Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Hungarian Commune of 1956

Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?, 1 September 1988 · scan pp. 16–17 · about 1,897 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

The article we reprint here - a summing-up essons of the Hungarian workers' uprising of was first published in the Irish Marxist magazine Solas, December 1966. It was the first writing on workers' struggles in the Eastern bloc by the Trotskyist tendency from which Socialist Organiser Ten years ago this autumn Stalinism showed that it was still very much alive, that it had not been buried either with Stalin or at the 20th Congress → and that those who said it had were wishful fools or liars. The Hungarian workers rose for socialist democracy, an end to the grinding economie regime of parasitic Stalinism, and in favour of national Iberation from the oppression of own in blood by the White counterRevolution; the Horthy years with the the Russian bureaucracy...and they lapsburg admiral at the head of the were mercilessly crushed by the eaction; the war in alliance with Germight of the Soviet Union. It was nany and the aftermath of defeat, with shown decisively that de- ian occupation which had no use for the Iungary as the battleground; the RusStalinisation' was a change of gears, lass differentiation of the days of Lenin an adjustment of tension and tempo und Trotsky: next, Hungary part of the — but in no sense a basic change. joviet sphere of influence as recognised The monster was still sucking blood ›y the Great Power Conferences, real and had sharp and deadly teeth to sower in the hands of the Rus amarmy, and the CP with ample defend its suckers. lemonstrate the of a peaceful revolution Possibility Ten years is too short a time for a detailed re-telling of the story here to be lave first broken the back of the state, necessary; but we will best honour the or someone has; the years of Rakosi's proletarian martyrs of 1956 by briefly error vented first against the honest exarining the lessons of their struggle. communists who found reality under the We have seen the contributions of extended fiat of Stalin nearer to Horcapitalism's ad-men on this anniversary: hy's barbarism than to any kind of pious breast-beating, mixed with socialism, who resisted or resented the assurances that Hungary is far better off conception of the satellite states as today! They were willing and eager to milch-cows for the Russian economy; they still do, reaping the anti-socialist scream about the rape of Hungary, as of the police terror that for years haa and then the attempt to ease the tension propaganda harvest of their lives - but ruled from Siberia to central Germany the capitalists themselves, behind their - an attempt which finally got out of hypocrisy, were just as concerned as the hand for the buraucracy and led to the Stalinists that on no account should a Hungarian explosion. democratic workers' state, freed from stifling and disfiguring scab of them - were denounced by his acStalinism, be allowed to emerge. A complices and Titoite Yugoslavia is one thing: self bureaucracy shook to its foundations. In assertion by the armed masses a dif- Hungary critical voices emerged, at first ferent and deadly thing. No less than the among the intellectuals and students. bureaucracy did they fear the Hungarian mass movement, and for the same Leader of the war-time underground CP reason. One day before the fighting began who later resisted the Stalinist corrupDulles, then US Secretary of State, openly defended the legality of Soviet troops in Eastern Europe. During the Eastern Europe at that time, bloodbath the New York Times reported the US Government as openly opposed to the revolt, and embarrassed by it.

They had let the Russians know in the most diplomatic language that they would 'defend' Berlin and Austria -but as for Hungary...Dulles had already given the line on that. The Hungarian masses were 'left to their fate'; to the capitalists they were only useful as propaganda — and for this purpose the only good revolution was a crushed revolution. late.

We know the story of Hungary. The centuries-long struggle against both Austria and Russia for national emancipation; a Bolshevik Government, the first Hungarian Commune, in 1919, put Reform or Revolution in of the 1956 An the traces its political lineage. salaries of managers and technicians, as Bolshevik Russia had known. When the AVO (the hated political police) opened fire on students who demanded that this programme be broadcast over the radio it sparked off a series of pitched battles.

After a week of bitter fighting against tanks and machine guns, the workers controlled Budapest: the Russian army withdrawn. Workers' councils organised the means of life. Popular confidence swelled and grew, and took the form of cleansing the streets of Budapest of the symbols of Stalinism.

Hammers and sickles which had come to:, to the ground. The elation and solidarity of proletarian freedom was everywhere.

A new government emerged, composed of members of the CP who had been int disfavour at various times, led by Nagy and Maleter.

As later events, including developments in Hungary itself have shown, liberalisation was possible without loss to the bureaucracy; and the Polish October 1956, which had acted as a spur to the Hungarians, showed that a bending to pressure, controlled by a secWhen Stalin's crimes — a portion of tion of the bureaucracy, was also acceptable. But the crime of the Hungarians was that they had asserted their freedom arms in hand. This was the danger, the fuse to the powder keg. Real power wasn't in the hands of the Nagy governrehabilitated. ment, but was held by the workers and students. The Russians had retired, but they were far from satisfied. tion, he was hanged in 1949 after con- Nagy announced the withdrawal from fessing to fantastic crimes at one of the the Warsaw Pact. And the opportune show trials which took place throughout moment arrived for the Russians to return, when the English-French-Israeli modelled on the Moscow trials of the invasion of Suez set the example in the thirties. Over a quarter of a million slaughter of the people of Port Said. A workers and students marched behind new onslaught against the Budapest his disinterred bones, in a resurgence of workers was now made so much easier. popular feeling comparable to the giant A new army crossed the border, unaffuneral of O'Donovan Rossa in 1915. fected by the spirit of Budapest, set up a 'provisional' Government under Janos Soon the workers were out in the streets, arguing, discussing, while the erstwhile Kadar, hitherto a supporter of Nagy. tyrants hesitated to resort to repression Now the 'Red' army had the most that might exacerbate the situation. modern tanks, and they retook Budapest When the stiff-necked Gero clique did after heavy fighting with great casualties finally make up their minds it was too for the rebels — the most determined of whom were concentrated in the workers' A programme of democratic demands areas such as Czepel and Dunapentele. was drawn up: withdrawal of Russian Thus the armed resistance was broken; troops; an end to compulsory produc but for weeks after the workers held out ion norms; workers' control -in- in the slow grinding battle of a general ceiling on the strike.

Scan page 17

Soviet tank, Hungary 1956 The irony of the situation emerged when workers mounted a bust of Lenin on their barricade to taunt the advancing Russians! But this was the natural place for even a statue of Lenin in the Budapest of 1956. It was as if some force of historic truth acted through the confused people who put it there, to ensure that Lenin' was seen in his rightful place - with the proletarian insurgents...

The Stalinists still say it was a fascist counter-revolution; and still they find believers, who are surely credulous to believe in a fascist general strike! Of course there were fascists. Some had founa good jobs terrorising workers as members of the AVO - these the workers dealt with mercilessly, as they dealt with other known Stalinist terrorists. The struggle was conducted by the proletariat with proletarian weapons: the general strike; the councils of workers deputies; and armed struggle — albeit with pitiably poor arms against tanks. The Stalinist lies were exposed when the Daily Worker's Budapest correspondent, Peter Fryer, defended the Hungarian workers from the shameless hired hacks of their murderers.

The workers burnt only the symbols of; 'communism' - its real meaning rose, phoenix-like, in their programme: not to restore capițalism or the landlords, but to retain nationalised property cleansed of the bureaucracy and privilege which were the social basis of the terror. There was some feeling for restoring the land to the smallholders who had been forcibly collectivised in the barbarous Stalinist manner. But the big landlords, including the Catholic Church, who owned half of all Hungary until Nagy's agrarian reform after the war, would have needed a better army than that which the workers had defeated either to regain possession or restore their rule.

It must be admitted that the situation was fluid and many possibilities existed: only a struggle between different tendencies would have decided the outcome. Between the withdrawal of the first Russian army and the final suppression a Government essentially centrist balanced on top of the workers' councils. Its perspective was one of consolidation of limited gains rather than of extending the revolution to spread the fire to the heart of the bureaucratic power -Russia.

The great vacuum was the absence of any pre-ordered party which could raise the magnificent spontaneous action of the masses to a higher level of effectiveness, such as was imparted in 1917 by the Bolshevik Party. Hungary shattered a lot of illusions: in Stalinism for its sincere adherents and fellow-travellers; and in an easy non-revolutionary self-reform by the bureaucracy for some 'revolutionary marxists' who had given way to wishful thinking. The debilitating negative proof of defeat showed that those who had striven to maintain the conception of the Lenin-type Bolshevik party after the degeneration of the Comintern were correct, and no less correct in regard to the anti-bureaucratic revolution in the East as to the anti-capitalist revolution in the West.

The 10th Anniversary finds the Stalinist world split down the middle, its "monolithic' unity rent by the narrow national interests of the Chinese and Soviet bureaucracies. East European and Russian standards have risen, the terror has been relaxed - but still the congenital crisis of Stalinism continues, still this regime of oppression of the working class and betrayal of socialism must disguise itself with "socialist' camouflage; it remains unsettled and the rulers need gimmicks and 'experiments' - every gimmick and every sort of experiment to ward off the one solution -the initiative of the masses of the workers.

After Berlin in 1953, Hungary was the first great lightning flash of the coming revolution of the workers in the Stalinist states. The Hungarian workers were isolated and they were crushed, and the reinforcements for this came from the heart of Russia. But tomorrow, when the rumblings in Russia itself explode in the mass movement of the workers to reclaim the power to control their own lives — where will the bureaucrats get reinforcements from then? When the Russian workers move decisively no power on eart will accomplish what Krushchev's tanks did in Budapest in November 1956.

levolution in Easte rn Europe Page 15

----- pull-quotes -----

represent tyranny were torn down; the proliferate statuary of the State crashed

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →