Socialism and democratic rights
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-09-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 22 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 22
There is not, nor can there ever be, absolute freedom. Nevertheless, it is important to recognise that there are certain basic human rights which ought not to be violated.
Yet these rights are being trampled upon in many parts of the world under different economic and social regimes. Socialists and communists are imprisoned in countries like Argentina, Chile, Iran and South Africa, while noncommunists are killed or gaoled in other communist countries.
When it comes to civil and human rights, therefore, it is important that socialists should not be seen to have double standards. The British left have always been the champions of free speech, free association, free trade unions, free elections, free parliaments, in countries like Chile, Argentina, Brazil and South Africa, as well as at home. We must stand up equally for human rights in the so-called socialist countries.
Disgust
If oppression takes place in the name of socialism, then socialism is besmirched, and those who would otherwise be in favour of a socialist society turn away in disgust. This has already happened on a vast scale, and the oppression in the Soviet Union and other 'socialist' countries has done untold harm to the cause of socialism. Democracy and freedom have always been the instruments of genuine socialism, not its enemies. Once antiEric Heffer MP Reform or R olution in democratic methods are used, then socialism goes out of the window. Shortly before her death at the hands of the German right in 1919, Rosa Luxemburg warned the Bolsheviks:
"Freedom for the supporters of the Government only, for the members of one party only — no matter how big its membership may be — is no freedom at all. Freedom is always for the man who thinks differently. This contention does 'not spring from a fanatical line of abstract justice, but from the fact that everything which is enlightening, healthy and purifying in political freedom derives from its independent character, and from the fact that freedom loses all its virtue when it becomes a privilege".
Luxemburg argued that the dictatorship of the proletariat would be an extension of democracy". "This dictatorship consists in a particular application of democracy, not in its abolition; it implies energetic action against the acquired rights and general economic relations of bourgeois society, and without this intervention a socialist transformation of society is impossible"
This type of bureaucratic society has nothing in common with socialism, the essence of which is freedom and democracy. Socialism means the flowering of the human spirit, not its curtailment or destruction. The very idea of prison or in a mental institution for their beliefs fills genuine socialists with horrOI.
Prisons
It is this that turns Soviet dissidents into 'counter-revolutionaries' once they gain their freedom and reach the west.
They were not always reactionaries. But they have been in labour camps, prisons, or mental hospitals merely for expressng their views, or sometimes just for demanding the implementation of the law. The west, with its apparent freedom of speech and politics, seems to them like paradise.
Roy Medvedev, a Soviet dissident who has remained a marxist and a socialist writes:
"Socialist democracy is simultaneously a goal and a means. Democracy is essential as a value in itself. To be able to express one's thoughts and convictions freely without fear of persecution or repression is a vital aspect of a free socialist way of life. Without freedom to receive and impart information, without freedom of movement and residence, without freedom of creativity in science and the arts, and without many other democratic freedoms, a true socialist Akin.
Polish militia attacks workers society is impossible. Democracy all government activity open to scrutiny — is also necessary as a of ridding our society of bure: and corruption. It offers firm prc against a relapse into ar lawlessness"
Socialism and democrac! theretore, synonymous. It is im to stress this because today in Bri Conservative Party is trying tr that left-wing socialists want i European-style state. These samı who make such a song-and-danc Soviet repression are quite happ main silent about what goes on i tries like Chile and South Afric:
Double But the fact that many Tor double standards on the que: human rights is no reason for : to follow their example. Oppr oppression, and when it is carrie the name of socialism, then i solutely vital that socialists shi only protest and attack it, but al from the roof-tops that such of
Scan page 23
has nothing in common with genuine socialist concepts. Unless we identify ourselves totally with those fighting for freedom and democracy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe our protests against oppression in Chile, Iran, South Africa, etc., are a sham.
One crucial test for the left is the attitude it takes to those in the Soviet Union who are now trying to create genuine trade unions. At the beginning of 1978 the Free Trade Union Association of the Soviet Working People was founded. The members of the Association have suffered police harassment, imprisonment and detention in psychiatric hospitals for their attempt to give Soviet workers an independent voice.
The reality is that trade unions in the Soviet Union are controlled by the state. Consider, for example, the fact that Aleksander Shelepin, who visited Britain as the leader of the Soviet trade unions, was previously head of the KGB, the secret police. Imagine if the former boss of MIS or MI6 were to become General Secretary of the British TUC!
Socialists have consistently opposed the control of trade unions by the state. They opposed Hitler's absorption of the German unions into the Labour Front, and the transformation of the unions in Mussolini's Italy and Franco's Spain into subordinate parts of the Corporate State. Under Stalin the Soviet trade unions also lost their independence, becoming 'transmission belts' for the bureaucratic party and state machine.
Millions
Therefore although trade unions exist in the Soviet Union, with many millions of members, these documents show that they are no longer instruments of workers in their struggle to defend and improve living standards and working conditions. It is perfectly understandable that some independent-minded Soviet workers believe that they must organise genuine trade unions. They should receive the same degree of support from British trade unionists as do trade unionists in Chile, Bolivia, and the Reform or MILICON black trade unionists of South Africa.
The British labour movement must take a clear stand in support of Soviet trade unionists. If we do not, we will be guilty of the charge of having double Dr Colin Morris said at a service at Westminster Abbey to commemorate Human Rights Day 1977:
«We would do well to take account of some words of Gerald Winstanley, leader of the Diggers, a seventeenth century protest movement of the English peasantry against the worldliness of the church and the tyranny of the rich. His followers paid a heavy price for their resistance to the state and from bitter experience he wrote, "There are but few who act for freedom, and the actors are oppressed by the talkers and the verbal professors of freedom' Perhaps there has been too much talk about freedom and the time has come to act. An essential part of that action must be to support those in all parts of the world who need our help.
From the Introduction to 'Workers Against the Gulag', by Victor Haynes Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 21
Scan page 24
e Church in Poland Th Many socialists in Britain are hesitant bout supporting Solidarnose because of the visible strong influence within it of the Catholic Church. But why is it that the Church has that influence?
¡ Let's start with Father Jozef Tichner, who preached at Solidarity's first national congress. His book, "The Ethics of Solidarity" clearly supports workers taking strike action: "Senseless work is the most extreme form of the exploitation of many by man. It is a direct insult to the uman dignity of the worker. When Work becomes senseless, the strike is only kind of behaviour which makes Sense"
Tichner is not opposed to socialism.
merely distinguishes between 'Closed tocialism' (Stalinism) and 'Open Socialism'. 'Closed Socialism', "allows of only one possible form of exploitation -chat which is the result of private ownership of the means of production. When, herefore, after the abolition of private property, the workers come to the conclusion that they are being exploited, closed socialism concludes that they have allen victim to an illusion"
Or take Father Jerzy Popieluzko, the priest murdered by the Polish security orces in October i984. After martial law 11981, when many steelworkers in Waraw were being arrested and jailed, eaten and attacked, Popieluzko declared The duty of a priest is to be with the MI people when they need him most, when i chey are wronged, degraded and "maltreated"R r He sat with the steelworkers in court, the worked tirelessly to raise money, Lood, clothing for the jailed workers' amilies. And, yes, he preached against the authorities as well. For that he was killed, his finger-nails ripped off, his body black and blue, his tongue ripped out. Again, in May 1977 in Krakow a leading SIKOR (Workers' Defence Committee)
sympathiser, Stanislaw Pyjas, a student, was killed. His funeral was attended by 2,000 students. Violence was feared. Who supported the students and appealed to the workers of Krakow to act to ensure they didn't get hurt? Cardinal Wojtyla.
When 14 people began a hunger-strike against the arrest of KOR members in : 1977, where did they find sanctuary? In ! St.Martin's Church in Warsaw. 90. The church is one of the precious few ¿Places where Poles can escape the tyran.
ny of the state. Before the rise of Solidai nosc, it was the only major institution in • Poland autonomous from the state. The Catholicism of a Polish worker fighting ibfor his or her class, or of a priest closely ›dinked with such workers, is different Trom the Catholicism of the Vatican.
Here is a scene: 3lst August 1985, the 5th anniversary of the founding of ¿Solidarnosc. Workers, farmers, old, young are attending church for a 'birthday mass'. Posters, produced by the L'ünderground, are displayed. One shows Irlarge fist crushing a prison. Another, a Idefiant 5-year old to represent SolidarnOOSC.
Hymns are sung, but hymns with -Alr words like "Oh my country, how long If wounds are today!". An observer is have you been suffering! How deep your moareduced to helpless tears by the passion ‚in ith their voices". As the 'birthday mass' grends a powerful voice comes through the in loudspeakers "Let us swear to make •Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe Page 22 Solidarnosc live"
Thousands of fists shoot into the air, and thousands of voices shout as one "We sear it". And outside a group of Silesian miners - no doubt remembering their comrades killed in December 1981 - lay a wreath over the grave of Jerzy Popieluzko. Where else under martial law can workers gather like this, feel their unity like this, express their opposition like this?
Now to understand all this does not mean you have to support it. It doesn't mean we can forget the church has its own interests, its own goals, its own ideas -often bitterly opposed to what we stand for as socialists. It doesn't mean we stop proposing and fighting for secular, rational, human, workers' solidarity. But does mean we can never support the bureaucrats on the grounds that their 'Marxist-Leninist' mumbo-jumbo is somehow better than the workers' Catholicism.
Indeed, the most important thing to said against the Polish Catholic Church that its. hierarchy has been one of the most important props of the Polish state!
It constantly preached 'moderation' and "compromise' to Solidarnosc from August 1980 to December 198l.
Take for example the Bydogozcz crisis of March 1981. According to Timothy Garton-Ash in his book. The Polish Revolution', the "workers would never again approach the extraordinary degree of mass mobilisation, popular resolution and preparation which they achieved on 30 March" as they prepared to launch a general strike. At the eleventh hour Lech Walesa called it off. Walesa said: "The Pope wrote to us and the Primate pleading with us for reason and reflection".
And Jaruzelski was happy to broadcast Archbishop Glemp's message the day after martial law, which said: "The authorities consider that the exceptional nature of martial law is dictated by a higher necessity. It is the choice of a lesser rather than a greater evil. Assuming the correctness of such reasoning the man in the street will subordinate himself to the new situation".
To refuse our support for Solidarnosc i to strengthen the church. Can't you hear the bishops? "Look at these western socialists. They watch you beaten bloody with truncheons and thrown in jails for defending your rights. And what do they do? They do nothing. Come to us..."
page afternoon, until the government had given an answer to the ultimatum over the release of the political prisoners. For a moment it looked as though the tenuous agreement had broken down yet again. Jagielski could not believe it. Only an hour before he had undergone the humiliating experience of trying to get Walesa and the strike committee representatives to sign as soon as possible, whereas they insisted on reading every single demand and agreed formulation out loud, one by one, in front of reporters and delegates. The hapless minister could only repeat again and again, "OK, I accept, I'll sign"
Now again more delays, even possible breakdown. Jagielski was sent packing to get immediate assurance from the government about the release of the KOR members. His arrogance and selfassurance had been totally knocked out of him.
Jagielski arrived on Sunday, the next day. After the Plenum of the Central Committee of the PUWP signed the text of the agreement and after a few more delays to ensure the release of the political prisoners (they were to be freed starting the next day), at 4.35 on Sunday afternoon Jagielski and Walesa entered the large hall in the Lenin yard.
Sitting there in complete silence were over 1000 delegates from different factories in the region.
Walesa took the microphone. "Dear friends, throughout this strike we have thought of the interests of our country and it is of that that we shall be thinking when we start work tomorrow September 1, a date whose significance you all know.
'Have we obtained everything? No, but we have obtained a lot under the circumstances. The rest we can obtain because now we have our trade unions. We've fought to get them, not only for us but for all the country. Let's make sure we maintain their independence. The strike is over."
For other Polish workers the fight was just beginning. Silesia, the industrial heartland, whose workers are the highest paid in the country was continuing the strike it had called out of solidarity with the Baltic workers.
They tore to shreds the government's last hopes that the disease of free trade unionism would remain firmly enclosed within the Baltic coastal area. The Silesian workers were now demanding their own free unions.
An MKS had been established in the Silesian coalfields as well. Centred in Jastrzebie, it grouped 26 mines and 208,000 miners, as well as 27 other factories representing 100,000 workers.
No pretence at delay, or even hardline rhetoric, now. The government rushed to negotiate with the MKS directly and apart from granting the same demands as at Gdansk it agreed to negotiate other demands such as abolition of the 4 x 6 hour shift system, lowering of the retirement age to 50 years, a working week of five days and the abolition of the official trade unions.
Scan page 25
Women shipyard workers Gda insk