Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Should socialists want more slaughter in the Gulf?

Socialist Organiser no. 366, 11 August 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 1,522 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Iran's suitender in Gulf War Why socialists the Gulf War gets more and more ridiculous. Their verdict is that socialists should "not rejoice" at the end of the war.

One of the most horrendous and barbaric wars of human history.in which over a million people died, many of them child soldiers - is nearly over, and we should mourn? On the contrary, socialists should rejoice, and loudly.

The United States may quite possibly have strengthened its hand in the region. But that may prove temporary. And it is a small matter compared to the weight of suffering that has been lifted.

To desire a continuation of this monstrous war, socialists would need very, very persuasive reasons. Something of immense importance would have to be at stake in the conflict. Socialist Worker's arguments are idiotic, as I'll show. They reduce to repulsive caricatures many ideas current on the left, ideas which led most of the left to support Iran at the beginning of the war. For that reason they are worth examining.

But perhaps worse than SW's political arguments are the methods used to cover their tracks. Socialist Worker of 30 July has dug up an old quote from the same paper of October 1980. "An Iraqi victory would give all conservative regimes in the Middle East a much-needed shot in the arm. That's why, even if it would temporerily strengthen the mullahs' hold, we must hope that the Iranians are able to repel the invaders".| Now SW concludes that this response "has been proved correct".

But this pro-Iranian policy was very briefly held. For the next seven years, until the summer of 1987, the SWP opposed both sides. To justify a political record by "losing' seven years of it is quite simply corrupt.

Later, in a separate article (How Iran - was defeated'), they half-heartedly justify their shifts of line. But they are trapped in a ferocious logic. Either there have been real changes in the political character of the Iran-Iraq war, which would justify sharp changes in approach;

1958: Iraqi revolution. 1968: Ba'ath Party seizes 1975: Iran and Iraq sign treaty in Algiers giving joint sovereignty over Shatt al Arab waterway. 1979, February: Iranian revolution. 1980, September: Iraq abrogates Algiers treaty and invades Iran. 1982: Iran dominant in war;

but stalemate. 1985: 'Tanker war' begins.

Iraq and Iran attack shipping in the Gulf. 1987: US and other Western powers send ships to Gulf to protect shipping and clear mines. Some conflicts with Iran. 1988: Iran sues for peace.

From 'Republican Worker" or, fundamentally, the pro-Iran lin was right all along, and for seve years of the war the SWP plugge the line of pro-imperialist traitors Naturally, SW veers all over th place trying to steer a course be ween these alternatives.

Their essential case is that the en of the Gulf War has seen strengthening of the US's (and, t an extent, the USSR's) position i the Middle East and throughout th Third World. They say the US' aim was to face down Iran, whos 'Islamic revolution' is a threat ti US interests. Iran was forced to su for peace, thereby accepting defeat Iran's 'surrender' is therefore defeat for all opponents of im perialism. Thus socialists have n cause to rejoice.

More and more, the SWP ten towards the argument tha throughout the war Iran's victor was worth supporting. There is ne other possible logic underlying wha they now say. After all, Iran wa consistently anti-American. Ira more or less had the support of th West from the beginning, and cer tainly it had the support of the reac tionary Gulf states, which ar vehementlv pro-Western. That' why SW feels it can refer to its ow 1980 assessment with confidence current policy fits neatly with it.

But SW hesitates to draw thi conclusion. "For the rulers of botl Iran and Iraq, the war became : part of their class rule", they note But SW of 23 July comments: "a every stage the interests of fightin the Iraqis and the Americans wer subordinated to the interests of the mullahs". If Khomeini had mobilis. ed against imperialism, they say, the war could have been won. Logical ly, therefore, at every stage" socialists should have criticised the mullahs — not for waging war, but for failing to do so consistently.

Indeed, some people have said that throughout the war: namely, the other SWP, the once-Trotskyist US organisation which now Castroite, Stalinoid, and increas ingly daft. Its British supporters recently parted ways with Socialist Action because they find it too sensible!

SW tries to break out of this logic by insisting on the decisive character of US involvement in determining the character of the war. After summer 1987, a test of strength with imperialism had begun. Or, more accurately: originally, in 1980, it was a test of strength with imperialism (via Iraq - no US gunboats then, please note); then (at an unspecified time) it became "a part of the class rule" of both sides; then it became a war against imperialism again.

There seem to be two respects in which US naval involvement changed the war. First, militarily. "The introduction of the task force foreed Iran to move its already severely depleted airforce south from the main battle front.. An arms embargo was imposed on tran... In the meantime arms and cash poured into Iraq" (30 July).

This is a dreadful argument. It ties socialist policy not to fundamental principles, but to the military course of the war. Once Iran starts losing, the policy changes (which is a peculiar sort of "defeatism'!)

According to Lenin, for example, "The philistine does not realise that war is the continuation of policy', and consequently limits himself to the formula 'the enemy has attacked us'. ... without stopping to think what issues are at stake in the war, which classes are waging it, and with what political objectives... For the philistine, the important thing is where the armies stand, who is winning at the moment. For the Marxist, the important thing is what issues are at stake in this war, during which first one, then the other army may be on top" (Emphasis in original: Collected Works, vol.23, p.33).

If Iran's war was a part of class rule" , it did not cease to be so because the mullahs started to lose.

But did America's involvement change the issues at stake? SW warns: "Socialists may have loathed the Islamic fundamentalist regime in Iran, but what will follow after the defeat will be worse". -Worse than the Khomeini regime? Well, no. More like the same. "US, Japanese and European big business doesn't mind a government still disgubed [?] in clerical garb..."

Indeed, "Iran's rulers decided to surrender because they thought the risk of working-class revolt through prolonging the war was greater than the undoubted risks of surrender" So the workers were likely to revolt if the anti-imperialist war continued? Funny sort of progressive"

rejoice war, if workers should want to rise up against it, you might think. Or are the SWP justifying support for the war on the grounds that the workers would rise up against it? This really is a right old mess.

"Iran's defeat is not simply a defeat for the rulers of the Islamic Republic, it is a defeat for Iran's workers too" , says SW. "Now, as well as fighting a vicious reactionary government in Tehran, Iran's working class face a victorious superpower"

For sure the US will do what it can to help Khomeini (and his successors) to stabilise their post-war regime. But is this not because the whole notion that the US aimed to remove the Khomeini regime was false? Does this not contradict the SWP's entire analysis?

And if the Iranian working class is in a weaker position now -which is extremely debatable -surely this is because the Iranian regime is not completely prostrate and 'defeated'. If only it were! In Islamic regime on the Pakistani model emerging in Iran. But why would that be worse than Khomeini?

Only if Khomeini's fundamentalist 'anti-imperialism' is considered to be a kind of deformed 'first stage' of socialist politics would the SWP's analysis make any sense. They do tend towards such a view. *Elsewhere in the region, fundamentalism became a focus for the poor and dispossessed... It was a nightmare for the United States".

Indeed; but was it a progressive phenomenon? Not every nightmare of Ronald Reagan's is a sweet dream for socialists.

We need to make our own independent judgments. Our enemy's enemy is not in this case our friend, even an unreliable one. We have every reason to rejoice at an end to the Gulf War. Our task now is to help the Iranian and Iraqi workers bring lasting peace — by destroying both regimes. • US out of the Gulf! • For the overthrow of Saddam Hussein and Khomeini! • Self-determination for the oppressed nationalities in Iran and Iraq! Photo: Kaveh Golestan (Reflex)

----- pull-quotes -----

why Socialist Worker considers the end of the Gulf War a 'victory for imperialism' Socialist Worker's autopsy on

Socialist Kinnock rats on unlateralism LEAVE THI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 366

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →