Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Everyday life in'actually existing socialism'

Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?, 1 September 1988 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,214 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Adam and Eve lived in the Soviet Union?

ANSWER: Because they did not have any clothes to wear, had only an apple to eat, but thought they were living in paradise.

This Cold-War-style joke is not that wide of the mark, save that it is sections of the workers" •movement outside of, rather than within, the Soviet Union who look upon the country as a workers' paradise. And apples, and fresh fruit in general, are not always the easiest things to acquire in the Soviet Union.

In the countries of 'real existing socialism' everyday life for workers is a round of tedious and badly paid work, long queues for consumer goods, poor social services, and low-quality accommodation. And Gorbachev's economic reforms will make things even worse.

According to Konstantin Simis, a Russian lawyer expelled from the Soviet Union in 1977, the average monthly salary for manual and office workers at the start of the 1980s was 164 roubles, before taxes. But the minimum salary required for a family of three to live even modestly, he calculated, was 250 roubles.

The low wages paid to workers contrast starkly with the incomes of the bureaucrats who oppress them. A Marshal of the Soviet Union receives 28 times the income of a worker on the minimum wage. Pay differentials between workers and senior executives in some enterprises can be tenfold or even the fiftyfold of the income of the former. When the hidden (and not so hidden) 'perks' for the bureaucrats are taken into consideration, the differentials in income are even greater. The higher echelons of the bureaucracy have their own chauffeur and domestic statt, priority tickets for entertainment and Reform or Revolution in Eastern Euri e Page 12 travel, special waiting rooms in stations, special private showings of films, and reserved dining rooms in restaurants.

Each Politbureau member has their own personal villa on the Black Sea in the Crimea or in the Caucasus, surrounded by huge parks, and staffed by cooks, chauffeurs, gardeners, hairdressers, doctors and gamekeepers.

Working conditions for the bulk of the Soviet workforce are even worse than those of workers in many Western capitalist societies. Punishments in the official Labour Code for labour indiscipline include fines, demotion, sacking, and deportation to a labour camp. Strikes are forbidden (in a 'workers state' workers cannot strike against themselves, runs the argument). Nor do workers in the Soviet Union have any trade unions to turn to in order to defend them in the workplace.

In fact, though, the Labour Code is not strictly enforced by factory managers, for fear that they appear as inefficient managers to their bureaucratic superiors. It is common therefore for many workers to arrive late, leave early, slip off to do the family shopping, stay off 'sick', or turn up with a hangover. A form of rotten corporatism prevails, whereby managers turn a blind eye to workers' absenteeism, whilst workers turn a blind eye to management fiddling the figures

ialis

to make it appear annant sl

been met.

Women workers have not received the equality so often promised or even declared to have been realised by the ruling bureaucracy. A survey in one Soviet town showed that 66% of women were in comparatively unskilled jobs but only 19% of men. Only 16% of factory directors and chief engineers are women. Where women have become a majority in a particular section of the workforce, then the status, and pay, of that profession has declined:

Women also face a tremendous burden of housework. The notorious shortage of consumer goods in the Soviet Union means long hours of queuing when they are in stock in the shops. Women spend an average of six hours a week shopping. In families of the industrial working class the husband is calculated to have an average of 34 hours free time a week, the wife 20 hours a week.

Soviet-produced consumer goods are renowned for being of low quality, if not completely worthless. Anecdotes about matches that don't strike and pairs of two left shoes are legion. The worst quality goods aré those produced at the close of each morth, when factories are under pressure to meet their monthly production target and therefore produce straightforward funk in order to achieve the target at least nominally.

In 1987 alone 6,000 millions roubles worth of goods were rejected by the State Quality Control Board as being

Scan page 15

sub-standard. (Not that this prevented them from being included in the national production and output figures, as if they had actually ended up in the shops.)

The low quality of Soviet production adds to the futility and frustration of work in the Soviet Union. A stress-free working rhythm is impossible due to the shortage or complete absence of spare parts, which may not work in any case even when they are available. And why work harder to pick up an extra bonus when there is virtually nothing in the shops worth buying with the extra money earned?

The Soviet bureaucracy, and its admirers abroad, make great play of the Soviet Union's cheap housing and social services. Workers unfortunate enough to have to live in such housing or who attempt to use such social services do not share in such enthusiasm.

Rents are certainly cheap. But the accommodation for which it pays is of poor quality and overcrowded. It has certainly improved since the 1960s when, in Leningrad, for example, 57% of working class families lived in a single certain limited liberalisation of intellectual life. But the material problems faced by working class families in their everyday life remain unchanged. As a recent report in the French trotskyist paper 'Rouge' on contemporary life in Moscow pointed out:

"The shopping basket (of the average family) can be filled at the price of interminable queues, and its contents will be of a mediocre quality. Meat is rare or costs too much (10 roubles a kilo, for a monthly salary of about 150 roubles). It is not always possible to find cheese. Sugar has disappeared from the Ukraine in order to serve in the production of adulterated alcohol. As for oranges (from Cuba or Egypt) you have to walk around a long time to be able to buy a kilo"

In fact, Gorbachev's economic reforms will make the problems faced by working class families in their struggle for existence even worse. Plans to increase prices by scrapping or reducing government subsidies, introduce charges for many social services which are currently free, increase wage-differentials, and tie wage levels more closely to actual output, mean that workers will have to work harder even just to stand still in their already lowly position in Soviet society.

A survey of the opinions of over 6,000 skilled workers in 500 Moscow factories revealed that over half of them were of the view that Gorbachev's economic reforms had brought little tangible result - apart from harder work. In one factory 62% of those surveyed expressed this opinion. Equally widespread is the - quite accurate - fear that Gorbachev's economic reforms will lead to falling living standards. As one correspondent to the magazine Kommunist' pointed out:

'The increase in retail prices will provoke dissatisfaction in the population and undermine the faith of the people in the projects of the Party and in perestroika".

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →