Don't stop the carnival
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-08-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
says Eric 1. In this election for Leader and Deputy Leader, Tony Benn and I By Gerry Bate! for the Notting Hill Carnival to be banned. The recent rampage through the London underground by a group of kids who had just gate crashed a gig in Wormwood Scrubs, has added extra oil to the fire. Violence is too high, the critics say, and the Carnival is too risky. -Last year a 23-year old man was stabbed to death at the event.
But the idea that stopping the Carnival will reduce violence is ludicrous. In fact, it will raise temperatures. For the annual Carnival is an important date in the calendar of black people in Britain, especially black youth. To ban it is to clamp down on a major cultural event. Almost certainly, the result will be more violence.
Underlying the 'stop the carnival' is a racist theme. Black people are percieved as almost universally violent and threatening. 'Carnival safety fears over reggae rampage' declared the Daily Mail. It is covert racism, perhaps, but racism all the same.
Riot
Calls for a ban are not new, of course. The claim that the Carnival is a violent event is longstanding. In 1976, the Notting Hill carnival saw a major riot between youth and the police, foreshadowing the riots of Summer 1981. In the press at the time, the violence was potrayed as 'the blacks' needlessly having a go at the police.
In fact the police provoked it. It was part of an escalating sprial of police repression of black people and black people's resistance.
Violence at events such as the Notting Hill Carnival cannot be understood separately from racism in our society. Those who want to ban it are the same people who excuse, justify or perpetrate racism, including the Tories and the police. - Stewarding organised by the local community is the way to stop violence at the Carnival. The police should be kept out of it. They are seen as an alien force by most people there, who only make things worse. The carnival must go ahead!