Stay in the EETPU and fight!
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-08-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: a letter, signed Tom Rigby, Walworth, answering Martin Thomas. The machine reading had run it together with the Graffiti column and with the letter below it, Russia is a workers' state, whose sign-off it had taken for this letter's by-line. Transcribed from the scan of page 4. 'EEPTU', 'it to hope', 'stragegy' and 'it's crassest' are as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
I don’t find Martin Thomas’ arguments for activists to pull out of the EETPU at all convincing.
To begin with Martin chooses the wrong starting point. He argues: “If the left can’t stop Hammond taking the EETPU out of the TUC, we will not be able to make him re-affiliate in the near future”.
A lot of the rest of Martin’s argument is premised on this point. But it makes much more sense to begin with the fact that the leaders of “Flashlight” the broad left grouping in the EETPU, are only confident of taking 1.48% of the EETPU’s 336,000 membership out of the union at this stage.
Therefore it would be crazy to abandon to Hammond the 25,000 who voted against his line in the recent ballot and the 175,000 who didn’t vote, not to mention significant numbers of those who did vote for the union leadership but who may not have clearly understood the issues.
Martin contradicts himself. He argues “We can’t prevent a membership war: we can make sure it is not one-sided”.
This doesn’t fit in with his original starting point. The left inside and outside the EETPU can’t be at the same time too weak to beat Hammond and strong enough to turn the TUC against Hammond, win a membership war against him and in the process transform the TUC’s timid and bureaucratic objections to Hammond into a principled defence of trade unionism.
If Martin assessed the real weakness of the left properly he would focus on how small the pro-TUC split is likely to be.
In reality the issues in the EETPU/TUC fight are not clear enough to the majority of organised workers — either inside or outside the EETPU — to favour Martin’s approach.
There are real differences between the TUC leaders tepid new-realism and Hammond’s open scab unionism; but they are only implicit in the present dispute with the TUC. It is significant that the TUC has chosen to fight Hammond on the issue of the Bridlington agreements — not on no-strike deals, or scabbing at Wapping.
The problem for the left is to convince the bulk of EETPU members that Hammond wants to take the union down a road that will lead to disaster, to it becoming an open hard scab organisation. It has not yet reached that point, and it would be wrong to make analogies with the UDM etc. Hammond can still be stopped.
But it can only help Hammond and the bosses who back him to pull all the best activists out of the union. Especially as the left inside the EEPTU now has the best opening it has had for years.
There are some factors the left can take heart from. Hammond is seen as a pariah by many in the movement; EETPU members are prevented from participating in TUC activities such as training courses etc; the majority of EETPU members work on multi-union sites, so doubt and uncertainty must be creeping into the minds of many EETPU members about what Hammond is doing to their organisation.
The 25,000 who voted against “independence” provide a good starting point from which to build an opposition to Hammond provided the left doesn’t surrender in advance.
The alternative to this course of action it to hope to ‘convince’ electricians by means of a membership war. Apart from the fact, despite what Martin says, that this is something at which the officials are as good as the left, this strategy is more likely to benefit non-unionism than the TUC.
Obviously socialists can’t be neutral in any membership war between the EETPU and the TUC. We are for TUC unions organising non-union and new sites, we are against EETPU poaching; but we should relate to existing EETPU members by saying “look at the situation Hammond has got our union into, we should force him out”.
The alternative proposed by the “Flashlight” leadership of running away from a fight against Hammond is no alternative at all. It may provide a few bureaucratic positions for Flashlight leaders in a new TUC union (or in the “holding” branches) but it’s a dead-end for most EETPU members. It’s a stragegy that flows from the traditional outlook of some of the more Stalinist elements in the EETPU left, an outlook that found it’s crassest expression in 1964 when CP members were banned from holding office in the union.
How did the ancestors of some Flashlight leaders react then? The CP instructed them to resign their positions and return to the tools to act as rank and file members. The ‘left’ bureaucrats responded by tearing up their Party cards.
It’s the same kind of bureaucratic response being advocated by the Flashlight leaders today. We shouldn’t support it.
Tom Rigby Walworth