Against Arab chauvinism! Against Zionism!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-08-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
UN decision to partition Palestine [document published in SO 365-6] remains completely justified in relation to the new miniature 'State' of Jewish question, it will give it an Israel. Far even more tragic sharpness, not only by sharpening anti-semitic tendencies in Britain and in the countries of the Near East, but also and above all by crystallising the anti-imperialist sentiments of the Arab masses in all the neighbouring countries.
Even apart from the question of the attitude of the great powers, this State has no historic future. Subject to permanent crises and convulsions - permanent civil war having been avoided only by the complete purging of all the Arab villages on its territory - it will collapse in terrible butchery at a forthcoming stage of the Arab revolution, unless the Jewish proletariat separates itself in time from Zionist chauvinism.
The task of Jewish revolutionaries in Israel is to prepare that break. Their political line should remain unshakeably that of struggle against the partition of Palestine, for the reintegration of the territory of Israel into a united Palestine, in the framework of a Federation of Arab States of the Middle East which will guarantee the Jewish minority all the rights of national cultural autonomy.
The Arab feudal potentates, Farouk [king of Egypt] and Abdullah [king of Jordan], far from struggling against the partition of Palestine, seek above all to partition this unfortunate country between their own kingdoms. Their invasion aims above all to divert the attention of their own subjects from the mounting social tension in their countries.
At the same time, they have tried to exploit the anti-imperialist senSocialist rise of the world revolution' the right to their own state?
Even the mistakes and flaws of these to teach us.
timents of the masses to cover their own miserable capitulation to world capital (the Sudan affair, Iraq's and Jordan's treaties with the City, etc.) A few weeks of war have been enough to show the lamentable organisation of their military forces.
It is not under their leadership that the Arab masses will be able to reunify Palestine. Still less will the struggle against imperialism develop under their aegis, when even in the case of Palestine the Arab sovereigns are ready at the end of the day to have the compromise currently being worked out by the great powers imposed on them.
The opposition that the Arab masses everywhere manifest to the State of Israel and to the intervention of imperialism in this part of the world is quite another matter. This opposition is an incontestably progressive force which tomorrow will reinforce the general current of the Arab revolution in the Middle East.
Today, the masses remain in a waiting mood, as long as their own masters seem to be taking up the battle. When the treason of the latter is exposed to the world, the independent intervention of the Arab masses will be on the agenda.
It will permit at that point a convergence of the struggle against the SE15 4N/ The weakness of British imperialism after the Second World War, the consolidation of the native bourgeoisie in certain important colonies and the development of the working class, with the intensification of its social and anti-imperialist struggle, have forced Britain to withdraw its troops from certain colonies and to propose a readjustment of the defence of the Empire.
On the other hand, the native bourgeoisie has become a more trustworthy agent of indirect imperialist domination because of its growing fear in face of the organised working class, which has come out of this war stronger than ever. Particularly in the colonies and semi-colonies and in the colonial regions where American imperialism has penetrated as the foremost economic power, British imperialism is trying to pass over a part of the tasks of defence of the Empire and of the preparation of the next world war to American imperialism. On the other hand, Britain tries to keep as much economic influence and authority over the native bourgeoisie as it can.
That is what is going on at present in the Middle East. On the one hand, British imperialism is withdrawing some of its troops from Palestine and Iraq and leaving the UN, that is, American imperialism, the job of deciding the fate of Palestine; and, on the other hand, it is inciting 'holy war' in Palestine to gain political influence in the Arab world and it is trying to ally itself with the Arab states, as in the projected treaty with Iraq which would give British imperialism as much power as possible in conditions of indirect domination.
The antagonism between American and British imperialisms in this region manifests itself particularly on the question of how each of them can get most direct influence over the local economies and politics while sending the fewest troops.
The decision to divide Palestine, supported by the United States apparently in opposition to Britain, has created the following situation in the Arab East. Britain has gained the possibility of withdrawing some of its troops while enhancing its prestige in the Arab world. America, whose oil interests have not suffered by a certain loss of prestige, thanks to the economic links which tie the native bourgeoisie to American imperialism, has gained a direct agent there: the Zionist bourgeoisie which, through this, has become completely dependent on American capital and American policy. now has a justification to intervene militarily in the Middle East whenever that suits it.
The two imperialisms have created a situation of mounting chauvinism in which has become possible to crush the Arab working class and all the left movements in the whole Arab East - and the Russian support for the imperialist plan for dividing Palestine must equally be blamed for this.
The Arab feudalists and eoisie see the Zionist bourgeoisie not only as a competitor on the consumer goods market (as regards Egypt), but also on the market for imperialist agents in the Middle East.
By its racial war against the Jews of Palestine, the Arab League wants to limit the zone of activity of the Jewish industries and to prove to imperialism that it is a factor that can serve it even better than Zionism. At the same time, it favours imperialism in its largescale plans in the Middle East, and it is only too interested in following its orders with a view to using this chauvinist war to boost antiRussian sentiments and brutally to crush the Arab working class and all the left groups.
It sees the Zionist bogeyman and the Palestine problem in general as a good opportunity to divert the attention of the oppressed masses of the Arab countries from their social problems and from native and imperialist exploitation, to heighten racial hatred against minorities, and to recruit the jobless for the "jihad" in Palestine.
Scan page 9
In these circumstances, the traditional antagonism between the two cliques of the Arab League - the British Hashemite family on the one hand, and the American bloc of the Arabian oil king, of Egypt, and of the present regime in Syria on the other - manifests itself in their competition to have the most extreme and active intervention in Palestine, so as to be on the spot, to create established facts there, and to gather loot when it becomes necessary to comply with the final decisions of imperialism.
The Arab fedalists of Palestine, knowing that in such a racial war they are the natural leaders, want in this way to regain their authority over the Arab population of Paletine, an authority which had been weakened by the development during the war of While the revolt of 1936 began by a general strike, and was concentrated at the start in the cities, this time the main feature of the activity has been, from the start, military action by bands of rural guerillas. While in 1936-9 many of the "battles' were waged against British troops (even if the main drive was against the Jews), this time it is mainly the Jews who are attacked, while the functionaries of British imperialism and its officers and soldiers are treated in a friendly way or at most accused of not holding to the promised 'neutrality' In this way the Arab leaders have managed to create an atmosphere of extreme chauvinism, in which a provocation can lead to a massive massacre of Jewish workers, as in the retineries ot Haifa, by the backward sections of their Arab fellow-workers (some of the most advanced Arab workers did not participate in this action, and others rescued Jews), and where there are no more joint strike struggles by tions and urban elements of the coastal cities - the followers of Muss el-Alami) want order and security in the interests of business, but its 'national guard', in the midst of mass chauvinist attacks, is less and less important in comparison with the feudal-led guerillas.
Zionism, which seems to A diplomatic successes, has be at the height of its managed to help imperialism in which the Jewish masses have to learn what it means to be the scapegoat of imperialism.
The present civil war, which raises the chauvinism in the Jewish masses to the extreme, is itself in part the result of the Zionist chauvinism which accompanied the establishment of a closed Jewish economy-, Imperialism has managed to divert from itself the discontent of the Arab masses in the Middle East future, for the following reasons.
a) The wave of crushing of leftwing and working-class organisations in the Arab East developed before they were strong enough to defend themselves and hold their position. If that is true in the centres of the Arab working class, particularly in Egypt, then undoubtedly it will influence the more backward working class of Palestine.
b) In the near future, we have to expect a numerical decline of the Arab working class in Palestine, firstly as a result of the decline of work for the British Army and secondly as a result of the stoppages of work caused by the conflict. Unemployment among the Arab workers will not only threaten the limited conquests of recent years, but will create fertile ground for chauvinism and favour recruitment to feudal-led gangs.
c) The Arab Stalinists have lost part of their political and organisational influence because the masses workers, and so on constituted more than half the Arab working class, today almost three quarters of the Arab workers are employed on government works, in the oil companies, and in other industrial establishments. After the period of reaction and retreat, the starting point will be at a higher level than in 1939.
In the past the political activity of the revolutionary party among the Jewish workers was difficult because of their privileged position in the closed Jewish economy.
It will be all the more so today, now that this position is supported not only by American imperialism but also by Russia. The turn by the Jewish Stalinists, who have become the most enthusiastic advocates of the partition of Palestine and the creation of the Jewish state, further limit the points of contact which could have been used by the revolutionary party as a starting point for its activity among the Jewish workers.
On the other hand, the increased influence of the Arab feudal reaction is mirrored by an increased chauvinism on the Jewish side. There is a certain perspective for our work in the possibility of individually winning over Stalinists who have remained firmly opposed to partition and who may therefore recognise the treachery of Stalinist Russia.
The foregoing analysis 7 shows that in the near future (the next few months) we cannot expect largescale actions by the Arab workers, still less common actions by Arab and Jewish workers.
Until the weariness caused by the deterioration of the economic situation and the bloodshed makes itself felt - that will be the starting point of a new revolutionary rise - it is very probably that there will be a strengthening of chauvinism and massacres on a grand scale.
In the near future, our work will be limited essentially to maintaining links between the Arab and Jewish comrades, and to strengthening the cadres, particularly on the Arab side, as the basis for revolutionary activity in the future.
We must explain patiently to the most advanced sections of the Arab proletariat and the intelligentsia that racial military actions only deepen the gulf between Jews and Arabs and thus lead in practice to political division; that the fundamental factor and the main cause of division is imperialism; that the present battles are only strengthening imperialism; that, thanks to the bourgeois and feudal leadership of the Arab countries - which is the agent of imperialism — we have been beaten at one stage of the anti-imperialist struggle; and that we must prepare for victory at the next stage — that is, for the unification of Palestine and the Arab East in general - by creating the only force which can achieve these goals, the revolutionary proletarian party of the Arab East.
Our success will depend in large part on the consolidation in good time of the revolutionary communist forces in Egypt.
Haifa, January 1948.
----- pull-quotes -----
SOCIALS S ORGANISER Democracy,. not revengel
cy, Not lus 13p
Revenge': post from