A Drogramme for revolution
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 31 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 31
This Drogramme originally appeared in An Open Let- programme originally appeared An Open ter to the Party', written by Polish socialist dissidents Jacek Kuron and Karol Modzelewski. The authors were sentenced to three years in jail for publishing the document in 1964. Kuron himself has now developed a political perspective different from this → the theory of 'self-limiting revolution' — but the document remains as one of the boldest revolutionary Thus far we have considered the revolution as the gravedigger of the old order. It also creates a new society. Is the working class, which must be the main and leading force of the revolution, capable of developing a real, viable programme?
The class interest of the workers demands the abolition of the bureaucratic ownership of the means of production and of exploitation. This does not mean that the worker is to receive, in the form of a working wage, the full equivalent of the product of his labour. The level of development of the productive forces in a modern society necessitates a division of labour in which there are unptoductive sectors, supported by the material product created by the worker. Therefore, under conditions of a workers' democracy, it will also be necessary to set aside from the total product a part earmarked for accumulation, for the maintenance and development of health services, education, science, culture, social benefits and those expenditures for administration and for the apparatus of political power which the working class will recognise as indispensable. The essence of exploitation is not that the working • wage represents only a part of the value of the newly created product but that the surplus product is taken away trom the worker by force and that the process of capital accumulation is alien to his interests, while the unproductive sectors serve to maintain and strengthen the rule of a bureaucracy (or bourgeoisie) over production and over society, and thus in the first place, over the labour and social produced from within the Eastern life of the working class.
To abolish exploitation: means, therefore to create a system in which the organised working class will be master of its own labour and the resulting product; in which it will set the goals of social producion, decide on the sharing and use of the national income, hence define the size and purpose of investments, the size and disbursement of expenditures for social benefits, health services, education, science : and culture, the amount for the power apparatus and its current tasks. In brief, a system in which the working class will exercise economic, social and political power in the state.
How should the working class and its state be organised in order that it might rule over its own labour and its product? Workers' democracy 1) If there is no workers' democracy in the factory, there can be none in the state on any long-term basis. For it is only in the factory that the worker is a worker, that he fulfils his fundamental social function. If he were to remain a slave in his place of work, then any Roform 1 programmes. bloc. freedom outside the place of work would soon become "Sunday freedom," fictitious freedom.
The working class cannot rule over its own labour and its product without controlling the conditions and goals of its toil in the factory. To that end, it must Workers' Councils in order to run the actories. The manager must be made in. to a functionary subordinate to the Council, controlled, hired or dismissed by the Council.
However, these days, all key decisions relating to the management of an enterprise are made centrally. under these conditions, the Workers' Council would, in practice, be deprived of power. The manager is closely bound yp with the offices which make the decisions — the central apparatus of economic management. In this situation, the Workers' Council would inevitably be reduced to an adjunct to the management, as is the case with the present-day Conferences of Workers' Self-Government.
To manage enterprises through its Workers' Councils, the working class Revolution in Fastern Europe 29
Scan page 32
must make the enterprises independent, creating the preliminary conditions for workers' democracy and, at the same time, adapting management relationships to the new class goal of production (as we have already shown, the system of centralised management is an organisational tool of production for the sake of production, whereas production for the sake of consumption requires a decentralised system). Thus, while taking the first step toward realising its programme, the working class achieves that which is most far-reaching and progressive in the programme of technocracy: the independence of enterprises. But the working class and the technocracy each imbue this concept with a fundamentally different social content. To the technocracy, independence of an enterprise means that management has full powers in the factory. For the working class, it means self-government for the working force. That is why the working class must go beyond plant management by the Councils. Workers' self-rule, limited to the level of the enterprise, would inevitably become fictitious and a cover for the power of management in the factory and for the rule of a • new technocratic bureacuracy; exploitation would be maintained and the former state of chaos would return in a new form.
Basic decisions relating to the sharing and use of the national income naturally have a general social character; that is, they are made on an economy-wide scale and therefore, they can only be made centrally. If these central decisions were to remain outside the influence of the working class, it would not rule over the product that it has created and over its own labour.
Proletarian power 2) That is why in addition to factory councils, the working class will have to organise itself into a nationwide system of Councils of Workers' Delegates, headed by a Central Council of Delegates. Through the system of councils, the working class will determine the national economic plant and maintain permanent control over its execution. As a result, the Councils at all levels will become organs of economic, political, legislative and executive power. They will be truly elective offices, since the electors, organised according to the natural principle of production, will be able at any time to recall their representatives and appoint new ones in their place. In this way, the representatives of working forces in the factories wil become the backbone of proletarian state power.
Multi-party democracy 3) If, however, the workers' representatives in the Central Council of Delegates were to have only one draft plan for the division of the national income laid before them by the government or by the leadership of the sole political party, their role would be limited to a mechanical act of voting. As Reform Revolution in we noted earlier, a monopolistic ruling party cannot be a workers' party; it inevitably becomes the party of the dictatorship over the working class, an organisation of a bureacracy designed to keep the workers and the whole of society disorganised and in line.
For the council system to become the expression of the organised will, organised opinion and organised activity of the masses, the working class must organise itslef along multi-party lines. In practice, a workers' multi-party system means the right of every political group which has its base in the working class to publish its own paper, to propagate its own programme through mass media, to organise cadres of activists and tion, the abolition of preventive censorship, full freedom of scholarly research, literary and artistic creativity. Without the freedom to elaborate, publish, express various ideological trends, without full freedom for the creative intelligentsia, there is no workers' democracy.
In the workers' multi-party system, various parties will propose plans for the division of the national income to the Central Council of Delegates creating conditions for discerning alternatives and for freedom of choice for the Central representatives of the working class and for factory workers electing and recalling their delegates.
We speak of a workers' multi-party system, although it woula serve no purpose or even be possible, to limit membership in the parties to workers only. The working class character of the multi-party system would follow from the nature of the state power, organised as a system of councils. This means that parties seeking to influence the centre of political power woula be obligea to win influence among the workers.
By the same token, we are against the parliamentary system. The experience of both 20-year periods shows that it carried no guarantee against dictatorship and, even in its most perfect form, it is not a form of people's power. In the parliamentary system, parties compete for votes. Once the votes have been cast, election programmes can be tossed into the wastebasket. The deputies in parliament feel close only to the leadership of the party which nominated them. The electorate, artificially arranged in purely formal districts is atomised and the right to recall a deputy is fictitious. The citizen's participation in political life is reduced to reading statements by political leaders, listening to them on radio or watching them on television, while once every four or five years, he goes to the ballot box to decide which party's representatives are to rule him. Everything happens with his mandate, but without his participation. In addition, parliament is a purely legislative body, which permits executive power to emerge as the only real authority, dominated by men of economic power. Thus, in the parliamentary system, the working class and the whole of society, on the strength of their own vote, are Europe Page 30 deprived of influence As against this formal, periodic voting, we propose the regular participation of the working class through its Councils, parties and trade unions, in economic and political decision-making at all levels. In capitalist society, above parliament, stands the bourgeoisie, disposing of the surplus product; in the bureaucratic system, above the fiction of parliament, the central political bureaucracy rules indivisibly. In a system of workers' democracy, if it takes a parliamentary form, the working class will stand above it, organised into councils and having at its disposal the material basis of society's existence -the product of its labour.
Trade union independence 4) The working class cannot decide directly, but only through its political representation at the central level, how to divide the product it has created. But as its interests are not entirely uniform, contradictions between the decisions of workers' representatives and the aspirations of particular sections of the working class are unavoidable. The very fact of separating the function of management from the function of production carries with it the possibility of alienation of the elected power, at the level of both the enterprise and the state. If the workers were deprived of the possibility of self-defence in the face of the decisions of the representative system, apart from the right to vote (i.e. apart from that very system), then it would turn against those whom it is supposed to represent. If the working class was deprived of the possibilities of self-defense in its own state, workers' democracy would be fraudulent. This defense should be assured by trade unions completely independent of the state and with the right to organise economic and political strikes. The various parties, competing for influence in the trade unions, would struggle for the preservation of their working class character.
Universal education 5) To prevent the institutions of workers' democracy from being reduced to a facade, behind which the old disorder would make a comeback, their democratic forms must be the living expression of the activity of the working masses. Administrators, experts and politicians have the necessary time and knowledge to bother with public affairs while the worker is obliged to stand next to his machine. To take an active part in public life, the worker, too, must be provided with the necessary time and knowledge. This requires a certain number of hours to be set aside weekly from the required paid working time to insure the universal education of the workers. During those hours, workers grouped into production complexes will discuss draft economic plans submitted by ditterent parties for the country, factory or region which are too difficult for popular presentation only if an attempt is made to conceal their class content. The representatives of political parties participating in these hours of workers' education will bring both their programmes and the working class closer to each other.
Scan page 33
A workers' militia 6) In a workers' democracy it will be impossible to preserve the political police or the regular army in any form. The anti-democratic character of the political police is obvious to everyone; on the other hand, the ruling classes have had more success in spreading myths about the regular army.
The regular army tears hundreds of thousands of young people away from their environment. They are isolated in barracks, brainwashed of independent thinking through brutal methods, and taught, instead, a mechanical performance of every order issued by their professional commanders, locked in a rigid hierarchy. This organisation of armed force is separated from society in order that it may, more easily, be directed against society. The regular army, like the political police, is by its very nature a tool of anti-democratic dictatorship. As long as it is maintained, a clique of Generals may always prove stronger than all the parties and councils.
It is said that the regular army is necessary to defend the state. This is true in the case of an anti-democratic dictatorship, where, other than by terror, it is impossible to force the large mass of people to defend a state that does not belong to them. On the other hand, if the masses were allowed to carry arms outside the military organisation, it would create a mortal danger for the system. Consequently, a regular army, for such a system, is the only possible form of defense force.
It is said that the regular army is necessary to defend the state. This is true in the case of an anti-democratic dictatorship, where, other than by terror, it is impossible to force the large mass of people to defend a state that does not belong to them. On the other hand, if the masses were allowed to carry arms outside the military organisation it would create a mortal danger for the system. Consequently, a regular army, for such a system, is the only possible form of defense force.
We have already seen, during the revolutionary wars in Vietnam, Algeria and Cuba, that the armed workers and peasants — if they know what they are fighting for and if they identify their interests with those of the revolution -are not worse soldiers than those in the regular army. This is especially true for small countries threatened by the counter-revolutionary intervention of a foreign power. It has no chance with a regular army; it can defend itself successfully by a people's war. Regular armies are necessary to aggressors who undertake colonial wars and wars of intervention; they are necessary to the anti-democratic dictatorships in order to keep the masses obedient. This is evident especially in Latin American countries where the army has exclusively the internal function of the police. It can also be observed elsewhere — in Poland, too -as we saw during the events in Pozan. Whether or not the army and the workers actually clash, the regular army always remains an instrument of tyranny over the working class and society, just as a club always remains a means of beating, whether or not its owner actually puts it to that use. In a system of workers' democracy, the regular army does not insure defense against the counter-revolution; on the contrary, it may become the source and the tool of the counter-revolutionary camp. It must therefore be abolished.
To make democracy indestructible, the working class should be armed. This applies, first of all, to the workers in larger industries who should be organised into a workers' militia under the aegis of the Workers' Concils. The military will have to organise I have to organ itsel into a nationwide system tionwi de of Councils of f Counc experts who will train the workers' militia will be employed by the Workers' Councils and remain subordinated to them. In this way, the basic military repressive force in the state will be directly tied to the working class which will always be ready to defend its own state and its own revolution.
For technical reasons, it is unavoidable to maintain permanent military units within specialised divisions such as the navy, airforce, rocketry etc. The soldiers for those divisions should be recruited among the workers of heavy industry, and during their military sevice they should remain in touch with their factory teams and retain all their workers' rights.
Agriculture 7. Agricultural production plays an essential part in the economy and the peasantry too important a role in society for the workers' programme to bypass the affairs of the countryside. The future of agriculture lies, without doubt, with large, specialised industrialised and nationalised enterprises. The technical base for such an organisation of agricultural production can only be created by the industrialisation of agriculture. This requires enormous investments, whose realisation is a problem for the distant future. Under present technical-economic conditions, all Reform o attempts at collectivisation mean depriving the peasant of the land he owns which can be achieved only against his will through the methods of police dictatorship. The result would be a fall in production and a police dictatorship victimising the working class itself. Such collectivisation can be reconciled only with a bureaucratic system; it spells death for workers' democracy.
The free, unlimited interplay of market forces, under conditions of individual ownership of land, and given the present structure of agriculture, leads to capitalist-type farming. deprives owners of small and scattered holdings of the possibility of concentrating their means of investment, necessary for their development, and consequently shifts the major part of the means of investment in the countryside to the richest farms. It means the rationalisation of the rural economy through a deep crisis, bankrupting the poorest holdings; and it means unemployment and high prices for. necessities for the industrial working class. This is acceptable to the technocracy which is naturally sympathetic to capitalist farming, but unacceptable to a workers' democracy.
For the working class, the goal of production is the development of the consumption of the broad mass of people who today live at subsistence level. As we have already seen, the bureaucracy pushes the consumption of the majority of villages even below that level, deprives the peasant economy of its surpluses and agriculture of any prospects of development, because it seeks to minimize the real expenditure on labour and regards social consumption as a necessary evil.
The interests of the working class lie in overthrowing these relationships between the peasant economy and the state; it demands a rapid development of. agricultural production — the basis for increased consumption - through the! development of the mass of small and: medium individual holdings. This makes the working class the spokesman for the majority of peasants and creates the basis for a real alliance between them., To realise their common interests it isi necessary, first of all, to overcome the' "price scissors" which deprives small and medium peasant holdings of the material base for development, and tcr tax progressively the richest farms. Se-s cond, that part of the product of thet peasant's labours intercepted by the state in the form of taxes or in any other waymust be - after subtracting sums corresponding to the peasants' contribution to administrative expenditures - returned to the countryside in the form of: social and cultural investments and as state economic and technical aid to assist small and dwarf holdings.
To achieve this, the peasantry needs to organise itself on an economic basis and elect its own political representatives. It must set up its own production organisations and find new perspectives for the almost 60% of the peasantry which vegetates on small holdings and has labour surpluses; it is admissable to allow investments in industry to be Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 31
Scan page 34
blown up out of all proportion. This requires the proper use of labour surpluses in intensive additional production, such as livestock breeding, vegetable and fruit cultivation and such industries as meat packing and fruit canning. This is very difficult, and in the case of processing plants, impossible to achieve with the scattered forces of small holdings. The precondition of success is the creation of associations of small and medium holdings, having at their disposal a labour surplus. These associations, based on the land they possess, on cooperation and on state aid in the form of lowinterest credits, participation in small investments, transport guarantees, etc., will then set up small processing plants and, also in common, organise their supplies and marketing. This is the cheapest to increase the production of deficit-bearing agricultural produce and to invigorate the underdeveloped food industry. It is also the only way of intensifying the work of dwarf and small holdings and simultaneously employing on the spot, the existing labour surplus.
Peasant holdings must be provided with conditions favouring specialisation of production, without which there can be no rational husbandry. At the same time, in their contacts with state purchasing enterprises, peasant producers must be organised to defend themselves against artificial lowering of prices. For the isolated peasant producer who enters into a "voluntary" accord with the state is helpless when faced with the state's monopoly of the market. Accordingly, apart from creating production organisations, the rural population must form it own universal supply and marketing organisation for the peasant holdings. The richest farms, which are relatively few in number but play an important role given their size and economic strength, will then have no chance to transform themselves into capitalist enterprises; they will be short of cheap labour and cheap land that would otherwise be provided by the failure of weak holdings. The richest farms, however, will have the chance to increase their production on the basis of their own means of investment provided they are able to solve the manual labour shortage through the use of machines.
Inasmuch as industry plays the decisive role in the economy, the direction of industrial production will determine the general direction of the national economy. And the working class, which will have control of its own product will thereby create a general framework for the functions of the other sectors, including agriculture. But within these most general limits, determined by the level, structure and development of industrial production, the peasants must also control the product of their labour. The plans for development, for investments, for economic aid should not be imposed by the state on the peasant population.
Otherwise, a specific apparatus of control would come into being and would, finally, also obtain control over the working class. That is why political self-government by the peasants is a must for Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe rage 3t the good of workers' democracy. It is made possible because the interests of the workers and peasants converge.
Economic organisations of peasant producers are not enough to give peasants control over that part of their product taken over by the state and which is to be restored to the countryside in the form of direct state investments and state aid to peasant holdings. This can be assured only by the political representation of peasant producers on a national scale, elected on the basis of economic organisations and peasant political parties.
Internationalism 8. We do not consider the anti-bureaucratic revolution to be a purely Polish affair. The economic and social contradictions we have analysed appear in mature form in all the industrialised bureaucratic countries: in Czechoslovakia, the GDR, Hungary and the USSR. Nor do we view the revolution as the exclusive affair of the working class in bureaucratic dictatorships. The bureaucratic system, passed off as socialism by official propaganda in both East and West, compromises socialism in the eyes of the masses of developed capitalist countries. The international bureaucray and its leading force — the Soviet bureaucracy - fear all authentic revolutionary movements in any part of the world. Seeking internal and international stabilisaation of its own system, based on the division of the world into spheres of influence with capitalism, the bureaucracy suppresses revolutionary movements at home and uses its influence over foreign offical Communist parties to impede the development of revolutionary movements in Latin America, Asia and Africa. The anti-bureaucratic revolution is, therefore the concern of the international workers' movement and of the movement for colonial revolution.
Like every revolution, the anti-bureaucratic revolution threatens the established world order and, in turn is threatened by the forces guarding that order. The international bureaucracy will try to crush the tirst country!
countries of the victorious revolution in proportion to the internal forces it will still have at the moment of crisis.
Western imperialism will try to take advantage of our revolution to supplant the dictatorship of the bureaucracy with the dictatorship of the capitalist monopolies, which is no way better.
The working class must carry out all these changes in the area of political, social and economic relations in order to realise its own class interest, which is the command over its own labour and its product. Is this programme realistic?
With the initial step toward its realization - making the enterprise independent — the working class would create the conditions for adapting production to needs, eliminating all waste of the economic surplus and the proper use of the intensive factors of economic growth. The same would be carried out •. 27 by the technocracy, the difference being that the production goal of the working class is consumption by many, not the luxury consumption of privileged strata. That is why workers' control of production would assure the most radical resolution of the contradiction between an expanded productive potential and the low level of social consumption which impedes economic growth today.
The workers separate class interest coincides with the economic interests of the mass of low-paid white collar employees and of the small and medium holders in the countryside. In their combined numbers, they are the overwhelming majority of the rural and urban population. Since the slavery of the working class is the essential source of the slavery of other classes and strata, by emancipating itself, the working class also liberates the whole of society;
To liberate itself, it must abolish the political police; by doing this it frees the whole of society from fear and dictatorship;
It must abolish the regular army and liberate the soldier in the barracks from nightmarish oppression;
It must introduce a multi-party system providing political freedom to the whole of society;
It must abolish preventive censorship, introduce full freedoms of the press, of scholarly and cultural creativity, of formulating and propagating various trends of social thinking. It will thereby liberate the writer, artist, scholar and journalist; it will create, on the widest possible scale, conditions for the free fulfilment by the intelligentsia of its proper social function;
It must subject the administrative apparatus to the permanent control and supervision of democratic organisations, changing existing relationships within that apparatus. Today's common civil servant will become a man free of humiliating dependence on a bureacratic hierarchy;
It must assure the peasant control over his product, as well as economic, social and political self-government. It will thereby change the peasant from the eternal, helpless object of all power into an active citizen sharing in making decisions which shape his life and work.
Because the worker occupies lowest position in the productive process, the working class more than any other social group, needs democracy:
every incursion on democracy is first a blow against the worker. That is why workers' democracy will have the widest social base and will create the fullest conditions for the free development of the whole of society.
Because the workers' class interest most closely corresponds to the requirements for economic development and to the interests of society, the working class programme is a realistic one.
Will that programme be realised?
That depends on the degree of ideological and organisational preparation of the working class in a revolutionary crisis and theréfore also depends on the present activities of those who identify with workers" democracy.
Scan page 35
How did Stalin and the Russian bureaucracy come to p ower? This tract from 'The Revoll tion Betra by Leon Trotsky looks at the background.
The progressive role of the Soviet bureaucracy coincides with the period devoted to introducing into the Soviet Union the most important elements of capitalist technique.
The rough work of borrowing, imitating, transplanting and grafting, was accomplished on the bases laid down by the revolution. There was, thus far, no question of any new word in the sphere of technique, science or art. It is possible to build gigantic factories according to a ready-made Western pattern by bureaucratic command - although, to be sure, at triple the normal cost. But the farther you go, the more the economy runs into the problem of quality, which slips out of the hands of a bureaucracy like a shadow. The Soviet products are as though branded with the grey label of indifference. Under a nationalised economy, quality demands a democracy of producers and consumers, freedom of criticism and initiative — conditions incompatible with a totalitarian regime of fear, lies and flattery.
Behind the question of quality stands a more complicated and grandiose problem which may be comprised in the concept of independent, technical and cultural creation. The ancient philosopher said that strife is the father of all things. No new values can be created where a free conflict of ideas is impossible. To be sure, a revolutionary dictatorship means by its very essence strict limitations of freedom. But for that very reason epochs of revolution have never been directly favourable to cultural creation: they have only cleared the arena for it. The dictatorship of the proletariat opens a wider scope to human genius the more it ceases to be a dictatorship. The socialist culture will flourish only in proportion to the dying away of the state. In that simple and unshakable historic law is contained the death sentence of the present political regime in the Soviet Union. Soviet democracy is not the demand of an abstract policy, still less an abstract moral. It has becom a life and death need of the country.
It is sufficiently well known that every revolution up to this time has been followed by a reaction, or even a counter-revolution. This, to be sure, has never thrown the nation all the way back to its starting point, but it has always taken from the people the lion's share of their conquests. The victims of the first reactionary wave have been, as a general rule, those pioneers, initiators, and instigators who stood at the head of the masses in the period of the revolutionary offensive. In their stead people of the second line, in league with the former enemies of the revolution, have been advanced to the front. Beneath this dramatic duel 0f "coryphees" on the open political scene, shifts have taken place in the relations between classes, and no, less important, pro. found changes in the psychology of the recently revolutionary masses.
Answering the bewildered questions of many comrades as to what has become of the activity of the Bolshevik party and the working class — where is its revolutionary exed' ter-revolution Initiative, its spirit of self-sacrifice and plebeian pride — why, in place of all this, has appeared so much vileness, cowadice, pusillanimity and careerism - Rakovsky referred to the life story of the French revolution of the eighteeth century, and offered the example of Babeuf, who on emerging from the Abbaye prison likewise wondered what had become of the heroic people of the Parisian suburbs. A revoluton is a mighty devourer of human energy both individual and collective. The nerves give way. Consciousness is shaken and characters are worn out. Events unfold too swiftly for the flow of fresh forces to replace the loss. Hunger, unemployment, the death of the revolutionary cadres, the removal of the masses from administration, all this led to such a physical and moral impoverishment of the Parisian suburbs that they required three decades before they were ready for a new insurrection.
The axiom-like assertions of the Soviet literature, to the effect that the laws of bourgeois revolutions are "inapplicable" to a proletarian revolution, have no scientific content whatever. The proletarian character of the October revolution was determined by the world situation and by a special cor= 08 relation of internal forces. But the classes themselves were formed in the barbarous circumstances of tzarism and backward capitalism and were anything but made to order for the demands of a socialist revolu. tion. The exact opposite is true. It is for the very reason that a proletariat still backward in many respects achieved in the space of a few months the unprecedented leap from a semifeudal monarchy to a socialist dictator. ship, that the reaction in its ranks wan inevitable. This reaction has developed In a series of consecutive waves. External condl• tions and events have vied with each other in nourishing it. Intervention followed in. tervention. The revolution got no direct help from the west. Instead of the expected prosperity of the country an ominous destitution reigned for long. Moreover, the outstanding representatives of the working class either died in the civil war, or rose & few steps higher and broke away from the masses. And thus after an unexampled tension of forces, hopes and dillusions, there came a long period of weariness, decline and sheer disappointment in the results of the revolution. The ebb of the "plebian pride" made room for a flood of pusillanimity and careerism. The new comReform or Revolution in Eastern Europe Pars 1
Scan page 36
manding caste rose wave The demobilisation of the Red Army of five million played no small role in the for•mation of the bureaucracy. The victorious commanders assumed leading posts in the local Seviets, in economy, in education, and it they persistently introduced everywhere that pushed away gradually from actual par: finination in the leaderchin of the country.
The reaction within the proletariat caused an extraordinary flush of hope and confidence in the petty bourgeois strata of lown and country, aroused as they were to new life by the NEP, and growing bolder and bolder. The young bureaucracy, which o1 had arisen at first as an agent of the proletariat, began now to feel itself a court of arbitration between the classes. Its independence increased from month to month The international situation was pushing with mighty forces in the same direction. The Soviet bureaucracy became more self74.1 confident, the heavier the blows dealt to the world working class. Between these two facts there was not only a chronological, but a causal connection, and one which worked in two directions. The leaders of bureaucracy promoted the proletariat's tr defeats; the defeats promoted the rise of the bureaucracy. The crushing of the Bulgarian insurrection and the inglorious retreat of the German workers' party in 1923, the collapse of the Estonian attempt at insurrection in 1924, the treacherous liquidation of the General Strike in England and the unworthy conduct of the Polish workers' party at the installation of Piludski in 1926, the terrible massacre of the Chinese revolution in 1927, and, finally, the still more ominous recent defeats in Germany and Austria -these are the historic catastrophes which killed the faith of the Soviet masses in world revolution and permitted the bureaucracy to rise higher and higher as sole light of salvation.
As to the causes of the defeat of the world proletariat during the last thirteen years, the author must refer to his other works, where he tried to expose the ruinous part played by the leadership in the 'Kremlin, • isolated from the masses and profoundly conservative as it is, in the revolutionary movement of all countries. Here we are concerned primarily with the irrefutable and instructive fact that the continual defeats of the revolution in Europe and Asia, while weakening the international position of the Soviet Union, have vastly strengthened the Soviet bureaucracy. Two mass arrests among the Left Opposition.
To be sure, tens of thousands of revolutionary fighters gathered around the banne of Bolshevik-Leninists. The advanced workers were indubitably sympathetic to th Opposition, but that sympathy remained passive. The masses lacked faith that the situation could be seriously changed by a new struggle. Meantime the bureaucracy asserted: 'For the sake of an international revolution, the Opposition proposes to drag us into a revolutionary war. Enough of shake-ups! We have earned the right to rest. We will build the socialist society at home. Rely upon us, your leaders!" This gospel of repose firmly consolidated the apparatchiki and the military and state officials and indubitably found an echo among the weary workers, and still more the peasant masses. Can it be, they asked themsleves, that the Opposition is actually ready to sacrifice the interests of the Soviet Union for the idea of "permanent revolution"? In reality, the struggle had been about the life interests of the Soviet state. The false policy of the International in Germany resulted ten years later in the victory of Hitler - that is, in a threatening war danger from the West. And the no less false policy in China reinforced Japanese imperialism and brought very much nearer the danger in the East. But periods of reaction are characterised above all by a lack of courageous thinking.
The Opposition was isolated. The bureaucracy struck while the iron was hot, exploiting the bewilderment and passivity of the workers, setting the more backward strata against the advanced and relying more and more boldly upon the kulak and the petty bourgeois ally in general. In the course of a few years, the bureaucracy thus shattered the revolutionary vanguard of the proletariat.
It would be naive to imagine that Stalin, previously unknown to the masses, sudden! issued from the wings fully armed with a complete strategical plan. No indeed. Before he felt out his own course, the bureaucracy felt out Stalin himself. He brought it all the necessary guarantees: prestige of an old Bolshevik, a strong character, narrow vision, and close bonds with the political machine as the sole sourc of his influence. The success which fell upon him was a surprise at first to Stalin himself. It was the friendly welcome of the new ruling group, trying to free itself from the old principles and from the control of the masses, and having need of a reliable arbiter in its inner affairs. A secondary figure before the masses and in the events of the revolution, Stalin revealed himself as the indubitable leader of the Thermidorian bureaucracy, as first in its midst.
The new ruling caste soon revealed its own ideas, feelings and more important, its interests. The overwhelming majority of the older generation of the present bureaucracy had stood on the other side of the barricades during the October revolution. (Take for example, the Soviet ambassadors only: Troyanovsky, Maisky, Potemkin Suritz, Khinchuk, etc.) Or at best they had stood aside from the struggle. Those of the present bureaucrats who were in the Bolshevik camp in the October days played in the majority of cases no considerable role. As for the young bureaucrats, they have been chosen and educated by the elders, frequently from among their own fspring. These people could not have achieved the October revolution, but they were perfectly suited to exploit it.
Personal incidents in the interval betwee these two historic chapters were not, of course, without influence. Thus the sickness and death of Lenin undoubtedly hastened the denouement. Had he lived longer, the pressure of the bureaucratic power would have developed, at least during the first years, more slowly. But as early as 1926 Krupskaya said, in a circle of Left Oppositionists: "If Ilych were alive, he would probably already be in prison". The fears and alarming prophecies of Lenin himself were then still fresh in her memory, and she cherished no illusions as to his personal om. nipotence against opposing historic winds and currents.
The bureaucracy conquered something more than the Left Opposition. It conquered the Bolshevik party. It defeated the programme of Lenin, who had seen the chief danger in the conversion of the organs of the state "from servants of society to lords over society". It defeated all these enemies, the Opposition, the party and Lenin, not with ideas and arguments, but with its own social weight. The leaden rump of the bureaucracy outweighed the head of the revolution. That is the secret of the Soviet's Thermidor.
----- pull-quotes -----
workers, multi-party system artures freedom of speech, press and associa-
ni regime which had ensured success in the or civil war. Thus on all sides the masses were