Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Bill of rights oes too far

Socialist Organiser no. 367, 18 August 1988 · scan p. 4 · Tony Dale · about 492 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

In the Socialism for the 1990s' pamphlet, the bill of rights on the state (page 6), in attempting to popularise socialist ideas has bent over too far - the end result being confusion.

The article rightly raises the idea of replacing the police and army. It then goes on to say it is to be replaced by a 'people's militia'. It is with this slogan that confusion reigns.

What does a 'people's militia' mean? Basically it seems that the army is to be replaced by an armed body of 'people'!

Which class will it be based on? Which class interests will it defend? Which class will control it? All these questions raise two answers -workers or bosses?

The idea which needs to be raised is not the confused one of a 'people's militia' but that of a 'workers' militia", Our fundamental task has to be the destruction of the present state and the creation of a new state based on workers control. It is not possible to gradually transform the character of the capitalist state. To suggest such gradual changes is to either underestimate the power of the capitalist state or imprison ourselves inside the limits of that The destruction of the capitalist state is obviously not on the immediate agenda of the labour movement. The police, the courts, etc. are generally seen as more or less impartial. The only problem seen is one of curbing the excesses of certain parts of the police, army, elc.

We need to link up with the accritique tivists to fight for democratic demands, eg. increasing the powers of police committees. At the same time we must sharply counterpose to the present model of policing society the idea of a radically different system based on workers militias.

The Bill of Rights proposed in the article raises another interesting demand - 'Police duty should be made a part-time job of every citizen, like jury service.' Socialism raises the prospect of re-integrating the "law and order' functions of the state back into local communities. Workers militias will execute these functions in a radically different way than today's police. The radical difference comes from the different class they will serve.

To present the enforcement of working class socialist law and order as simply everybody being a copper for a few hours is misleading and not very appealing.

The basic issue is not whether everybody can have a bash at being PC Plod. The basic issue is that law and order will be under the control of the local communities and based on a fundamentally different set of principles. Principles founded on the protection of individual rights within the structure of the collective ownership of the resources and wealth of society.

So, to sum up, the attempt to put forward our basic ideas in a more accessible way is right, but let's mke sure we don't end up creating confusion on what our final goal is.

Tony Dale Manchester

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 367

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →