Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Truly Independen

Socialist Organiser no. 367, 18 August 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 664 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The laws are to those who 1 hurtful to tho not.

JJ Rouseau The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets, steal bread, the same spirit of majestic equality. The master and his butler, the mistress and her maid, the company manager and the shopfloor labourer will all be equal - at least in respect of the amount they will be required to pay. Everyone will pay equally, but some more equally than others. The poll tax is not some mad caprice on the part of the Tories, even if as late as 1983 the Tories could still declare that the rating system is basically sound but needs some improvement. It is the latest act of aggression of a government which has decisively abandoned post-war consensus politics and is intent upon restructuring society in its own repugnant image.

The attack is ideological, political and economic.

The Tories have an ideological commitment to a dog-eat-dog society where everyone looks to their own and rejects collectivist principles. 'Economic success' should be rewarded with more 'economic success' not 'penalised' by being partially redistributed to help the needy. The poll tax is based on exactly such a philosophy, levied on each individual in the hope that (s)he will elevate concern for a minimal poll tax above the need to provide for collective need.

The Tories, whatever their rhetoric about freedom of the individual, are politically committed to a strong, centralised • state. Checks on free trade unionism, increasingly overt censorship and more powers for the forces of coercion are just so many aspects of that political drive. The poll tax too belongs to that ruthless centralising drive, increasing central government powers over local authorities and reducing local authority accountability to its electorate. poll tax is: to replace, necessitates an army of In 1972 direct working class action broke the Tory industrial relations act and freed the Penton ville dockers. Defiance on the same lines can beat the tand it."

The Tories were re-elected for a third term of office in the face of a half-hearted challenge from a Labour leadership lacking the stomach for a real merciless fight The Independent continues to go up in my estimation. Last Tuesday's edition was particularly outstanding. Not only did it carry a brilliantly written analysis of the phenomenon of 'underemployment' (penned by a correspondent who modesty prevents me from naming, but who is clearly one of the outstanding analytical minds of our age), but also it devoted just 12 words to the story that gripped the rest of Fleet Street: "Royal Baby: The Duchess of York has given birth to a daughter", was the sum total of the Indie's coverage, at the bottom of its page 2 News in Brief column.

The next day's Daily Mail even suggested that the Indies's Andreas Whittan Smith might be *the first Republican newspaper editor since John Wilkes brought out the 'North Britain' in 1762 and was thrown into the tower."

The near-hysterical Fergie Mania of last week's tabloids was predicatable, the "serious' papers were not the Daily Telegraph gave the story 20 column inches on its front page and The Times gave it a front page picture and 1000 words. Worst of all, the Guardian (perhaps reflecting the fashionable Marxism Todav view that in this epoch of Thatcherism the good old monarchy isn't such a bad thing after all devoted 2,000 words, 2 pictures and a whimsical editorial to the event. This on the day that news of ceasefires in the Gulf and Angola, Loyalist shootings in Ulster and a surprise rise in the interest rates broke.] Questioned by the Daily Mail, Whittan Smith protested "a charming young couple have had a baby. That is all the story there is. The rest 1s completely synthetic he's a man who knows how to keep his head.

A certain Russel Lewis has.

----- pull-quotes -----

Anatole France. The Tories poll tax is permeated by

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 367

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →