Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[SUBSCRIBE! Please send me 6/12 months sub. I…]

Socialist Organiser no. 366, 11 August 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 1,661 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

SUBSCRIBE!

Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E To: Socialist Organiser. PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Belinda Weaver reviewe 'The The reviewa Unbearable Lightness of Being'. Watching *The Unbearable Lightness of Being' resulted in the Unmistakable Discomfort of the Bottom. At three hours or so, it's the first film I've seen a while that had an interval — just an excuse for the cinema to flog a few drinks and sweets. and show us the same twenty ads we saw before the film started.

But I still enjoyed watching it. Once you've made the mental adjustment for the more than one and a half hour's worth, you settle back and hope that what you see will justify the extra time. The film did take you into quite a different world, and I felt a bit odd emerging into rush-hour Baker Street. I expected to find myself in sixties Prague.

Based on the novel by Milan Kundera, the film charts the sexual history of Tomas, a young, single brain surgeon in Prague. Tomas isn't political, and neither are his friends. They are doing well by Czech standards. They find the regime absurd rather than horrifying. As the liberalisation of the *Prague Spring' develops prior to the Russian takeover, they view the bureaucrats as an inept and almost comical bunch who'll soon be seen off by the bright young things. From page 9 page present the Jewish population of Palestine has bent all its efforts towards the strengthening of its autonomous economic and political positions. But already the radical section of the Jewish nationalist youth has become aware of the pointlessness of these efforts of "conciliation" and "manoeuvre" on the part of the Jewish Agency to obtain from imperialism or from the great powers unlimited immigration and the setting-up of a Jewish state.

The current wave of terrorism by the "Irgun Zwei Leumi" and "Stern" gangs constitutes acts of despair by this minority, used and then abandoned by the bourgeois RE WE he film objectifies women In the meantime, Tomas get on tist. While on a visit to a spa, he eets another woman, Tereza, who ds up moving into Tomas's flat id tying him reluctantly down to a rt of monogamy. Tomas loves reza, but monogamy to him is bearably weighty. He feels ¡htest and happiest when he can llow up a chance encounter with a sman, any woman. leaders of the Zionist movement, and coming from the impasse into which the whole movement has strayed. Of course, this terrorism of despair does not in itself constitute the path to a solution to the Palestine problem. Quite the contrary. In the face of the terrorism, the Arab feudalists and bourgeois can manage to create an atmosphere of artificial "solidarity" between the masses and imperialism, and sharpen the hostility between Arab and Jewish workers. From the military point of view, these acts can only accelerate the establishment of an alien British police force in Palestine, which is the aim of the whole post-war imperial policy. But as the last stage of Zionism, terrorism, yielding no concrete result, can make the most conscious and active elements of the anti-socialist bureaucracies.

Lightness and heaviness are the words which express the characters's feelings about life and relationships. Sabina feels lightest when she is carrying on secret atfairs; she'd feel weighted down if people knew. Tereza can't take infidelity lightly like Tomas can.

Tomas would probably have carried on his feckless, charming way but for the rather heavy clampdown of Russian tanks in Prague. He finds it too oppressive, and flees to Geneva and 'freedom' . But Tereza Jewish masses open to reconsidering the whole question of Zionism and the solution of the Jewish question. It is this reconsideration which the Fourth International should prepare for at the present stage.

Eventual unity between Jews and Arabs should first come through the abolition of all racist ideology and practice on the part of the Jews. • Down with exclusively Jewish enterprises! For the hiring of Arab workers in all the industry of the country! • Down with separate Jewish and Arab trade unions! For the setting up of Jewish-Arab trade unions! • Down with the camouflaged boycott of Arab or Jewish products. Down with the "closed Jewish economy""! For the mutual integration of the Jewish and Arab gays.

For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.

For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.

For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.

Get Socialist Organiser delivered t hates it there. Having no ties mak her feel weightless and invisibl Better the familiar Prague with : its new terrors than the lightness Switzerland.

The characters try to change to in with the new times and new rel tionships, but they only succeed some extent. Tomas is weight down by one small misdemeanou which costs him a lot. Though t matter is small and insignificant, grows to dominate his life. It weig him down, but to cast it off wou economies. • Down with the idea of a "Jewish state". imposed on the majority of the population of the country! For the elimination of Zionist ideas from the workers' movement! For the integration of the Jewish workers into the movement of the national-democratic revolution of the Arab masses. • For a break by the Jewish trade unions and workers' organisations from the Jewish Agency, and the full publication of all the secret minutes of this organism. • For a break by the Arab trade unions and workers' organisations from the Arab League and the Arab High Committee for Palestine, and the full publication of all the secret minutes of these organisms.

All these slogans, which can only be defended at present as slogans of We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.

your door by

cause even greater heaviness, the

heaviness of guilt and betrayal. neaviness of guilt and betrayal All the characters' lives are shaper All the characters' lives are shaped by the Russian invasion. Shown close up, with real footage cut into the film, the tanks are an abomination. When they first arrive, Tomas is chasing Tereza, who has fled the flat after a quarrel. As he follows her down the narrow, cobbled street, he sees and hears the oncoming tanks. The street is barely wide enough to allow the tank to pass. Graceful, lovely Prague is invaded, by what seem to be barbarian hordes. In the first days the Czechs surround the tanks in protest, there are demonstrations and photographs taken of the monstrosities. But then the authorities start to pick people off in ones and twos, and the betrayals. and denials begin.

The film evokes the atmosphere of the era well - the excitement and hope of the liberalisation, then the outrage, disbelief and despair of the invasion, followed by the confusing 'normalisation' where people are asked to denounce others, sign oaths, recant their views and conform.

My main quibble with the mum is the extraordinary amount of female nudity. Sex was a large part of the book, and so can't be left out of the film. But in the book, both characters were equally naked; in the film, the women alone are exposed. The film objectifies the women in a way the book didn't.

Kundera didn't strip the female characters as bare as director Philip Kaufman does. Kaufman seems to gloat over the women in a way that leaves a nasty taste in the mouth. general propaganda, necessarly come up against bitter opposition from the Zionists, not only for ideological reasons but also and above all because the privileged material situation of the Jews in relation to the Arabs is thereby put in question. But to the extent that the collapse of Zionism becomes more and more evident in the eyes of the masses; to the extent that immigration slows down and the extreme danger of the Arab explosion comes closer; to the extent that our propaganda helps the masses to realise that it is a question oj we and death for them to find a basis of agreement with the Arab masses, even at the cost of a temporary abandonment of certain privileges — our slogans will be able to go from the propagandist level to the level of agitation, and will be able to encourage a split between the workers' movement and Zionism. That is the condition sine qua non for achieving Jewish-Arab unity of action against imperialism, and it is the only way to stop the Arab revolution in the Middle East proceeding over the corpse of Palestinian Jewry. Here, as among the Jewish masses in the rest of the world, a firm position against the current at the present stage is the only way to prepare a reversing off the current at the next stage. It also implies the need for the sections of the Fourth International to carry on preparatory propaganda work inside the far-left Zionist organisations. By showing that the slogan of a "bi-national state" is a nationalist and anti-democratic slogan, going against both the right of peoples to self-determination and the immediate needs of the anti-imperialist struggle in Palestine, our militants should at the same time put on the agenda, on each occasion, the question of the concrete realisation of the slogan of Jewish-Arab unity. They should put the centrist leaders up against their responsibilities, put on the agenda the adoption of the anti-racial pro-

----- pull-quotes -----

th having it off with as many established possibes, sa. a as

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 366

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →