Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[fice by a Protestant strike. There followed ten…]

Socialist Organiser no. 368, 25 August 1988 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,040 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

fice by a Protestant strike.

There followed ten years in which Britain tried to stabilise Northern Ireland by beating down the Catholics, the Catholics remained unquellable, and bitterness grew on all sides. The Anglo-Irish deal of November 1985 marked an attempt by Britain to find a new direction, but so far it has meant little change.

Repression, repression, and more repression - that has been the answer of successive British governments to Northern Ireland over almost all of the last twenty years. It erodes the civil rights of everyone, and it does not work.

Northern Ireland needs a political programme on which Catholic and Protestant workers can begin to unite — a federal united Ireland, with regional autonomy for the Protestant-majority area, and with some confederal links between Ireland and Britain. I have no illusions about magically "transforming the TUC's timid and bureaucratic objections to Hammond into a principled defence of trade unionism" (Tom Rigby, SO 366). But I do believe that the definitive split between the EETPU and the TUC will inevitably take out into the workplaces disputes which until now have been kept within the TUC corridors.

David Felton reported in the Independent of 8 August: "The EETPU has... drawn up plans for a recrultment war. Senior officials say that at least five percent of the members of any union are discatisfied and ripe for poaching...

A group of large trade unions plans a recruitment war aimed at -glic the electricians' union after it has been expelled from the TUC next month... Most officials now regard a bitter recruitment battle as inevitable... The s naS Bave sTae eBer fall on the siste to prepare for the atMore recently the EETPU has won the right to represent Docklands Light Railway staff in competition with the rail unions.

No doubt the TUC leaders will bungle this membership war. No doubt their talk of 'strangling the EETPU is hot air. No doubt only a small part of the EETPU membership will be won over to TUC unions.

But we can't afford to wash our hands of the whole business. We can't afford to be on the sidelines. Whatever the bunglings and hypocrisy of the TUC leaders, the membership war will be about basic principles of trade On the one side, the BETPU will be bold and uncotrained in pushing no-strike deals. It will get a lot of backing from employer and the press. On the other side, the TUC leaders will be pushed into some activity, even if only to defend their dues income.

This battle matters. We would not have chosen to fight it this way, but it will be fought whether we like it or not. Socialists must throw our full weight on the side of defending the TUC and pulling as many members as possible out of the EETPU.

"Staying and fighting" in the EETPU will mean being on the sidelines. This will be an EETPU with leaders emboldened by their split from the TUC, with more new members handed to them by eager employers, and without most of its militants (for they will leave whatever we say). A struggle by a few socialists inside such an EETPU will have no grip at all on the battle for or against no-strike business-unionism which is about to unfold.

Martin Thomas, Islington.

Scan page 8

We continue our series of reprints on The Trotskyists and the Formation of Israel' with a document issued by the Palestinian When the left today writes or speaks about the 1948 Israeli-Arab war, it is a story of anti-Arab atrocities by the Jews, and no more. The clear implication is that the Arab side of the war deserved support, whatever Marxists in 1948 saw it quite differently. Of course they condemned anti-Arab atrocities. But some Trotskyists internationally (as we'll see from later reprints in this series) backed the Jews; the Trotskyists in Palestine itself condemned both sides as chauvinist. They could all see that the Arab forces were led by corrupt feudalists, manipulated by British imperialism, and engaged in a "racial war"

We also print here an introduction to the Palestinian Trotskyists? document by the official magarine of the world Trotskyist movement, whicl published it in 1948. The introduction softens the line considerably. Here the mass Arab chauvinism indicted by the Palestinian Trotskyists has mystically become a force for "the Arab revolution", which drives forward despite the crushing of socialist and working-class organisation among the Arabs. It is a first example of a way of thought which would grip the whole Trotskyist movement, in which any nationalist mobilisation or disturbance, whatever its form, is automatically a 'new By 1948 it had become plain that the Trotskyists' position of 1946-7 (document reprinted in SO 365-6) was flawed. The Trotskyists had maintained that the formation of a Jewish state was impossible; it now existed. The Trotskyists had insisted that the main issue in Palestine was Introduction by the magazine Quatrieme Internationale (1948). The theses of our Palestinian comrades, which we publish here, were drafted before the formal proclamation of the State of Israel and the invasion of Palestine by the armies of the Arab states.

The theses explain the basic developments, so it will be sufficient here to outline briefly the position of the Fourth International on the recent events.

What we said at the time of the Trotskyists in 1948.

the faults of its leadership. feudal lords and the terrible social misery, and the struggle against imperialism and Zionism. To prepare, as from today, this convergence, is the task of the revolutionaries in the Middle East who, while struggling against any chauvinist or antisemitic current, will concentrate their propaganda on the following slogans: • Down with the partition of Palestine! For a united and independent Arab Palestine, with national minority rights for the Jewish community. • Down with imperialist intervention in Palestine! Out with all the foreign troops and the UN "mediators' and observers'! For the right of the Arab masses to determine their own future. For the election of a Constituent Assembly through universal secret suffrage! For the agrarian revolution! • Down with the Arab League, instrument of imperialism! Down with the corrupt kings and the feudal exploiters! Long live the Arab socialist revolution in the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 368

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →