Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[reviews Jean-Luc Godard's film "Breathless' - an avant-garde…]

Socialist Organiser no. 368, 25 August 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 1,195 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

reviews Jean-Luc Godard's film "Breathless' - an avant-garde sensation when it came out in 1959, and recently rereleased. "Breathless' has as much emotional weight as a seap bubble.

Its anti-hero, Michel, models himself on Bogart and seems to believe he's living inside a movie, where guns go bang but don't ever hurt anybody.

The girl he loves, Patricia, is an ambitious journalist, but she's weightless too, like Michel. They both seem to move in a dream world.

Godard's film was an attempt to show how modern life and culture are destroying us and making us lose our souls. The petty crook Michel steals cars for fun and uses his gun as if it were a toy, while Patricia goes along for the ride. These two don't seem to know or care about right and wrong; they seem to have no moral sense at all.

Yet Godard himself is only playing at condemning them. The two characters are simply too appealing to be reprehensible. Belmondo's Michel, with his apeing of Bogart, is foolish but charming, while Seberg's Patricia is stylish and mysterious. She's a bit of a blank, but you can see that's why Michel finds her irresistible.

Godard sends up his own ideas by the form the movie takes. It veers from being an arty, New Waveish essay to being a full-on B grade gangster film. Yet Godard just plays with the B grade formula. He doesn't hold us in suspense. The plot is spelled out (literally) for us, and the conventions are sent up. It's B grade drama as comedy.

The idea for the film came from a newspaper article, and the film has some of the simplicity of a tabloid article. Michel, the killer and thief who thinks he's a movie tough guy, is the kind of creation the tabloids helped bring into being - crims who want the notoriety of being on the front page.

Michel is a simple soul. In the movies he admires, the corpses walk off the set when the director calls Cut!" But Michel isn't in the movies and he has finally to come to terms with his actions and the consequences they bring.

Godard is kinder to his hero than to his heroine. Patricia doesn't have Michel's charming fecklessness. She WE Jean Paul Belmondo looking young gets impatient with him, and finally finds him a bit of a nuisance.

As a journalist and supposed contributor to the mass culture that's affecting us all, Patricia is shown as being in some way responsible for the way Michel has turned out. There's something a little cruel in the way Godard shows her emotionlessness. Godard mourns for Michel but he hasn't much sympathy for Patricia, the cool, anti-socialist bureaucracies. modern girl.

What's amusing about the film is the way Michel uses the movies to romanticise about his own sordid, hand-to-mouth existence, the way he interprets his life as a grand romantic adventure. Though he's a hood on the scrounge, he has an innocence that makes us like him all the same.

The film seems to have caught on. In a new print with up-to-thegays. minute subtitles, it's packing them in in London.

It probably makes a change having a genuine 1959 film for a change instead of all the eighties imitations that have been around the past few years. Whether it's value for money, though, is hard to say.

It's big on style, but there's nothing to it. You can watch it, and then walk out and forget it all in two minutes flat.

We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. 6/12 months sub. I enclose £ To: ser. PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA socinin for the ture needs of society the essence socialism, but a planned society is not necessarily a socialist one.

Democratic control and discussion of planning is necessary, too. To see what can happen in the absence of this, we can look at the recent attempts of the Hungarian, Czechoslovak and Austrian governments to plan their future energy resources.

Their plan involves a highly ambitious scheme for diversions and dams affecting some 200 km of the River Danube.

A massive reservoir is being established at Hrusov, near Bratislava, capital of Slovakia. The Danube is to be diverted from its old bed to a newly excavated concrete canal for some 25km. There are to be dams and hydro-electric generating systems between the reservoir and the canal, along the canal, and 100 km downstream at Nagymars in Hungary.

The Austrian and Czechoslovak sections of the scheme are well advanced but cannot be used until the Hungarian dam and 150 megawatt power station are ready. This is because the hvdro-electric turbines along the canal work best when water is allowed down it in massive surges, and there needs to be a barrage at Nagymars to break the flow.

The Hungarian government has done very little on their part of the scheme, pleading poverty. An additional factor, though, has been a growing movement of environmental protest at the project.

In particular, Duna Kor (the Danube Circle) has come up with substantial scientific objections, disconcerting official circles because of the strength of their arguments and of their considerable popularity in the country. Pressure on Hungary from its partners, and financial offers, have led it to go ahead from 1 October. Together has come a clampdown on Duna Kor and other groups.

Scientific objections continue to mount. A major objection is that the reservoir and canal will destroy the flood plain and river branch system in Southern Slovakia and north-west Hungary, the backboneof the Danube eco-system.

The flood plain, with its system of natural canals, is a giant fish hatchery and nursery, supplying lower reaches of the Danube with fish and nourishment for fish. Slovak scientists predict that the annual Danube fish catch will drop by three quarters.

More serious for the human population will be the effect on drinking water. Beneath Bratislava and the Hrusov reservoir lies Europe's largest natural reservoir of drinkable water — ten billion litres. At the bottom of the artificial reservoir will collect some 3 to 4 million cubic metres of sediment each year. This will contain bacteria and pollutants which will eventually percolate into the natural reservoir and pollute it. -Also, nearly half of Hungary's drinking water filters through the Danube's banks into the surroun ding soil, its purity depending on the high oxygen content and low organic material content. These in turn depend on the plant and animal life of the river. If these are harmed as predicted, the water will no longer be so fit for drinking.

A further drawback, would think, would be extra erosion of the river banks by the surges of water leading to rapid silting up of the Nagymars dam.

Karolyi Grosz's new government will find it difficult to choose between the financial cost of cancelling

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 368

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →