Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why a people's militia is best militia is best

Socialist Organiser no. 368, 25 August 1988 · scan p. 4 · about 407 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Ray Moore, a training officer with Terget workers into the munitions factories. Tony Dale (letters, SO 367) criticises the slogan of a people's militia as confused.

-It is an old socialist slogan. The Marxist movement before 1914 demanded people's militias in place of standing armies. Following discussions with French comrades, Leon Trotsky took it up again in the Action Programme for France (1934). He repeated it in the Transitional Programme (1938):

*Substitution for the standing army of a people's militia, indisselebly linked up with factories, mines, farms, ete."

Trotsky and his comrades, in documents like the Transitional Programme, also called for workers' militias - but in a different context. They advocated workers' militias as the workers' response to organised violent strike-breaking and fascist gangs. They advocated people's militias as their alternative to the standing army.

Of course, Trotsky and the other Marxists of the first half of this century may have been wrong. But I think not.

In advanced capitalist countries where the wage-working class is the great majority of the population, a people's militia would be a workers' militia by sheer force of numbers. You might want to exclude a tiny minority of former exploiters and rulers from militia service, but to exclude small shopkeepers, professional people and so on would be stupid, unnecessarily alienating such people from socialism.

In an underdeveloped country where wage-workers are only a minority, it would be doubly necessary to organise a people's rather than just a workers" militia. We do not advocate military dictatorship by the working class over a peasant majority!

So people's militia is the fundamental slogan, workers' militia the subsidiary one. This issue is part of the general one of the socialist revolution being democratic, more democratic than Westminster flim-flam.

We raise the slogan of a workers" militia when it is directly and visibly an issue of strike-breaking or fascist attacks on workers' meetings, union and party offices and so on. We call for a: people's militia as our democratic and socialist alternative to the military and paramilitary forces of the capitalist This approach is doubly necessary after 60 years of Stalinism. Just the slogan "workers' militia" would convey to many people the prospect of being ruled over by a private army of the socialist and working-class parties.

Any slogan can be used in a reformist way, but I do not see why "people's militia" is worse on that score than "workers" militia"

Colin Foster, Peckham.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 368

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →