Why the French miners are right to fight Whetton's
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-08-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
same thing protecting jobs and keeping pits open.
International capitalism is working towards the same end. In France, Belgium, Germany or Britain they are determined to screw the mineworkers, privatise the pits, and extract every ounce of profit by introducing flexible working, etc. There are lessons not just for French miners but for every other miner - there is an attack on the standards, practices and conditions that have been taken for granted for years. We have got a duty, whichever country we happen to live in, to support one another, One of the reasons advanced on the left for going into the Common Market was that we would be able to support one another as international socialists a lot better. I don't think that has come to fruition, but it has certainly got to be argued not just in the pits but throughout industry.
One of the big differences between the French miners' dispute and ours has been their ability to pull in support from power workers who recognise that it is a threat against them.
I'm glad to see that at last some miners who were assualted by the police during the miners' strike are now receiving compensation. I know one case very well - Sid Richmond, an ex-NACODS man who was a pensioner at the time of the strike.
It was disgraceful what they did to him. They dragged him out of a car, roughed him up and handcuffed him so tight that his hands began to bleed. So I'm glad to see that they've got victory at last.
It's taken over three years since the end of the strike to make the congratulate them.
There are demands for the reintroduction of internment. What workers need to bear in mind is that what is being done in Ireland today could well be introduced into Britain tommorow. Internment isn't just a way of trying to break the IRA. It's an attempt by the state to legalise whatever action it chooses to take against people who oppose it. That includes trade unionists, political activists and not just "terrorists"
For a long while I have said that Ireland is an Irish problem and will be solved by the Irish. International arms have never brought peace to a country. The Americans learnt that to their cost in Vietnam. The Soviet Union found that out to its cost in A political solution is needed, not a military one. One of the greatest tragedies | see about Northern negotiating a solution is what is needed, but the state doesn't want that. The state is quite prepared to use Northern Ireland as a training ground and a battlefield so long as it stays across the Irish Sea.
People have to recognise that there can be no military solution in Ireland. It has to be a politically negotiated settlement. The introduction of internment will not damp the situation down. In fact it could well exacerbate it.
I've no comment to make on the birth of the royal baby except to say that the whole royal family are parasites on society. While I have no axe to grind against them personally, I am opposed to the institution of Royalty being used against uS.
Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM, South Yorkshire, and a former Secretary of Bevercotes NUM, Notts.
Socialist USA over scientific fraud, and James (The Amazing') Raudi, magician and exposer of 'paranormal' claims.
Last week, they reported in Nature that Benveniste's findings were a delusion: • due care had not been shown in the experiments; • contamination of the test tubes was possible, since they were kept in rows next to each other; • the results were not always repeatable (a sign of uncontrolled factors affecting things): • numerical results agreed with each other more closely than would be expected even with a genuine homeopathic effect (a sign of observer bias);| • the Nature squad's own experiment showed no homeopathic effect.
Benveniste's response was bitter and angry, accusing Maddox's of amateurism and incompetence, exerting psychological pressure, and implying dishonesty.
Letters to Nature suggested ways for the so-called effect to have been caused accidentally, criticised Nature for printing the report in the first place, or supported Benveniste's results (from a team who had shown a homeopathic treatment for hayfever to be effective).
Other comments on the affair range from "a load of crap" (from a professor of immunology) to more measured observations that the Nature squad had not in fact disproved Benveniste's findings.