A political or moral critique of Stalinism?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-08-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
14 Nov 2026, after a reader report: a letter, signed Neil Stonelake, Cardiff, answering Laurens Otter's letter and Duncan Chapel's reply (SO 366). Transcribed from the scan of page 4, replacing the machine reading, which had cut the headline to 'A politica moral' and run on into the opening of Jill Mountford and Mark Osborn's Leon Trotsky feature (now a separate item). 'thier', 'preceeding', 'Schactman' and 'comrade Otters' are as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
Laurens Otter’s letter on the class nature of the Soviet Union and Duncan Chapel’s reply raise some interesting points.
Comrade Otter asserts that SO is inconsistent in regarding the Soviet Union as a degenerated worker’s state, as opposed to a new form of class society with a new ruling class.
Comrade Chapel states (quite correctly) that the ruling caste of the Soviet Union has no power to transfer its control of the means of production to succeeding generations. This is a key point, thrown into sharp relief by the struggle for ascendency between the Gorbachev faction and the rump of the Brezhnev clique. When Brezhnev & Co left centre stage, so to speak, the offices and power they had conferred on members of thier entourage (including in Brezhnev’s case several members of his family) were quickly removed. However, this doesn’t in itself affect the argument that the bureaucracy can regenerate itself, unless one accepts that the Gorbachev clique represents a change in quality rather than quantity.
Similarly, the export of capital is not in itself germane to the discussion. Actually, the invasion of Afghanistan did involve the export of capital in certain forms. This doesn’t per se tie us down to any specific societal model of the USSR. It is rather an illustration of its relation to and interaction with states organised on the basis of monopoly capitalism. No state exists in a vacuum. In Hungary, for example, the introduction of the new economic mechanism in 1966 was facilitated by both the preceeding long boom in the west and its contingent phase of detente allowing greater production for export. This didn’t and doesn’t make Hungary into a capitalist country — unless one wishes to base an entire political analysis on trade figures. It merely expresses the relationship between two inherently antagonistic ruling elites who happen to be under pressure simultaneously to deliver the goods to workers in their respective spheres of influence.
The fundamental flaw in comrade Otter’s analysis goes beyond the precise nature of the economic relations between capitalism and the Stalinist states. It is much, much older.
In short, Laurens hasn’t made clear if we should regard Stalinism and the Stalinist states from a political or a moral viewpoint. It’s easy to do a competent hack job of spotting similarities between monopoly capitalism, Stalinism and (say) fascism. James Burnham made a living out of this sort of thing in his later years. This is after all, what academics are paid for. The trouble with this approach is that it relies (at best) on empirical backup of fundamentally moralistic arguments.
(For example “Stalin killed more people than Hitler, we shall now count them.”)
Comrade Otter would doubtless forgive me for calling him a moralist. He does, after all, represent a strand on the left older than Marxism. But this is where we part company. The slogan “Workers’ Liberty, East and West’ is a political slogan, not a comforting moral axiom. As a paper SO has always been consistently anti-Stalinist, but not from a moral angle.
I don’t believe, as a rationalist that abandonment of the ‘degenerated workers state’ label would in itself be an abandonment of the ‘one true faith’, but Laurens must give concrete reasons for his alternative. More importantly he must spell out what this means in day-to-day political terms. For example, if Stalinism is as bad as (say) fascism and worse than capitalism, whose support does the left enlist in fighting it? Our own ruling class?
Over the past fifty years people such as James Burnham, Max Schactman, Tony Cliff and Milovan Djilas (at least two of whom started out as socialists) have adopted analyses similar in style and content to comrade Otters. Schactman ended up supporting the US war in Vietnam. What price morals?
I look forward to comrade Otter’s reply.
Neil Stonelake Cardiff