Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Russia is a workers' state

Socialist Organiser no. 366, 11 August 1988 · scan p. 4 · Duncan Chapel · about 261 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: a letter answering Laurens Otter in SO 365, printed below Tom Rigby's Stay in the EETPU and fight! and signed Duncan Chapel, Nottingham. Transcribed from the scan of page 4. 'inconsistant', 'indespensible', 'acheived' and 'worker's liberty' are as printed.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 4

In SO365, Laurens Otter argued two points: that SO is inconsistant by rejecting the theory that the Soviet Bureaucracy is a new class while we call the USSR imperialist; and secondly no radical can support an economically progressive action of Capitalism or Stalinism.

The USSR is not imperialist in Lenin’s term — capitalism’s highest stage. I don’t think “imperialist” is the best way to describe the USSR. But consider the Roman or Turkish Empires. They weren’t capitalist either, but they were imperialist in the same sense the USSR is — driven by the tendency to increase the power, prestige and revenues of their ruling stratum.

Laurens suggests this means the Bureaucracy has to be a new class! He’s wrong. It plays no indespensible role in the process of production. It does not own the means of production. It cannot guarantee, or transfer to its children the material advantages it has.

On “progressive” Stalinism, Laurens misses the point again. The Red Army’s record in Afghanistan is reactionary: over 5 million refugees; a devastated economy; villages, families and agriculture ruined.

In ‘Revolution Betrayed’ Trotsky argued that when Stalinism does something progressive we say so, and we say it’s good. That doesn’t mean defending the Bureaucracy — for the massive gains made by Soviet workers are made possible by the nationalised economy, and are acheived in spite of the Bureaucrats.

Our programme remains the same: a workers’ revolution in the USSR and across the world which exchanges Capitalist and Stalinist oppressors for workers’ control and worker’s liberty, East and West.

Duncan Chapel Nottingham

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 366

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →