Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Where is Socialist Worker going?

Socialist Organiser no. 367, 18 August 1988 · scan pp. 10–11 · Clive Bradley · about 2,167 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

*Zionism' is also directed at in- DISTINGU jority of Jews are Zionists, this is in Throughout it's existence (from practice a hostility towards Jews, or the Socialist Review Group in the at least all Jews who are not anti- '50s, through to International Zionists. We think the results of Socialists in the '60s and "70s) the criticised the SWP and others for it. differentiated politically from But even this has been interpreted mainstream 'orthodox' Trotskyism as an attack on the Palestinians. on a wide range of issues. Indeed, Oppostion to Israel has now until 1968 when they made a become a fetish for the SWP. The dramatic and sudden switch and When is a public meeting not open to the public? Answer: when it is held by the Socialist The SWP National Committee has just decided to ban supporters of Socialist Organiser from its public meetings. This follows last month's ejection of SO sellers from the SWP's *Marxism 88 summer school. We have been declared "beyond the pale' of political debate - too bad even to talk to. In this we are hardly the first, and nor will we be the last. But the signs are that the SWP's degeneration is accelerating.

What are the signs? There are two main aspects. First, an astonishing political shift away from the SWP's own bedrock tradition towards the worldview typical of 'average Trotskyism' (or what they would call 'orthodox Trotskyism' , which they have always detested). Second, an apparent contempt both for democracy general, and for rational terms of debate: instead of debate, they employ (and their leading figures do it most crudely) cheap demagogy.

The SWP have not given an explanation of the ban on Socialist Organiser, but certainly the underlying theme is outrage at our alleged "Zionism' What they mean is that we have a two states' position on the Israel/Palestine conflict, and that we do not share their relentless hostility to 'Zionism' . That is that we do not support the destruction of the state of Israel. We try to understand Zionism historically rather than simply denounce it. Socialist Organiser is not, of course, Zionist in any sense other than that we defend Israel's right to exist. We do not defend its policies, its oppression of the Palestinians, its alliance with the United States or any other of its obnoxious features. if we are Zionists, so too are most opponents of Zionism in Israel. (So too, incidentally, is the majority of the PLO!)

In fact, the SWP are today simpexplicitly reject the idea that Israel Jewish workers can play any role in making the socialist revolution. The "smashing' of Zionism will be carried through by the Arab workers of the region, whether Jewish workers agree with it or not. Oddly, the SWP describe the result of this process as a "democratic' state. They compare the situation to South Africa, although the resemblance is utterly superficial.

The SWP's hostility towards dividual Zionists. Since the vast mathis are deeply pernicious, and nave Socialist 0:g-The Socialist Workers" Party is a prominentparticipant in the Chesterfield movement. It seeks to engage in debate with the Labour left. Yet recently it has adopted worse and worse Stalinisttype methods in debate. More and more they rely on irrational and hysterical methods of argument. Clive Bradley looks at the direction the SWP is taking and asks where it will lead.

question of Israel for them defines all other political questions, as if to be a 'Zionist' on this issue defines you as a 'Zionist' on all issues. It has been detatched from rational criticism of the Israeli state and become the question of questions.

Fixing the label "Zionist' on Socialist Organiser serves the purpose of declaring us outside 'respectable' socialist opinion. It is a way of declaring us not worth listening to, or debating with or allowing into meetings.

For example, Alex Callinicos, one of the SWP's top intellectuals, recently turned down a debate with Iranian Marxists on the Gulf War. As an excuse, he particularly insisted against sharing a platform with 'groups who support the terrorism of the Israeli state against the Palestinian people . He meant Socialist Organiser.

This is of course, pure libel. Either it is conscious libel — that is, Callinicos is deliberately lying. Or, if he really believes it, hysterical; it suggests an extraordinary inability to debate in rational terms. Whichever, it is typical of the SWP today.

Lies, disinformation, demagogy and hysteria characterise current SWP methods of argument. They are in fact, the characteristic methods of Stalinism. Of course the SWP is still a long way from being a party like the Stalinist parties in the '30s. But the SWP members should think about what they are building.

Why do they refuse to debate? Why do they lie about other people's political position? What are they afraid of?

SWP has been a distinct tendency, 367. 18 August Is Cliff following Healy? proclaimed themselves "Leninist' "building the revolutionary party, the Cliff group was explicitly antiLeninist. The Leninist theory of the party they considered *substitutionist. But their origins were in Trotskyism, and they formed a part of the Trotskyist tradition broadly defined.

The Cliff tendency was one of the most sharply anti-Stalinist Marxist groups; 'state capitalism' was the label they pinned on the system in the USSR to show that they hated it. It was not only the USSR: China, Cuba etc were all also considered 'state capitalist' - and this was seen as the more-or-less inevitable product of "Third World' revolutions in which the working class was unable to play a decisive role.

The actual event which led to the formation of Cliff's group as an independent entity was the war in Korea which began in 1950. Distinet from the rest of the Trotskyist movement, they were neutral viewing North Korea merely as a proxy for the imperialist USSR against the imperialist USA.

Whether they were right or wrong about Korea (and they ignored the independent dynamic of the Korean national movement), this attitude is in important respects radically different from the SWP's current line, for example on the Iran/Iraq war. Today the bare fact of the United LUTI States' hostility to Iran dictates support for Iran in its 'anti-imperialist' war (against Iraq). All more subtle issues are phased out in the name of militant anti-imperialism. Those of us who have argued against support for Iran (or Iraq, or the USA) are denounced for *the politics of neutrality". If they were logical they would denounce us in the usual terms employed by the 'orthodox' Trotskyists they used to despise, as "Third campists"!

The SWP have been victims of precisely this accusation trom their very inception and should know better. Now they practice vicious demagogy on such serious subjects.

There are other big differences, and not only with their line on Korea. A characteristic feature of 'orthodox' Trotskyism is a view of events which collapses all details -indeed practically all concrete analysis into generalised assumptions. 'Analysis' is a matter of deducing what should be happening according to preconceived schemas, rather than actually analysing what is happening. The schemas are derived from a more-or-less crude division of the world into "imperialism' and 'the revolution.' On Iran, the SWP have collapsed into a variant of this 'campist' worldview (with the difference that the USSR is one of the "imperialist's'). Moreover, and what is particularly striking, it is a variant in which there is not even a superficial attempt to relate their preconceptions to facts. There is little actual analysis of the Gulf War; what little there is has been contradicted by the actual course of developments (such as the idea that the US wanted to see Khomeini's! regime replaced), without the sWe batting a self-critical eyelid.

All this might suggest that the SWP is retreating, bit by bit, from all the theoretical 'gains' of its tendency. It is difficult to imagine the ardent Iranian patriots of 1988 as neutralists on Korea. In fact there is more to it. Theory for the SWP and its predecessors has always played, as leading SWP writer Duncan Hallas once put it, -an 'operational' role: it serves to justify rather than inform, SWP current practice. Hallas of course meant that it was adequate to grasp the essence of reality, even if not fully to understand it. But in fact major aspects of the SWP's theory, like the 'permanent arms economy (which was meant to explain postwar capitalist boom and stability) have quietly been shunted to the back of the book shelf, if not actually dropped in the bin.

They don't define themselves on the left by distinct ideas. Rather, they try to promote themselves as the 'hardest' people on the left, the ones who never have to water down their politics for whatever reason. Being "hard' on the Gulf War, or Israel/Palestine fits into this - like a kind of advertising gimmick. 'You want to fight imperialism? says the SWP. We're the hardest anti-imperialists'. If in fact the left suffers from prejudices on these issues, the SWP simply presents itself as the most consistently prejudiced.

Where will it all end? It is now almost impossible to conduct a discussion with the SWP, even outside their meetings. But lies and hysteria cannot sustain a political tendency forever. The SWP should think about the experience of the Healy group (Workers' Revolutionary Party).

For the Healyites, selfproclaimation as 'the revolutionary party® accompanied increasingly systematic lying about opponents: Cliff himself was often accused of particularly heinous crimes. For them too, 'Zionism' became a watchword in heresy-spotting. (They were to be the first group to call Socialist Organiser "Zionist ). Politics, and especially "polemic became a way to sustain their organisation: denunciation, rather than rational argument, was used to keep the membership in line, and to "rally the faithful'. But gradually the organisation declined and eventually it blew apart.

It may seem fantastic to compare the SWP with the Healy group (or with Stalinism). But they are heading in that direction very very quickly. Members of the SWP need to act fast to stop the Tot.

Scan page 11

Though NOLS have hardly any sabbatical officers this year they do have quite a few Area Convenors up and down the country.

At NUS Summer Convention last month the NOLS profile was small and lacked intent and the will to tackle the threats facing students. SSiN held two fringe meetings each with about 25 people attending. Here we had an open forum for new officers to discuss strategy and tactics for fighting voluntary membership and loans.

Regrettably, only one NOLSie turned up to discuss with us. NOLS like us, advertised two fringe meetings but, not surprisingly, only managed to get one off the ground. The other never started due to a genuine lack of punters — they were all at the SSiN fringe meeting.

NOLS' profile at NUS Areas Political Convention a few weeks later was markedly increased — all their celebrities turned out, lots of pool playing and buying of drinks for independents went on, in fact the NOLSies had such a good time they forgot all about politics. So much so that they had to organise a NOLS Area Convenors conference at Labour Party HQ in Walworth Road to make up for lost time.

It's clearly the case that the conference at HQ was a direct result of the distinctly apolitical convention a few weeks earlier. Because if it wasn't Rachel Pitkeathley, our NOLS NC member, would surely have been in on the discussion. After all she was at the last NOLS NC meeting and there was no mention of organising an Area Convenors conference then. Unless, of course, NOLS are not serious about building a strong campaigning fightback against the Tory attacks.

Simon Buckby, NOLS/NUS officer, invited all area convenors who are members of NOLS and left independent to discuss and debate voluntary membership, loans and the government inquiry. That is, all area convenors except two, both SSiN supporters.

Still it's reassuring to know that some things never change - the NOLSies are still the miserable carving bureaucrats they ever were.

The NOLS prioritised campaign for the next year is the Poll Tax. This is undoubtedly a good issue to build a campaign around. At present the NOLSies are supporting non-compliance, though they did say that they did not want anyone to be imprisoned. Whether what's oing on in the Scottish Labour Party Executive will have any effect on NOLS about non-compliance is hard to tell.

We should be building support for the campaign and getting a solid base in favour of non-compliance. Students should be setting up or joining existing local Poll Tax groups. This is an obvious and important way of getting students integrated in the Labour Party and the community. Poll Tax groups should be set up on campus. These must include members of all tre unions represented in your college and should be initiated through the campus joint trade union committee at the start of the term. Students

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 367

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →