Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Hungarian market disaster

Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?, 1 September 1988 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 646 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

"Intensification of our participation in the international division of labour... the profitability of production is to be increased...

"A rapid increase in the production of those goods which can be economically manufactured and compete on the world "Instruments of economic regulation should be developed so that... differences in efficiency are more reliably reflected in profitability, and so that the accumulation and use of funds becomes more flexible at the level of the individual enter. prise".

These are extracts from the 1976 Five Year Plan for Hungary - the country that has been practising economic 'Gorbachevism' for 25 years. Has 'perestroika' Hungarian-style worked? The answer to that question is much discussed in the Kremlin.

-ff one or two Soviet factories go bandwor in the next months", commenced the Gordian (5 May 1988), "if the spectre of unemployment begins to stalk the steers of Moscow, or if insider dealing or a Sovier stock exchange suddenly rears s nead it is not implausible that the responsiole Soviet minister will pick up hs sesaront to seek advice in Budaces In a sungars experience illustrate! the dismena acts by all the rulers of th vorac uitra= JIT: work - but Mon manfonor ples market he mans soesn't work much better.

discons so Hungary are most often Budapest, Eastern Europe's most fashionable shopping centre. But by January this year, Hungary owed SIO. billion to Western banks - $1,000 per head of the population.

Real wages fell 8 per cent between 1979 and 1986. A small percentage of Hungarians, many of them privateenterprise profiteers, own BMWs and Mercedes; but 25 per cent are on or below the poverty line.

Unemployment is still low by Western standards - somewhere between 10,000 and 40,000 - but new measures state that wage levels will be maintained only in those factories and offices where the workforce is cut by five to ten per cent. 100 or so enterprises are viewed by the government as "permanent and hopeless loss-makers".

How does Hungarian perestroika work? Sandor Demjan, chair of the Hungarian Credit Bank, told the Financial Times (I1 September 1987): "We lend money to those companies which make money". Instead of getting interest-free central government grants for new investments, as in the past, Hungarian enterprises have to get loans at interest from a bank The Introduction of profit-oriented commercial banking, Hungary's 'Little Bang', has been followed up by opening banking in Hungary (like industry) to the partial involvement of foreign capital.

It used to be called Kadarism, after Janos Kadar, the leader who was imposed after the defeat of the revolution in 1956 but then turned to economic reform. Now they call it Grosznost, after the prime minister, Karoly Grosz, who is Thatcher and Kadar pushing the country further down the same path.

The gist is to combine central planning with the market, and maintain a good dose of economic dealings with the West.

The problem is that it brings the bad effects of market economics without doing away with the bad effects of bureaucratic management. Despite reams of proclamations about the need for profit to regulate the economy, bureaucratic string-pulling still counts for a great deal. Hungary's rulers can see no answer except to push further along the road of market economics.

There has been some political liberalisation - Hungary now has a semi. tolerated independent trade union - but only bit-by-bit. The Financial Times explained why.

"From experience, Mr Kadar knows that once the borde labelled 'reforms' is fully uncorked... the Far tessa's pent-up grievances will pour oux uncil nothing remains - least of all the party.

What Kadar knew Grosz has not forgotten. And Gartenter will be ing a watchful eye.

Scan page 11

Demonstration in the Ukraine This division of Europe into Eastern and Western 'spheres of influence' was 200- Solis

----- pull-quotes -----

Ero se she glamorous Vaci Street in = Rendertion in Eastern Eul

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 369–370: Reform or Revolution in Eastern Europe?

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →