Is the USSR Imperialist?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 41 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 41
The US is a brutal imperialist power. This scarcely needs to be said on the left. But many on the left think that we should align ourselves with the USSR and with its gambits in arms diplomacy. They believe that condemnation of the USSR implies cold-war bigotry and jingoism, like that expressed in the memorable phrase of one of Reagan's scriptwriters about 'The Evil Empire'.
Socialists have no time for this chauvinism. But we should have no time for dishonest cant either. Or for the ignoble thought that we should not bother too much about the evils of the Russian system because we want peace with that system at all costs. Socialists want peace; but socialists who make political and ideological peace with the vile oppression of the working class and of subject nationalities which is Stalinism are selling their socialist birthright. We should be as bigoted against oppression in the USSR and by the USSR as we are bigoted and irreconcilable against the oppressions of capitalism at home and abroad.
For what is the superpower conflict about? Our world is dominated by two power blocks — one led and loosely dominated by the US, and the other tightly dominated by the USSR. Nothing less than the future of humanity depends on the prevention of all-out nuclear war between these blocks.
Nuclear peace has been preserved for four decades on the basis of a balance of nuclear terror. Wars between the blocks have been confined to Korea and Vietnam, and have involved not the USSR but North Korea and China, and North Vietnam. Conflict has otherwise been confined to the struggle for influence and dominance in the Third World.
The US's typical ally in this competition has been the right-wing militarybased regime linked to archaic and corrupt local oligarchies and ruling classes. The USSR's best allies have been the local - usually peasant-based - Communist Parties and their military formations. Those Stalinist movements have channelled, and organised into powerful forces for social change, nationalist grievances as well as the social discontent of workers, peasants and urban petty bourgeois.
But the superpower conflict is not a contest between progress and reaction. The international Stalinist movement, linked to the USSR, has shown itself to have a dual character. It is sometimes capable of being revolutionary against capitalism and pre-capitalist systems -but always it is simultaneously counterrevolutionary against the working class. Mobilising peasants and, sometimes, workers to gain power, it imprisons the working class in a totalitarian vice once Stalin it has succeeded in gaining and! stabilising control.
During and after the Second World War, the Russian Stalinist bureaucracy demonstrated first that it could survive, then that it could expand, and finally that it could replicate itself in countries as distant and as different as China and Cuba. The bureaucracy has shown itself to be more stable and durable than Trotsky, who saw it as a transitory and aberrant freak, believed possible. The pattern of the bureaucracy's rise is perfectly plain in retrospect.
In the decade between the final crushing of the working class Left Opposition in 1927 and the Moscow Trials of the mid '30s, the Russian Stalinist bureaucracy took to itself all the worst characteristics of a ruling class. In 1928 it faced down the revolt of resurgent capitalist forces — the kulaks and the NEP-bourgeoisie - and, as Trotsky later (1940) put it, made itselt the sole master of the surplus product.
Slave-driving the working class, and converting many millions of workers and peasants literally into slaves in labour camps, the USSR rapidly industrialised. Surrounded by hostile imperialist powers, the bureaucracy manoeuvred and fought for advantage, and began to compete with those powers on something like equal terms.
In mid 1939 it signed a pact with Hitler's Germany which freed the hands of the Nazi regime to unleash the Second World War, and gained for the USSR partnership with Hitler in the partition of Poland and Nazi acceptance of Russian annexation of Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania, the three Baltic states since incorporated into the USSR. Various other spheres of joint activity were discussed between the Nazis and Stalin, including invasion of then Britishcontrolled India. One of the reasons why they fell out was a dispute over whose sphere of influence Bulgaria was in.
The sudden Nazi invasion of the USSR in June 1941 came close to toppling the Stalin regime, but by 1943 the tide had turned and Stalin's armíes began a relentless march west, at the very heart of Germany.
At Yalta in 1944, Russia's control of Eastern Europe was acknowledged by the big capitalist powers. There followed two or three years of interregnum during wnich Stalin's armies, allied to largely (though not entirely) manufactured local CPs, established iron totalitarian control in occupied Eastern Europe and Germany. Stalin had been forced by US pressure in 1946 to evacuate the not thern part of Iran, which the USSR had invaded in 1941; and his plea to the UN that the USSR should be given 'the Mandate' over former 'Italian' North Africa (Libya) was unsuccessful. But by 1948 Stalin's system had extended itself to incorporate vast areas of Europe andi about 90 million people.
That is where it is today, acting as a brutal occupying power. It used military, force to repress the German workers in 1953, the Hungarian people in 1956, ang the Czechs in 1968. It used the threat of it to limit and ultimately destroy Poland's Solidarnosc in 1980-1.
This, too, is an imperialist system, and one which today holds far more people in direct subjugation than any other imperialist power now existing:. Even within the USSR's own frontiers a majority of the people belong to oppressed nationalities - like the 50 million Ukrainians, for example, who are subject to a relentless 'Russification' The argument used by most Marxists against defining the USSR as imperialist goes something like this. Imperialism in the 20th century means monopoly capitalism and its drive to expansion: Russia is not monopoly capitalist, therefore it cannot be imperialist. But. this is using categories, definitions and labels not to facilitate thought but io prevent it; not to make sense of the facts, but effectively to deny them.
If this approach is pursued consistently, it must result in the denial that there has ever been in history an imperialisnr: other than monopoly-capitalist im+ perialism; and that would still leave the Stalinist USSR to be linked in history. with a vast number of imperialisms which were not based on monopoly capitalism, thereby defining monopolycapitalist expansionism as some sort of aberration. That is decadent logicchopping, not Marxism.
This nonsense passes for Trotskyism, or even 'orthodox' Trotskyism, on this question. But in fact Trotsky himself had a different position. In 1939 he recognised the 'element' of imperialism in Stalin's policy, and he did so in word that leave little doubt about what 4* would have made of the gigantic fact of the USSR's post-war expansion. ^41sThe USSR did expand, and for over 40 years it has managed to hold on to what it got, in face of every pressure Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 39
Scan page 42
Germany the USSR was the second strongest military power in the world, overshadowing Europe and matched only by the US. In response to the USSR's settled control of Eastern Europe the US and its allies resorted to cold war and preparations for a third world war. The USSR's power neutralised the early US monopoly of the atom bomb, balancing the threat of the A-bomb's use with the threat to take Western Europe should it come to war. By the time Western Europe had been built up economically and militarily so as to have some chance of standing up to Stalin's armies, or at least for long enough for the US A-bombs to tip the balance, the USSR had broken the US monopoly and had its own nuclear bombs. Instead of world war 3 there was prolonged cold war, supplemented by the Korean and Vietnam wars.
On the other side, the old colonial powers, France and Britain, came out of the war enfeebled and weak. Powerful nationalist movements confronted them in the colonies, some Stalinist-influenced or controlled. The Chinese Stalinists won power in the biggest semicolony on earth in 1949, and the Vietnamese in the north of their country in the mid-'50s.
The US aspired not to set up its own colonial block, displacing France and Britain, but to win hegemony in the non-Stalinist world on the basis of its great economic strength. It prised open the old exclusive trading blocks and nudged Britain and France towards the dissolution of their colonial empires.
A powerful wave of rationalisation and integration of the capitalist world developed, and a growth of almost free trade under the economic hegemony of the US giant. The cold war unfroze in the '50s, and not even the Vietnam war brought it back to the icy level of the late '40s and early '50s.
Then, in the 1970s, the US's unchallenged hegemony in the capitalist world came to an end. It was defeated in the Vietnam war, and faced with intense and vigorous competition from Europe and Japan. The USSR expanded its influence in Africa, and at Christmas 1979 it invaded Afghanistan to stop the defeat of its client regime there. The invasion alarmed the capitalist world simultaneously allowed it to justify a renewed military drive to US and internațional public opinion. Seven years of renewed intense cold war followea, accompanied by hot wars in Afghanistan — 'the USSR's Vietnam' - and in Central America.
Peace will not be helped by pretending that either of the two bloody superpowers is other than what it is. The real road to peace lies not in negotiations between capitalist and bureaucratic imperialists, but in a different direction -the direction of consistent democracy in international affairs and the overthrow of the imperialists by the working class, East and West.
That road to peace was mapped out in a magnificent document addressed to the peoples of the world - and in the first place to the working class of every Reform or Revolution in Eastern Eur country - by the Russian Bolsheviks on 8 November 1917, the day after the Russian working class took power. Naturally some of the specific conditions have changed, but in its fundamentals this programme is as fresh and as adequate today as it was when the Congress of Soviets - that most democratic, and at the same time most revolutionary, of representative assemblies — proclaimed it to a blood-drenched and war-weary world 70 years ago. Excerpts:
«The Workers' and Peasants' government created by the revolution of 6-7 November and backed by the Soviets of Workers' , Soldiers', and Peasants' Deputies calls upon all the belligerent peoples and their governments to start immediate negotiations for a just and democratic peace.
By a just, or democratic, peace... the government means an immediate peace without annexations (i.e., the seizure of foreign lands, or the forcible incorporation of foreign nations) and indemnities... In accordance with the sense of justice of the democracy in general, and of the toiling classes in particular, the governinterprets the annexation, or seizure, of foreign lands as meaning the incorporation into a large and powerful state of a small or feeble nation without the definitely, clearly and voluntarily expressed consent and wish of that nation, irrespective of the time such forcible incorporation took place, irrespective of the degree of development or backwardness of the nation forcibly annexed to, or forcibly retained within, the frontiers of the given state, and finally, irrespective of whether the nation inhabits Europe or distant, overseas countries.
If any nation whatsoever is forcibly retained within the boundaries of a given state, if, in spite of its expressed desire - no matter whether that desire is expressed in the press, at popular meetings, in party decisions, or in protests and revolts against national oppression — it is not permitted the right to decide the forms of its state existence by a free vote, taken after the complete evacuation of the troops of the incorporating or, generally, of the stronger nation, without the least pressure being brought to bear upon it, such incorporation is annexation, i.e., seizure and coercion. The government considers that it would be the greatest of crimes against humanity to continue this war for the purpose of dividing up among the strong and rich nations the feeble nationalities seized by them, and solemnly declares its determination to sign immediately conditions of peace terminating this war on the conditions indicated, which are equally just for all peoples without exception...
While addressing this proposal for peace to the governments and peoples of all the belligerent countries, the Provisional Workers' and Peasants' Government of Russia appeals in particular to the class conscious workers of the three most advanced nations of mankind, the largest states participating in the present war, namely, Great Britain, France and Germany.
re Page 40 For these workers, by comprehensive, determined and supremely energetic action, can help us to bring to a successful conclusion the cause of peace, and at the same time the cause of the emancipation of the toiling and exploited masses of the population from all forms of slavery and all forms of exploitation. The Workers' and Peasants' Government created by the revolution of 6-7 November and backed by the Soviets of Workers' , Soldiers' and Peasants' Deputies, must begin immediate negotiations for peace.
Our appeal must be directed both to the governments and to the peoples. We cannot ignore the governments, for that would delay the possibility of concluding peace, and the people's government dare not do that; but we have no right not to appeal to the peoples at the same time. Everywhere there are differences between the governments and the peoples, and we must therefore help the peoples to interfere in the question of war and peace.
We will, of course, insist upon the whole of our programme for a peace without annexations and indemnities. We shall not retreat from our programme; but we must deprive our enemies of the opportunity of declaring that their conditions are different from ours and that therefore it is useless to start negotiations with us. No, we must deprive them of that advantageous position and not advance our terms in the form of an ultimatum. Therefore the point is included that we are ready to consider all terms of peace and all proposals. We shall consider them, but that does not necessarily mean that we shall accept them... We are combatting the duplicity of governments which in words talk of peace and justice, but in fact wage annexationist and predatory wars. There is not a single government that will say all it thinks. We, however, are opposed to secret diplomacy and will act openly in the eyes of the whole people. We do not, and never did, close our eyes to the difficulties. War cannot be ended by refusal, it cannot be ended by one side only... In proposing the conclusion of an immediate armistice, we appeal to the class conscious workers of the countries have have done so much for the development of the proletarian movement. We appeal to the workers of England, where there was the Chartist movement, to the workers of France, who have in repeated insurrections displayed the strength of their class consciousness, and to the workers of Germany, who waged the fight against the Anti-Socialist Law and have created powerful organisations...
The government and the bourgeoisie will make every effort to unite their forces and drown the workers' and peasants' revolution in blood. But the three years of war have been a good lesson to the masses; Soviet movements in other countries, the mutiny of the German fleet, which was crushed by the Junkers of the hangman Wilhelm... The workers' movement will triumph and will lay the path to peace and socialism"
Scan page 43
SUBSCRIBE! Arabs, Jews and The debate on: Palestir Anti-Semitem sandladi Zionism) Price £1.80 hlets and Social cialis /londn Irlas Get Socialist Irgani! er Rates(UK) £8 50 for six Name ...
Address Please send n Socialist Orga deli vered t › your mo aths. E 6 for 5/12 months sub er, PO Box 823, SOCIALIST Jor • by OR 6 A enclose £... To: ndon SE15 4NA.
The Tories new homeless Ulster cops did shoot to kill
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKERS LIBERTY
Britains death squad exposed