few isolated cases, and as a result, has to rely on the bureaucratic strength of the other TUC unions to recruit new members.

The EPIU might guarantee safe bureaucratic careers for some of its leaders like John Aitken and lan Brown but it isn't the best way to fight Hammond.

Rank and file activist electricians should stay in the EETPU where the majority of electricians remain. They should use the ferment created by the union's expulsion to raise the arguments against Hammond and everything he represents.

There may come a time when it's fruitless to continue in the EETPU but the point has not been reached yet. The job of socialists and all active trade unionists is to fight now while we still have a chance to stop Hammond turning the EETPU into a totally closed, hardened scab outfit.

The future of the EEPTU will be decided by this struggle, A policy to deleat Hammond must include: * Opposition to single union, strike deals. * For immediate reaffiliation to the TUC. * Support for workers in struggle. * Opposition to EETPU poaching against TUC unions, as on the Docklands Light Railway. * A campaign for union democracy including election of all officials for fixed periods and the right of branches and members to communicate independent of the executive. * Encouragement of the maximum possible contact between rank and file electricians and members of TUC unions. Dissident EETPU branches must not be kicked off joint shop stewards committees and trades councils. * Kick EETPU leaders Pornographer David Sullivan's Sunday Sport now has a sister publication, called simply The Sport published on Wednesdays. Sullivan also has a new editor with the strangely Dickensian name of Peter Grimsditch to replace the late and unlamented Mike Gabbert. You may recall the period last year when Express Newspapers were so concerned by the success of the Sunday Sport that they handed control of their ailing Star tabloid over to the Sullivan/Gabbert team. The experiment was not a success. and the final straw for the Express group and its suave chairman Lord Stevens was the loss of millions of pounds worth of advertising from Tesco and the Co-op. The Star is, to this day, vainly attempting to recover its image as a 'family' newspaper.

Meanwhile the new team of Sullivan and Grimsditch claim that their Wednesday Sport has overtaken the circulation ofToday and is building up a cult following among yuppies. Grimsditch has taken tabloid journalism to its logical conclusion by blatantly inventing stories so bizarre that not even Ms Wendy Henry would believe them.

A few examples have included the revelation that Adolf Hitler was a woman; a story about a baby from space brought up by gorillas in the Amazon jungle; a 100-stone man who hasn't eaten for months in an attempt to find a girlfriend; and World War Il bomber found on moon' (plus the follow-up story, World War Il bomber found on moon vanishes').

Unlike, say, the Sun or Star, the Sport makes not even a token effort to carry anything vaguely resembling news in the usually understood sense. Apart from bizarre 'exclusives, its other main content is, of course, sex....in the form of obviously fabricated "true life' letters. articles about 'nights of passion' which seem to emanate from companies owned by Mr Sulliyan himself.

can quite believe that the Sport's main audience is now yuppies rather than the working class readers who Mike Gabbert aimed at; it has just the right combination of trivia, childishness and smut that would appeal to the Porsche and winebar crowd. I can also understand people (especially women) getting very angry about this so-called newspaper and backing calls from

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 371

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →