Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Labour Party!

Socialist Organiser no. 366, 11 August 1988 · scan pp. 5–9 · Sam Eaton · about 5,637 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

fact, the US wants and wanted a very 'controlled' end to the war. It does and did not want Iran to be absolutely humiliated and vanquished, precisely because that would be too big a risk for the US.

In reality, it is the present regime in Iran that is making peace, and the dominant faction within it that is most enthusiastic about it. Contrary to all the hasty warnings of the SWP, at no point did US involvement lead to a qualitative change in the war's character; at no point was there any question of Iran's national rights coming under serious threat. This is the basic question -and this SW refuses to address.

Instead they are dissolving all working-class considerations into a vague populist 'anti-imperialism' Socialist Worker Review (July 1988) warns against a pro-Western Socialist Organiser Is the SWP an alternative?

Available from S Box 823, Londo SE15 4NA. 75p 25p postage.

366. 11 August 1988. Page 5 75p

Scan page 6

Hussein was probably pro- the Jordanian population is mpted by two factors. Since the Palestinian, a claim that runs beginning of the intifada or contrary to a widely-held belief. uprising, last December, Arab The aim is to distance Jordan pressure on him to abandon all from the ideological underpinnclaims to represent the Palesti- ing of this second Israeli 'Jornians, in rivalry with the PLO, dan option'. has been very strong. The But this policy also entails a inevitably voices annexation. Annexation would Algiers Arab summit in June risk. For 'disengagement' leaves raised that Israel almost certainly be accomreaffirmed the PLO's sole a political vacuum in the West it, through formal panied by the expulsion across Arab prisoners blindfolded on the way to interrogation. The decision by King Hussein of Jordan to relinquish all claims to the Israelioccupied West Bank has contributed to a major new diplomatic offensive by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), Following Jordan's "disengagement', pro-PLO leaders of the uprising in the West Bank and Gaza are reported to be moving towards a *declarationof in -dependence'. Coupled with the creation of a "government-in-exile', this is a radical step towards the creation of the structures of Palestinian statehood.

Hussein's decision is unlikely to have been made lightheartedly. The West Bank was ruled by Jordan from 1950 to 1967, when it was seized by Israel. Jordanian law continued to operate there officially, and Jordan continued to have jurisdiction over schools, hospitals, agricultural projects and religious institutions. Until the mid 1970s, the Palestinian leadership in the West Bank tended to be pro-Jordanian. Economic links with Jordan are still important, although they have gradually been superceded by links with Israel.

Pressure

legitimacy as Palestinian representative. Despite formal agreement with this proposition since as long ago as 1974, Hussein has long held to the possibility that he might play a role, possibly a dominant one, in negotiations with Israel.

Within Israel he is regarded as a potential 'moderate' negotiating partner by the more doveish sections of the Labour Party. (In fact he is a brutal dictator responsible for the slaugter of 30,000 Palestinians in 1970). But the resilience of the intifada - which must surely have been having an effect on Jordan's large Palestinian population — has forced Hussein to stop equivocating.

"Transfer"

Second, Hussein must be afraid that Israel might act on its other 'Jordan option' - the forcible 'transfer' of thousands of Palestinians across the border, where, according to the mainstream Israeli right, they belong. (According to a different rightwing view, Jordan is really Israel's too).

Significantly, 'disengagement trom the west bank nas been accompanied by an insistence that only a minority of Palestinians in a refugee camp. Bank, and have been should fill the river of West Bank Palestinians, to reduce the number of Arabs who would otherwise become citizens of the Jewish However, the usually very hawkish Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir has unequivocally resisted these calls, and looks likely to go on doing so.

The question now is whether the PLO can fill the vacuum, both politically, in the eyes of the world, and 'physically' through the establishment of real administrative structures.

Difficult

Presumably, even with the impressive structures that have been established by the intifada, it would be extremely difficult for the PLO (or the Palestinian nationalist movement within the occupied territories, which supports the PLO), directly to take over from Jordan in the running of schools and hospitals, although they may be able to take former Jordanian employees onto their own payrole to a limited extent. So Israel is likely to fill the 'physical gap'. But politically, a government-in-exile would be recognised by a large number of states, especially in the Third

Scan page 7

In the last issue of SO we printed a letter sent to us anonymously through the post and allegedly written by Labour MP George Galloway. This letter, if genuine, showed Galloway to be involved in a computerised witch-hunt of Labour leftists. George World, , most of which recognise the PLO.

Negotiate

More important is whether a government-in-exile would have any impact within Israel. Already, the view that Israel should negotiate with the PLO is far more respectable than it was five years ago. This week, left Zionist parties declared themselves for negotiations with the PLO on condition that it renounces violence and recognises Israel; members of left Zionist parties have had discussions with the PLO, which are prohibited by Israeli law.

The government-in-exile formula is implicitly a recognition of Israel (which is why the PLO has not opted for it before, given extra weight by the leadership within the occupied territories; the intifada has tipped the balance further away from the 'rejectionists' on the Palestinian side. Moreover the PLO has recently made louder-thanusual noises that it is prepared to recognise Israel.

This may make no short-term difference to the stands of either the Labour or the Likud wings of the Israeli establishment, but it should strengthen the hand of the 'peace camp".

Certainly the government-in-exile is a logical next step for the Palestinian uprising. According to reports, the maximum negotiation position of the government-in-exile would be for a Palestinian state within the borders of the 1947 Partition Plan; the West Bank and Gaza would be the minimum. This would be, very explicitly, a 'two states' formula, albeit one whose maximum expression would be accepted only by a tiny minority of Israelis.

Risks

Contrary to the assumptions of many on the Left, this would not represent a retreat by the Palestinian national movement. It is a course of action involving a lot of risks, not least those arising from the preciptous "disengagement' of Jordan (such as the status of many Palestinians who currently have Jordanian citizenship but may now lose it). But a clear and unambiguous course towards "two states' should be supported by all socialists. Aside from any other considerations, it matches the logic of the Palestinian struggle as it has actually developed. I was very distressed by your treatment of the forged letter story. Leaving aside the criticisms that could be made of the jounalistic practices involved, I am bound to say that giving over your whole back page to such a counterfeit story does not say much for your revolutionary alertness to the kind of dirty tricks played by the enemy from time to time.

In the event you published the story which was a calumnous and libellous attack on at least three activists in the Labour Party on the basis of a forgery on notepaper stolen from my briefcase from the House of Commons.

You may be interested to know that you anonymous correspondent had earlier written to The Sun newspaper offering them the opportunity of purchasing the contents of my briefcase. "The Sun" immediately turned the letter over to the police. It is to your discredit that you chose a different path.

Although the forgery contains some attention to detail, and thus limited plausibility it was, on five minutes reflection, an obvious and crude hoax.

I will deal only with its most salient contradictions.

In the last paragraph of the hoax I am to be found congratulating Anita Pollack "on being selected" The letter is dated February 6th. In fact Anita Pollack was not selected as Euro candidate for South West London unti 18th March.

In the first paragraph of the hoax I described Mark Lazarowicz, a close friend and comrade of mine, as having "as far as I know left the IMG a long time ago". Mark Lazarowicz has never been member of the International Marxist Group or any other far left organisation.

In the third paragraph I am to be found inviting Anita Pollack to "give Wendy a ring at Westminster (219-6815)". In fact "Wendy left my employment and Westminster the previous month and the telephone number in question left with her.

The hoax is signed with what is clearly an attempt at my signature which has been subsequently thought not to pass muster and has been thus transformed into a per procurationem of my ow n signature.

There are other errors and turns of phrase which ought to have alerted you to the fact that this letter was a forgery, but I will leave this for now, except to say that before you published this story both Anita Pollack and myself told you unequivocally that it was a forgery.

On a political level, the conspiracy you allege in your article headlined Labour's MI5? is equally flawed. The facts are that I have no relationship connection personally or politically with either Paul mlioned twice in the letes Pollack or the mysterious and who is presumed to be Mr Paul Thomson, the Chair of the LCC The truth is that until receiving your telephone call I had never in my life had a conversation with Anita Pollack. I have serious political disagreements with her political position, still more Paul Thomson's, and I am no longer a member of either the Executive Committee of the LCC or even the organisation itself.

As to 'witch-hunting', a simple telephone call to, for example Militant, would have located the truth; that I have consistently opposed the expulsion of Trotskyists trom the Labour Party and continue to do so. Indeed, I even made a high profirst expelled members, Mr Brychan Davies of the Rhondda constituency. I am neither 'new realist' or "soft left' and I have no connection with 'the student democratic left' As for my perjoritively described 'anti-imperialism"; I will leave my comrades in the national liberation movements to evaluate my work in this field.

In conclusion, your article accuses me of an act which is both politically sinister and illegal. It By John O'Mahony Last week we reported George Galloway's assertion that the letter is a forgery.

It may well be a forgery. We don't know. The best way to handle something like this is to publish all the evidence — both the alleged letter, and Galloway's comments. The labour movement is entitled to know about such things and to have the chance to explore the truth — without the threat of the big stick of the capitalist courts being used against the labour movement The secretive, oppressive, and il liberal practices of Mrs Thatcher's Establishment are not a model for the labour movement to follow, especially at a time when we are campaigning for more freedom of information.

If indeed the letter is a forgery, then George Galloway will emerge strengthened as a result of the exposure of the forgery, and not besmirched.

If George Galloway thinks it is to his advantage to sue SO, then no doubt he'll sue. But whether or not George Galloway is involved, it is pretty certain that activities like those referred to in the alleged letter are going on in the Labour Party now [see page 2]. We do not know the present state of George Galloway's relations with his erstwhile comrades of the Labour Coordinating Committee, but he was until recently part of that wing of the Labour Party.

Regular readers of Socialist Organiser know that we run an 'open' newspaper. It is normal for us to publish replies and rebuttals, and we see it as a matter of course that Galloway has the right to reply to last week's SO.

It is unfortunate that George Galloway should make such a shoddy polemic of his response to the alleged At the end of last week, about the time Galloway would have been writing the letter printed here, I responded to a police request to go to Cannon Row police station and talk to the officer investigating the theft of Galloway's briefcase.

The idea that the notepaper Constituency Labour Conterdide 107 11am so Spm, at the GEORGE GALLOWAY, MOUSE OP COMMONSE LONDON SHIAOAA goeswithout saying that should decide to so proceed, would have a substantial legal claim against you. I would, however, prefer not to take a left-wing newspaper to court whatever its oftence against me. My decision will be greatly intluenced, however, by the prominence which I hope you will give to the above in the next edition of your newspaper, together with a suitable apology. I look forward to hearing from you.

Yours fraternally George Gallowayent the alleged forgery was done came from the stolen briefcase was just one line of inquiry, not something that had been established. George Galloway has no right to write as if it is fact.

It would seem on the face of it to be improbable that the briefcase-thief who tried to make a few bob selling George Galloway's papers to the Sun would be interested in the internal Labour Party political mischief-making which would motivate forgery - or, for that matter, able to do a reasonably plausible job of it should they want to.

In fact everyone in the labour movement knows that an MP's notepaper is not the most difficult thing to get hold of. If the letter is indeed a forgery, the internal evidence suggests that it is the work of former soft-left friends of Galloway's who are well acquainted with the affairs of the left and know Galloway well enough to write in what comrades who know him tell me is something like Galloway's style.

It is not unknown for letters signed "pp" to be signed with the correspondent's name rather than that of his secretary; and any schoolboy with a bit of tracing paper could have forged Galloway's signature passably, anyway.

When we got the allegedly forged letter, we tried the phone number given in it; it got us through to George Galloway's office all right. We printed Anita Pollack's comment that she never received the alleged letter last week; but she and George Galloway were until recently members of the LCC Executive together. Even the date of Anita Pollack's selection is not conclusive: the election of delegates and the nominations to the final Euro-selection meeting might decide a selection well in advance of the final formal vote.

I don't know whether the letter is a forgery or not. Publishing it is one way to find out - and to help find out who forged it, if someone did. After all, if someone is doing such forgeries, we should find out who.

George Galloway's polemic shows him to be concerned less with the truth than with throwing up a smokescreen of shoddy rhetoric, such as the linking of SO with... the Sun! Last Saturday, 6 August, Galloway's friends at the Gorbachev fanzine the Morning Star did a similar smut-job on SO, no doubt derived from Galloway's letter. my CLP.

Scan page 8

Part Two of the Draft Theses produced the Trotskyist Fourth International in January 1947 outlines their political conclusions for the Jewish-Arab conflict Palestine. Part One appeared in SO 365.

The interminable series of sufferings through which the Jewish masses of Europe have passed have without doubt sharpened the development of a national consciousness, both among the survivors and among the Jewish masses of America and Palestine who feel most closely tied to the fate of their brothers in Europe.

This national consciousness expresses itself in the following way:

a) The Jewish masses in general now wish to affirm their own nationality as against other peoples. A violent Jewish nationalism responds to the violence of persecutions and b) The Jewish masses in Europe have their eyes turned towards emigration. Given the hermetic closure of all frontiers, following from general world conditions postwar, and in line with the wave of nationalism which carries them away, this wish to leave the continent of Europe, which for them is just a huge cemetery, expresses itself above all in a Zionist drive to go to Palestine.

c) Inside the Zionist movement, the struggle for "the Jewish state" formerly waged exclusively by the far right ("the revisionists"), is now taken up by all the parties (Biltmore Programme") except the centrist party Hashomer Hatzair, The rebirth of the national consciousness of the masses is a result of the decay of capitalism, which is putting into question once again all the problems solved in its period of upswing. Basing itself firmly on its programme and a scientific analysis of the situation in Palestine, but considering at the same time the real state of the consciousness of the Jewish masses, the Fourth International should recognise as legitimate their wish to develop their own national existence. It should show concretely that gaining this national existence is unrealisable in decaying capitalist society, and especially unrealisable and reactionary in Palestine. It should show that for the Jews as for all the other peoples of the world, the defence or the definitive conquest of their own nationality cannot be got by means of the conThe SIDE 366. economies, but that the planned socialist world economy constitutes the only realistic framework in which a free and undistorted development of peoples is now possible. The Fourth International should make the Jewish masses aware of the terrible catastrophes awaiting them if the decay of capitalism continues. Only the integration of the movement for Jewish emancipation into the world workers' movement will allow a harmonious solution of the Jewish question. Socialist planning "turning the topography of the world upside down" (Trotsky) will guarantee all those who want it a special national existence in the framework of the United States of the World.

But the Fourth International wil never win a decisive influence among the Jewish masses just by preaching the necessity of the socialist revolution for their emancipation.

Only by taking the lead in a vast world movement of solidarity by the proletariat for the victims of imperialist and fascist persecution; only in showing the Jews in practice that the solutions proposed by the revolutionary movement are more favourable and more realistic than the Zionist "solution' , will the Fourth International succeed, at the next turn of events, in bringing the Jewish masses into the world anti-imperialist struggle. To go against the Zionist current now; to counterpose to it another immediate and concrete way out: such are the two indispensable elements to prepare for the next stage: when the Jewish masses have gone through the experience of being deceived by Zionism, when they have understood the pointlessness of their efforts and their sacrifices, they will turn towards us on condition that we are able as from now to offer them our solutions as well as Not 13p don Revi post SE1 an implacable criticism of Zionism.

a) All sections of the Fourth International should put forward the slogan, "Open the gates of all countries to the Jewish refugees!" "Abolition of all immigration controls". This slogan should be defended most specially by the SWP of the United States on the one hand, and by our British, CanaAmerican sections on the other. French and all Latin These latter, as well as our Australian section, and in particular the sections of Argentina and Brazil, should add to these slogans the demand: "Abolition of all racial and religious discrimination in immigration laws"

Every concrete opportunity (complaints about the lack of labour and the decline of the population; partial opening of the country for certain categories of immigrants; acts of commemoration for the victims of fascism...) should be used to arouse the working-class public opinion of the country and to demand the launching of concrete actions with a view to getting immediate results. Resolutions like those of the CIO should be used as a point of departure to demand actions from the World Federation of Trade Unions, and to organise coordinated actions in the sectors of economic and social life best placed to express solidarity in action (seafarers, government employees, civil servants...) with go-slows, organised sabotage, protests, meetings, coordinated demonstrations, etc... It is only to the extent that our sections are able to prove to the Jews that they are really and effectively struggling for the opening of their own countries to immigration that they will be able to get them to prefer immigration to those countries to immigration to Palestine, which is harder to achieve and also constitutes an act contrary to the vital interests of the anti-imperialist masses of the Middle East.

b) All the sections of the Fourth International should seriously set about the tasklof fighting the rot of anti-semitism which remains or is developing in large sections of the population in all countries. This work of cleansing is all the more urgent because 'official' workers' movement, from conformism, from cowardice, or from narrow factional calculation (the anti-Trotskyism of the French CP is often expressed through antisemitic arguments) does nothing to eliminate from the consciousness of the masses the anti-Jewish poison put there by Hitlerite propaganda.

At every concrete opportunity, our sections should destroy the fascist lies about "Jewish capitalism"- or "Jewish monopolists" They should systematically rouse up the mass proletarian organisations against every attempt to reconstruct the anti-semitic organisations. Using the tragic examples of recent years, they should imbue the consciousness of the masses with this fundamental truth, that their owr fate is at stake in the struggle against anti-semitic gangsterism.

It is only to the extent that our sections get this truth absorbed by the masses and translated by them into action that they will convince the Jews that only the integration of their movement of emancipation into the world workers' movement will put them in a position to defend themselves effectively against new waves of anti-semitism.

c) All sections of the Fourth In ternational that confront an organised fascist movement thoroughly using anti-semitic demagogy and going over to terrorist actions against the Jews, should try to mobilise the working class in armed formations (militias...) for the defence of the Jews. Where the Jewish population is concentrated in Jewish quarters, they should propose and favour the creation of armed self-defence militias while trying to fuse them with the workers' militias. They should explain to the Jewish masses that only this fusion in armed strug gle can guarantee effective detence; but at the same time they should warn the workers that only an armed defence of the Jews will prevent the same fascist armies crushing the whole workers' movement at a later stage.

The Palestine problem today The Palestine problem nas gained a new and special importance since the end of the Second World War as a result of a series of "new factors" which are changing its face profoundly.

a) The industrialisation of the Near and Middle East has to a certain extent bolstered up the native Arab bourgeoisies in Egypt, in Palestine itself, in Syria, in Lebanon, and to a lesser extent in other Arab countries. The social differentiation of the old feudal and patriarchal Arab society has accelerated. An Arab proletariat, much more powerful numerically and already conscious politically, has appeared on the political scene in several, countries of the Middle East (strikes in Egypt, Palestine, Syria, Iran and Iraq).

Arab nationalism is being differentiated in the same wayAlongside feudal and reactionary pan-Islamism, there now appears a progressive pan-Arab current which sees the creation of a Union of the Arab countries of the Middle East as the only real framework for the development of the productive forces and for the constitution of an Arab nation. The bourgeoisie can only defend this idea in a hesitant way on the ideological level, to the extent that it wants an expansion of the market for its industry which, since the end of the war, has been plunged into a profound crisis. The only force capable of realising this programme of the national-democratic revolution of the Arab world is the proletariat, which alone is capable of pushing through, by the mechanism of the permanent revlution, the struggle against feudalism for agrarian reform, for the emancipation of the Arab world from imperialist intervention, and for the constitution of the unity of the Arab world.

b) The sharpening of anti-imperialist movements in the framework of the colonial revolutions, the most important overturns in the period immediately after the Second World War, and the weakening of the old imperialist powers (Britain, France, Italy) have SEne consequence that the bourgeoisie and even certain feudal layers have seized the possibility of gaining by pressure, without having to unleash real mass struggles, from which they always recoil, important concessions from the occupying powers, such as the withdrawal of French troops from Syria and Lebanon, and the preparation of the withdrawal of British troops from Egypt. These various retreats by imperialism are a stimulant for the anti-imperialist struggle in the other colonial countries of the Middle East. They deal a severe blow to the prestige of imperialism and increase the confidence of the native masses in their own strength.

c) The transformation of Palestine into the cornerstone of the system of imperial defence in the Eastern Mediterranean. After the withdrawal of British troops from Egypt, Palestine will be the main base for the British fleet, airforce, army and secret services in the Eastern Mediterranean, the cornerstone of the defence of the Suez Canal and the imperial route to India. The strong concentrations of British troops in Palestine just use the terrorist troubles as a pretext. In reality, for British imperialism it is a matter of constructing a durable base with a view to future military conflicts and the defence of the Empire.

d) The transformation of the Middle East into one of the main items at stake between the "three big powers". Before the war the Middle East was the sector of the world where the predominant influence of British imperialism was least threatened. Since then, Rommel's advance to El Alamein, the installation of American "observers" in the kingdom of Ibn Saud, the unleashing of the Anglo-American dispute over Iranian oil, the penetration of the Orthodox

Scan page 9

Jewish refugees arrive in Haifa Church throughout the Middle East as major agency Kremlin diplomacy - all these developments have put exclusive British domination in question in this part of the world and transformed it into an area of constant conflicts between the powers.

East has the world's most untapped and greatest oil reserves, it is also becoming, in the present period, the main area of dispute in the world struggle strategic staterial, of which the Us's and the USSR's reserves are severely reduced. The various "tactical" moves of the Arab countries dle East.

It is the Arab masses, the workers and the poor peasants, who constitute the revolutionary force in the Middle East and also in Palestine, thanks to their numbers, their social conditions, and their material life, which puts them directly in conflict with imperialism. The revolutionary party must base itself in the first place on the dynamics of the class struggle, waged for the defence of their interests. Developing as the Arab proletariat grows and the revolutionary party will educate the masses on the necessity of more and more opposition to the Arab bourgeoisie, which is closely tied to the effendis. When the mass struggle reaches its climax, when worker and peasant committees cover the Middle East and the question of the seizure of power by the Arab proletariat is on the agenda, the revolutionary party will have educated the masses sufficiently to lead them also to the expropriation of the "national" bourgeoisie.

Can these four objeea) Far from wanting the immediate withdrawal of the British forces of occupation, the Jewish masses, on the contrary, want them to stay in the country. The only thing that the Zionist leaders, bourgeois and worker alike, do demand is concessions on immigration and the setting-up of a Jewish state. But the overwhelming majority of the Jews of Palestine (in the first place, the "Haganah") are ready to "act" against imperialism only to the extent that such "action" does not endanger the fundamental "security" of the Jewish community in relation to the Arab world. That is why an armed struggle, or even widespread sabotage action, undertaken by the Jewish masses is more or less excluded at the present stage. The aim of the current Zionist action is only to apply pressure on British imperialism to get concessions, and not to push for its expulsion from Palestine.

The terrorist movement and the so-called "Hebrew committee of national liberation" do pose the objective of the expulsion of British imperialism from Palestine. But they can conceive of this expulsion only in the form of a general arming of the Jews of Palestine, who would hold the Arab world in check until such time as massive immigration by Jews would make them militarily capable of opposing the "Arab threat". Quite apart from the utterly utopian character of these views, they are ultra-reactionary and can only further widen the gulf which separates the Jewish and Arab workers in Palestine.

b) All the Jews of Palestine oppose the immediate convocation of Constituent Assembly which would put power into the hands of the majority of the population, which is Arab.

The terrorists claim to fight for a free, independent and democratic Palestine. But, being the most fervent partisans of a "Jewish state" they too must find a subterfuge to deny sovereignty to the majority of the population of the country. They say that they are ready to organise general elections only atter having given the Jews in exile "an opportunity in a determinate period ol time" to return to their country. In other words, they support general elections only if and when the Jews become the absolute majority of the population.

c) The Jews have no interest in the expropriation of the effendis, since this expropriation would practice deny them any possibility of buying new land and expanding their "closed Jewish economy" in Palestine.

d) They are even more bitterly opposed to the expropriation of the enterprises built with foreign capital and to the closing of the country to the import of capital, because this would be a mortal blow to their Jewish economy.

All this leads to the conclusion that at the present stage the Jewish masses of Palestine, as a whole, are not an anti-imperialist force, and that the constitution of a JewishArab anti-imperialist bloc cannot be a slogan for immediate agitation. imperialism, and can only pave the way for the complete extermination of the Jewish minority at the next stage, in the Arab uprising.

If, therefore, the Fourth International should do all it can to warn Jewish refugees against emigration to Palestine; if, in the framework of a world movement of solidarity, it should try to get the doors of other countries opened to them, and warn them that Palestine is a veritable death-trap for them; in its concrete propaganda on the question of Jewish immigration it should start from the question of the sovereignty of the Arab population. Only this Arab population has the right to determine whether or not immigration to Palestine should be open or closed to Jews. The question of immigration should be decided by the Constituent Assembly, elected by all the inhabitants of the country aged 18 and over. Such is the only democratic position on this problem, a position which also fits into the framework of the general strategy of the revolution in the In consequence, the Fourth International should condemn and fight British repression of Jewish immigration, denounce all the police measures, and counterpose concretely on each occasion the demand for the immediate withdrawal of the British troops. It is not difficult to explain to the Arab masses that this limited imperialist repression against the Jews is only preparation for much more violent repression against future Arab movements. It is in the interests of the Arab masses to take advantage of each outburst of anger against British police terror to pose concretely the question of the withdrawal of the British troops. It would besides be made clear in this case that the very "victims" of this repression would not at all accept this serious struggle against their "oppressors"

Likewise the Fourth International should oppose all the "solutions" which imperialism is proposing and may implement with or without the aid of its agents in the Jewish Agency. These solutions, such as the partition of Palestine, limited immigration of 100,000 Jews. or the handing-over of the mandate to the UN, all have the aim of perpetuating the presence of British troops in the country and still deny to the majority of the population its right to decide its own future.

At the present stage, 1 general unity betTween Jews and Arabs in Palestine is unrealisable: only on a very limited scale, and to the extent that a section of the Jewish workers is employed outside the "closed" Jewish economy, have Jewish-Arab strikes like those of the last year been able to happen.

But that does not mean that this unity is ruled out for all time. At

----- pull-quotes -----

file public interyention jn Labour Galloway responds SOCIALIST SER Weekly in defence of one of the

struction of "closed' states and GREETA Democracyr not revengel

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 366

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →