Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Stalin's post-war conquests: what tl Trotskyists said

Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?, 1 September 1988 · scan pp. 37–40 · about 3,920 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 37 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 37

Leon Trotsky was the main leader of the revolutionary workers uprising Petrograd in October 1917, and the organiser of the Red Army. From 1923 until he was murdered by a Stalinist agent in 1940, he was also the most vigorous and courageous opponent of the new bureaucracy in the USSR from a working-class socialist point of view.

After Trotsky's death, his comrades continued his struggle against that bureaucracy, and tried to continue his work of analysing and assessing the levelopment of the USSR. At the end of World War 2, the Kremlin vastly xpanded its area of rule, seizing and pillaging Eastern Europe. Facts became available about the vast system of labour camps in the USSR, where up to ten million people were slaves.

The Trotskyists tried to update their understanding, and summarised their conclusions in Theses at an international congress in 1948. As the Trotskyist movement splintered and become disoriented in the difficult rears after 1948, many of those conclusions were garbled or forgotten But they are still relevant today. We reprint excerpts from the Theses. ment...

History has not yet pronounced its final verdict on the USSR. Its economy, its state, its culture are undergoing constant change, which is far from having reached a definite conclusion. The composition of its social strata is subject to continuous and rapid variation. The proletariat which emerged from the Czarist regime with the stirring memories of the October Revolution and entered upon the road of industrialisation twenty years ago with enthusiasm, has given way to a working class newly drawn from the peasantry, whose immense creative energies are crippled by the Stalinist dictatorship. The peasantry of today, transformed by the tractor, the kolkhoz (collective farm) and the terror of deportations, only resembles superficially the old Russian peasantry. The workers' bureaucracy composed of upstart revolutionaries, has changed into a more or less closed caste, desirous of reviving the customs and nationalist traditions of the foritier ruling classes.

In spite of its complexity two striking features emerge from this picture. The sum total of the production relations inherited from the October Revolution has proved to possess an infinitely higher capacity of resistance than the Marxists had foreseen. The decisive historic Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 35

Scan page 38

JOatober 1917: Revolution.

Movomber 1917: Beginnings of civil war. tate 1917-early 1918: British, Ffench and other foreign forces begin in. dervention to help counter-revolutionaries.

March 1918: Treaty of Brest-Litovsk. Bolsheviks cede vast areas to Germany il return for peace.

Summer 1918: Civil war stepped up. ¡The 'peasant socialist' SR party openly supports counter-revolution; the Mensheviks (an avowedly Marxist party who consider the revolution premature) dither. Both are banned.

Movember 1918: Revolution in Germany. Mensheviks take firm line of critical support for Soviet government and are re-legalised. 901D: Most intense period of the civil war. But there are revolutionary upris. ings in Europe. April: Soviet Republic in Bavaria (southern Germany). MarchRugust: Soviet Republic in Hungary. Workers put pressure on Western governments to abandon anti-Bolshevik intervention. By the end of the year the Red Army is in a strong position. March 1920: Poland invades Soviet Union.

Late 1920: Poles defeated and civil war ends.

Septomber 1920: Mass factory occupations in Italy.

Early 1921: Collapse of industry: overall is producing less than one-fifth of its 19 output. From spring, famine: millions starv to death. Under the emergency regime of 'war communism, where the only method of economic allocation was military commands, the Soviets have withered. With the removal of the immediate threat from the counter-revolutionaries and imperialists, the workers and peasants are less patient.

the naval base of Kronstadt, near Petrograd.

February 192I: Georgia, previously under a Menshevik government which has made treaties with the Soviet government of Russia, is forcibly annex.

et. Trotsky protests at the time, though later he writes a pamphlet justifying the annexation against bourgeois criticism.

The Mensheviks are banned again in earLy 1921.

March 1921: Bolshevik Party congress brings in New Economic Policy (controlled reintroduction of free market); bans factions inside the party. A debate on fade unions ends in victory for Lenin, who argues for trade-union independence from this 'workers' state with bureaucratic deformations'.

Uprising by German CP in March 1921 ands in fiasco.

June-July 1921: At the 3rd Congress of the Communist International, the Bolshevik leaders sound a retreat, calling for an orientation to 'the conquest of the masses' rather than immediately 'the conquest of power'.

March 1922: Stalin becomes general secretary.

May 1922: Lenin suffers a stroke. He out of action almost all the time from Reform or Revolution in Eastern E Churchill and Stalin dividing up ine wur now until his death in January 1924. Late 1922-early 1923: 'Lenin's Last Struggle'. Lenin tries to form a bloc with Trotsky to struggle against Stalin and the growing bureaucratism. Trotsky, however, is not decisive enough. The party and state machine falls into the hands of the "troika' of Zinoviev, Kamenev, and Stalin.

October 1923: First Trotskyist opposition manifesto, the 'Platform of the 46'. December: Trotsky's 'The New Course". Trotskyists argue for more democracy and more industrialisation.

October 1923: German CP muffs revolutionary opportunity and is heavily defeated.

February-May 1924: 'Lenin levy': Core of Bolshevik Party swamped in a mass of 240,000 new recruits, many of them careerists. The party has long had unchallengeable control of the Soviets; now the machine has unchallengeable control of the party.

Summer 1924: 5th Congress of Comintern, under Zinoviev's leadership, promotes a blustering ultra-left course. Trotsky polemicises against this. Western CPs 'Bolshevised': given more efficient organisation, but also bureaucratic regimes and bans on factions.

Autumn 1D24: Trotsky publishes 'Lessons of October'.

December 1924: Stalin comes out for 'Socialism in One Country', previously considered an absurdity by all Bolsheviks.

1925: Growing tension between Zinoviev and Kamenev, on one side, and Stalin, on the other. Stalin shifts towards an alliance with the right wing led by Bukharin, who advocate a long-term policy based on the richer peasants. The split between Zinovier and Kamener and Stalin comes out into the open in December 1925.

Early 1926: Joint Opposition (Trotsky, Zinovier and Kamenev) formed. Intense political battle from summer 1926 to end of 1927, over democracy, industrialisatior and planning, and international issues.

Comintern is shifting towards a policy of seeking powerful bureaucratic and bourgeois friends, rather than relying on workers' struggles.

December 1927: Defeat of the Opse Page 36 110. .... position. Trotsky and Zinovier expelled from the party. Zinovievites immediately capitulate. Trotskyists sent into exile in remote parts of the USSR.

Early 1928: First signs of Stalin turning against Bukharin and the right wing. Pyatakor and a few other Trotskyists capitulate.

January 1929: Trotsky deported from USSR.

July 1929: Preobrazhensky, Radek and some other Trotskyists capitulate, on the grounds that Stalin is carrying out the essentials of the Opposition's policy of industrialisation and planning.

Late 1929-Fobruary 1930: Stalin's wavering policy lurches into a full-scalo collectivisation drive. By February 1930 over 50% of peasants are in collective farms. Then there is another lurch backwards; but after that Stalin's change of course becomes stable. By 1936 90% of peasants are in collec. tive farms. Together with this goes a vast mobilisation of resources for forcedmarch industrialisation. Results: • Number of livestock drops by about two-thirds, as panicked peasants slaughter their beasts. • Consumption per head of meat, lard and butter fall by over 50% between 1928 and 1932. There is severe famine in 1933. • Real wages fall by over 50% between • Social inequality and bureaucratic • Industrial labour force doubles between • Between 1927-8 and 1937, output of electricity increases by a factor of 7; of steel by a factor of 3½; of coal by a factor of 3½. Output of industrial consumer goods, for example wool cloth, remains • All independent trade union activity steady, however.

crushed. Savage labour laws punish 'economic sabotage' by death and absenteeism or leaving your job by jail.

Late 1932: Communications between Trotsky and his co-thinkers in the USSR January 1933: The Comintern's thir are finally cut off.

period' policy, pursued since 1928-9, of breakaway 'red' unionis; no united front, etc., finally opens the way for Hitler to take power. No self-criticism from the

Scan page 39

Comintern: Trotsky abandons the orientation of reform of the Comintern and calls for a new International. Soon afterwards he calls for revolution rather than reform in the USSR.

February 1034: Rakovsky capitulate! - the most prominent surviving Trotskyist leader in the USSR.

Over the year 1934, Comintern shifts from the 'third period' policy to one of 'popular front" with bourgeois forces against fascism.

December 1934: Assassination of Kirov (the local supremo in Leningrad) becomes the signal for the start of the Great Purges. Not only oppositionists, but also the great majority of the delegates to the solidly Stalinist party congress of 1934, are purged, jailed or e ecuted. By 1940-2 ten million people are in labour camps. 1936-8: Moscow Trials.

March 1938: Hitler seizes Austria october 1938: Hitler seizes the "" German-speaking part of Czechoslovaki March 1939: Hitler seizes the rest of 23 August 1939: Hitler-Stalin pact, including agreement on:

I September 1939: Simultaneous German and USSR invasions of Poland, which lead to World War 2.

November 1939: USSR invades Finland, seizes 16,000 square miles of te ritory.

July 1940: A Stalinist agent murders Trotsky.

June 1941: Germany invades USSR. January 1943: USSR wins battle of Stalingrad. Tide of war turns against uer many.

November 1943: Tito establishes a government in Yugoslavia; in the following months Tito's Communist Party, at the head of a guerrilla army, wins full power in Yugoslavia. 1944-45: USSR army advances througl Eastern Europe, winning control over some 80 million people. Coalition govern ments are set up, sometimes including monarchists and fascists, but with Communist Party members in key ministries. USSR also occupies northern Iran, but is forced by diplomatic pressure to withdraw in 1946.

February 1945: Yalta conference between US, Britain and USSR. May 1945: Germany surrenders. July-August 1945: Potsdam conference between UŞ, Britain and USSR finalises deal worked out at Yalta - partition of Germany: shifting both eastern and western borders of Poland far to the west, putting former Polish territory in the USSR and former German territory in Poland; deporting 15 million Germans from Eastern Europe.

US and Britain concede Kremlin overlordship in Eastern Europe. Stalin repays them by holding West European CPs to collaboration with their capitalist rulers.

August 1945: Atom bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Japan surrenders. 1947: 'Cold war' between USSR and the West begins. Stalinists in Eastern Europe move to take full control, using the 'salami tactic'. They co-opt some of the political oppositión and suppress the rest. January 1948% Stalin, condemns Tito. Tito turns to the West for aid. February 19489 Prague coup' -takes full power in Czechoslovakia. significance of the revolution is thus borne out in full measure. But at the same time, the possibilities of reaction and regression in all fields, including the economic, within the framework of these production relations, have been shown to be infinitely vaster and more dangerous than anyone could have thought. These two factors must stand out clearly from our analysis.

The same complexity likewise appears in the present situation of the USSR, as it has emerged from the war and the first years of the imperialist "peace' Although the Soviet Union has come out of the war as the first military power on the European continent, it has not improved either its internal or international situation, relative to capitalism. Internationally, the policy of pillage and bureaucratic expansionism has in no way succeeded in altering the relationship of forces, which has deteriorated as a result of the constitution of a single imperialist bloc. Internally, the reconversion of economy was carried out through a series of violent collisions which assumed the form of a real crisis. The bureaucracy has only maintained itself because of the unstable equilibrium between the proletariat and the restorationist tendencies in Russia itself, and between the world proletariat and the world bougeoisie, has not yet been upset in one direction or another. But the bureacracy has proved more than ever incapable of eliminating any of the contradictions undermining its power. More than ever before, the fate of the USSR depends on the fate of the class struggle on a worla scale, and for the degenerated workers' state the fundamental alternative remains: Forward toward socialism, or back toward capitalism...

The fundamental contradictions of present Russian economy are the followa) Contradiction between the production relations on the one hand ('collective ownership of the means of production), the maintenance of which imperiously demands the restoration of workers' control, the progressive introduction of workers' management of production; and on the other hand, the bureaucratic management of the state and economy, which increasingly endangers the maintenance of this collective ownership, threatened by the pillage of the bureaucracy ('the bureaucracy digs into collective property as into its own pockets') and by the more and more pronounced tendency toward stagnation in the development of productive forces. This is concretely expressed by a more and more manifest diminution in the rate of accumulation.

b) Contradiction between the tendency toward contralisation, coordination and conscious planning of economy inherent in the production relations and the tendency • toward primitive accumulation, the crystallisation of a "parallel' economy of simple commodities and toward anarchy resulting from the failure to satisfy the masses' needs by the bureaucratically managed economy •The tendency toward primitive accumulation, created by want, breaks out through innumerable pores of the planned economy": (Trotsky).

...The bureaucracy has been incapable of ensuring a harmonious developmest of production, a diminution of the contradiction between town and country an easing of the sharpness of soical tradictions. To attain • these engi € it economy would have had to be oriented first and foremost toward a satisfaction of the needs of the masses; the aims af the plan would have had to be calculated and controlled by the intervention.of millions of producers, economic progress would have had to be measuredin terms of the progressive rise of the masses level of consumption and educt tion. However, the bureaucracy defends the essence of the production relatiol inherited from October only as a basis for its privileges, and not as a basis rd socialist development. Under these con ditions, the preservation of the regim which collides more and more with immediate and historic interests of masses, could only be accomplishes through the imposition of the mos totalitarian police dictatorshiproM history. The development of productive forces, while developing the neeas or ne whole population, has only assured the satisfaction of the needs of a privileged layer and has tremendously accentuated social inequality instead of reducing it: The bureaucratic regime, substituting spirit of lucre, coercion, arbitrariness and terror for revolutionary devoti8h; creative energy, the critical spirit and free initiative of the masses as the motive power of planning, has corrupted the latter at its roots The more the bureaucracy tries to em, brace in its plan all of the country's productive forces, the more the latter escape its hold. Theft on a gigantic scale, migration of millions of workers, peasants and even technicians, the development of the free market, both peasant and hai dicraft, are the clearest signs of tendency. To counteract these, bureaucracy can no longer appeal 19 material interest. It must resort primari, ly to terror. Large-scale compulsory labour camps, the regimentation of thg whole of social life, the arbitrary impasis tion of all living and working norms! give more and more of a caste character. in this trait is summed up the teali tionary role of the bureaucracy and it incapacity really to keep in check t disintegrating forces which it has fise. unleashed. Under these conditions, ti progressive character of the production relations means nothing else but that a change in property relations is not necessary for the ovethrow of the bureaucracy. The production relations and bureaucratic management are more and more inextricably bound up. Consu quently, the progressive character of the Russian economy which is determined by its capacity to develop the productive forces, tends to become eliminated by, the bureaucracy. The greatest attentior must be devoted to the study of this development...

Not only does collective ownership in Russia today not have a socialist character, but it is becoming more and Revolution in

Scan page 40

The slogan reads: "The Friendship, the Example, the Aid, of the Soviet Union are the guarantee of the fulfilment of the six-year plan" more inadequate to guarantee by itself, that is, without the political overthrow of the bureaucracy, any further economic progress. The fall of productive forces resulting from the war only emphasises the tendency inherent bureaucratic management, of bęcoming more and more an absolute bfake on ęconomic progress...

If we apply the term 'degenerated workers' state' to this social organism, we are perfectly aware of the necessity to constantly bring up to date the complete and precise meaning of this detinition. In reality, it is impossible to give any exact definition of present Russian society without a lengthy description. The relative superiority of this formula in comparison with all the others proposed up till now lies in this, that it takes into account the historic origin of the USSR and at the same time emphasises its noncapitalist character and the instability of its social relations, which have not yet aqcuired their final historic physiongnomy, and are not likely to in the next few years...

From an uncontrolled caste, alien to socialism, the bureaucracy has become an uncontrollable caste, mortally hostile to socialism both in Russia and on a world scale. It possesses all the reactionary traits of the old owning classes — parasitism, waste of the surplus social product, cruelty toward the oppressed, exploitation of the producers. But it does not possess any of their progressive features, connected with a necessary historic function of introducing and defending an economic system that is superior from the standpoint of the division of labour and the ownership of the means of production.

If its regime seems to be 'more stable' than the decadent capitalist regime, this is exclusively due to the fact that it has succeded in using to its own advantage production relations which are infinitely superior to those of capitalism. In reality the bureaucracy has, during the past twenty years, occupied a much less stable position in Russian society than even the most decadent borgeoisie occupies in its society. It has no juridical or economic safeguards of its privileges. It is in constant fear, not only of losing its privileges but also of losing its individual Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 38 freedom and life; terror weighs on its privileged layers just as heavily as on the masses. The success of every bureaucrat does not depend on his birth, wealth, personal capabilities or on the success of his work, but on the arbitrariness of the hierarchy. Not only has the bureaucracy not worked out a distinct ideology, not only does it not have the instinct or characteristic of every social class, but in the course of the unceasing transformations which it has undergone, and as a result of the terrible blood-letting entailed by the consecutive purges, it has become demoralised even before it could attain an understanding of its role.

...The foreign policy of the bureaucracy has undergone an essential and definite change following the Second World War. Before this war, that policy was based on the possibility of neutralising the pressure of the capitalist environment on the USSR by setting off against one another the antagonistic imperialist blocs, and to a lesser extent, by manipulating 'national' Stalinist parties. The subjective reflection of this policy was the theory of 'socialism in one country' which was based on the conception of a more or less gradual development of productive forces in Russia, dependently of the development of the capitalist world.' The disappearence of German, Japanese, Italian and French imperialisms as first-rate powers and the extreme weakening of British imperialism, have placed the Soviet bureaucracy face to face with American imperialism. The latter has more or less succeeded in setting up a 'capitalist united front' against the USSR. The united front is not based on the 'fear' of the 'revolutionary' nature of Stalin...

'Defend what remains of the conquests of October' is a strategic line for the revolutionary party, and not alone a 'slogan' • This strategic lne has its historic justification; it must also be seen, in each concrete situation, in what tactical form it is to be applied within the framework of the Fourth International's general strategy of world revolution.

The historic justification of this strategy derives from four fundamental considerations:

a). The historic superiority of the Russian production relations vis-a-vis those of the capitalist world;

b) The objective weakening of world imperialism resulting from the exclusion from its, market of the Russian sphere;

c) The crushing of the USSR by imperialism would historically signify an enormous step backward; for the great mass of the workers, this would not signify a defeat of Stalinism as such, but of Communism itself.

d) The necessity of preserving what is left of the conquests of October, as a condition — not sufficient, but necessary — for a socialist development of economy.

By defending the remnanats of the conquests of October we do not in any way consider the USSR as a whole. On the contrary, we believe that the policy and the very existence of the Stalinist bureaucracy constitute a permanent threat to all that is, in our opinion, still worth defending...

Will be necessary to continue this revolutionary class struggle consistenly and uniterruptedly in the case of the occupation of any given country by the Russian army, even though the revolutionary forces clash with the Russian army, and also in spite of the military consequences which this might entail for the Russian army in its operations against the imperialist military forces. In any case, the use of military means remains subordinated to the necessities of the revolutionary class struggle of the proletariat in whatever countries it may be. Thus, our defence of the USSR remains identical in all cases with the continuation of the revolutionary class struggle...

It is particularly important to stress the following points.

a) It would be the gravest mistake toapply the strategy of the 'defence of the USSR against imperialism' to the different tactical diplomatic or military manoeuvres of the bureaucracy, to its temporary retreats, to the concessions which it is forced to make to imperialism within the framework of international power politics. 'Defend what is left of the conquests of October' means, in the face of these problems to denounce the reactionary character of the Stalinist policy which lays the most solid bases for a concentration of petty bourgeois, peasant, etc. forces in the camp of imperialism and fundamentally discredits every notion of communism in the eyes of the proletariat. This means, under all circumstances, not to remain silent on a single crime of the bureaucracy, not to offer an apology for a single one of the monstrous manifestations of its policy, which constitutes the main break on a revolutionary development of the workers' struggles.

b) All formulas along the line of 'last bastion of the revolution' 'socialist workers, workers and peasants tower workers' which constitute gross deformations of a Marxist definition and tend to create illusions regarding the nature of the Stalinist dictatorship, thus discrediting the Fourth International, must be expunged from our vocabulary.

----- pull-quotes -----

February: mass economic strikes in Petrograd. March: rebellion by sailors

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →