Forward to socialism
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-07-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
by Eric breword by Tony Benn MP Heffer MP 50 bend gap between the low paid -who are mainly women - and those on higher pay. Collective bargaining has clearly failed to achieve this redistribution.
I support Party Policy on the issue of abortion. I believe there should be changes in the law to give women the right to choose whether or not they have an abortion, and to ensure that abortion facilities are available, free within the National Health Service, on an equal basis throughout the country.
I have voted against attempts to restrict the 1967 Abortion Act on three occasions in the House of Commons, and 1 voted for Jo Richardson's Abortion Facilities Bill in 1981.
The links between the Women's Organisation and the rest of the Party could be strengthened by the adoption of a formal constitution and rules for the Women's Organisation This article is taken from "Forward to Socialism" by Eric Heffer. I1 originally appeared in Socialist Organiser.
Scan page 7
OUR BODIES
OLLOW PARTY POLC r: the left's candidate This sign greets "illegal" immigrants lat a detention centre hear in his article, he has voted nst attempts in House of imons to restrict women's ss to abortion. Since he e his article, he has also d against the Alton Bill -harp contrast to Roy Hatey and other Labour MPs either abstained or stayed , often not even out of perI conviction but from fear antagonising antitionists in their constitueniffer makes it clear that he orts the right of women in abour Party to have their : heard, and supports ands for the democratisaof Labour women's conce, despite his worries t the accountability and reignty of the Party ConIce. le proposals for manifesto" certainly need to be fleshed out. Exactly how should positive action programmes be implemented? We don't want a re-run of the actions of some Labour local authorities, where bureaucratically ham-handed efforts to get women into traditionally male areas of work led to unnecessary splits in the workforce, and isolation and hardship for the pioneer For a programme of positive action to be of any real use, rather than simply an exercise in divisive tokenism, it has to be under trade union control and tied to an expansion of jobs.
Of course, any manifesto for women will mean very little while the Labour Party refuses to support women's struggles — the fight against Alton, the strikes by healthworkers earlier lour CON this year → and refuses to fight for decent housing, an adequate minimum wage, full nursery provision, proper welfare benefits, the basic economic underpinnings for women's rights.
Eric Heffer stands for a Labour Party which sides with workers and with working-class women, and which bases itself on the struggles and needs of the working class. His statement on women's rights is miles ahead of the wishy-washy generalities in Neil Kinnock's "Policy Review' documents.
That some feminists in the Labour Party refuse to support Heffer is more a symptom of the growing divide between some brands of feminism and radical socialist politics, than a comment on Heffer's credentials. Recently I attended an induction course explaining the structure and some of the policies of local government and Wandsworth Council, in particular. One of the courses was entitled Equal Opportunities. Though the Council has a reputation of being more Thatcherite than Thatcher some of its objectives were quite interesting.
The Council aims to employ a workforce that broadly reflects the ethnic composition of the borough ie 20%. In 1985, 8.4% of the officers and 15% of the manual staff were from the ethnic minorities. Recruitment was running at 9% and 24% for officers and manual staff, respectively.
The equal opportunities officer explained how the Council had been pushed into creating structures and procedures to achieve these objec tives. He rejected the analysis that racism was to do with "bad' individuals who should be made to change by feeling guilty. However when questioned about the role trade unions could play he was dismissive: "they are the most racist organisations of all". Unfortunately this is a very common view.
Britain has a history steeped in racism; yet the black population is comparatively well integrated. A study in 1984 found that 56% of West Indians and Asians were in a union compared to 47% of whites. Nevertheless black representation in union structures does not match up.
Spurred on by a declining membership and an increasing level of activity from below, unions are slowly beginning to take the issue of representing black members' interests more seriously. In 1985, the NUPE Race Equality Working Party came up with certain recommendations: Race Relations Committees at branch, divisional and national levels; rules against racism and racist behaviour; multi-lingual leaflets; education courses; attempts to negotiate equal opportunity agreements; opposition to immigration laws and support for Black Sections in the Labour Party.
Monitoring, once a controversial issue, widely accepted ache NUCPS necessary step. estimates the proportion of black civil servants at 6-10% of its membership. The Institution of Professional Civil Servants (ICPS) said that the level of its black membership was "likely to be very small in view of the low numbers (of black people) within the civil service grades we represent"
The reissued TUC Black Workers Charter includes policies on positive action. A Labour Research Department study of 24 unions found that about half had national officers for issues affecting black members.
The NUT won an industrial tribunal case concerning a member who was excluded from applying for internal promotion. This issue of representation at all levels in the workforce and unions is very important. In Wandsworth, where the ethnic minorities are well represented in numbers on the Heathrow. Photo Andrew Moore manual side the small number black officers and the prospects promotion are real gripes.
Even so, unions could do more to represent their black members where they are now which tends to] be in the lower paid jobs. Improving the pay and conditions of those workers must be a priority.
Black people do not tend to take positions in the unions because many are not confident that the unions are responding to their special needs. Nowadays many unions produce multi-lingual leaflets. The ACTT Jobfit' scheme aims to get 35% of students from ethnic minorities.
Some unions including UCATT, NUJ and notably NALGO are involved in anti-deportation campaigns around individual members. The Bakers' Union, NUT and ACTT prohibit or discipline racist activity. CPSA bars members of fascist political parties from holding office in the union.
Equal opportunity agreements are commonplace. The GMB has negotiated for employment monitoring and industrial language training. In the Civil Service 26-point action program on recruitment has been agreed. It involves career development, appointment of Equal Opportunity Officers, use of targets and programmes and general opposition to racism. Some unions have won extended leave agreements, essential for workers with family and social commitments abroad.
There is a growing acceptance of the importance black self-organisation. In many cases it is the pressure these groups have brought to bear that has changed union policies and attitudes. The NUJ Race Relations Party is 90% black and has the right to move and speak to motions at conference. The NALGO black workers is a well organised and powerful group that is recognised by the union and holds its own national conference.
Black people have constantly struggled against low wages and appalling working conditions. They have also had to face racism in their unions. But they have always shown their willingness to organise alongside white workers. And increasingly, black and white workers have taken action against organised racists. The latest being the action by CPSA members objecting to the employment of a fascist activist in Hither Green.
We must continue to press for our union leaders to take up issues that matter to black members and to extend their campaign to recruit unorganised black workers, many of whom work in sweat-shop conditions.
As socialists our aim is to bring people along with us, and to get maximum involvement. That is why work in the unions and the Labour Party is not just an option but a necessity. For we recognise that the only force that can change society and begin to root out racism completely is the working class.
VI
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no. 365. 28 July 1988. The Jewish question in the capitalist world As a trading people, whose survival in the midst of other peoples has been rooted in a particular social function, the Jews have seen their fate determined across the ages by the general evolution of society, an evolution which changed their relations with the different classes.
The bourgeois revolution in Western Europe opened the gates of the ghettoes and integrated the Jewish masses into the society around them. The assimilation of the Jews seemed to be decided. But the countries of central and eastern Europe, the greatest reservoirs of Jews who had been pigeon-holed for centuries in the role of economic intermediaries, entered on the path of capitalist development at the same time as world capitalism had already entered its imperialist phase.
While the old relations of exchange and production were rapidly overturned, taking away from the Jews the material basis of their existence, there was no massive industrialisation allowing these millions of intermediaries who had become redundant to become integrated into the proletariat. The social differentiation of the Jewish masses was thus hindered. Only a small part of the Jews became capitalist or proletarian; a bigger part emigrated, thus counteracting the tendency towards complete assimilation which was operating in the western countries. The great majority remained in a miserable condition as small traders, "crushed between feudalism and capitalism, the decay of one augmenting the decay of the other" (A. Leon).
The anti-semitic movements of the past always had a direct or indirect social base. They were movements of different social classes whose interests came successively into conflict with the social function of the Jew.
It was the same with the revival which anti-semitism experienced around the beginning of the 20th centurya) In the underdeveloped countries of Eastern Europe, reactionary political forces succeeded in diverting the discontent and despair of the masses towards periodic pogroms because the hatred of the poor towards the Jewish small moneylender, pawnbroker, small trader and inn-keeper was an undeniable social reality.
b) In the countries of central found their social roots in the sharpening of the competition within the commercial and professional middle classes which were submerged by a tide of Jewish immigrants.
гуа5.383Т Over the next few weeks Socialist Organiser will be serialising some documents Zionism and Palestine from the archives of the Marxist movement.
Today it is conventional wisdom for much of the left that anti-imperialism requires the destructon of Israel. 44 years ago, at the Labour Party conference of 1944, the left thought it had scored a great victory when it committed the next Labour government to assisting the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine. In 1945-48, many socialists and Trotskyists backed the Zionists in Palestine)
the grounds that, with whatever wrong ideas, they were fighting imperialism.
Today we naturally side with the oppressed Palestinian Arabs whose revolt against Israeli rule in the occupied territories is now 8 months old. But clearly Zionism and Palestine are issues where instinct and immediate impulses of solidarity are not enough to give socialists a clear view. We have to think the issues through, try to get an overview, and check our conclusions against the analyses and c) In France, the anti-semitic movement which was unleashed at the time of the Dreyfus affair found its social origin in the hatred of the aristocracy for the Jewish bankers who bought up their chateaux, and of the aristocrats' sons who saw the careers which until then had been 'reserved' for them occupied by these dangerous competitors.
These social layers succeeded in directing against the Jews, for a certain period, the embittered nationalist feelings of a large part of the petty bourgeoisie.
Having their roots in determinate social conflicts, these different antisemitic movements appeared with very diverse manifestations, from phenomena of the crudest barbarism (the Russian pogroms) to the formulation of refined' nationalist theories characteristic of the imperialist epoch (Charles Maurras). 3 the assimilation of Jews in The social possibilities of Western Europe had created a powerful ideological movement towards total assimilation.
The impossibility of a massive assimilation of Jews in Eastern Europe gave rise to a powerful current in favour of a national renaissance and the conservation of national peculiarities. In the midst of strong concentrations of Jewish people, in Poland, in Lithuania, in western Russia, in Hungary, in Rumania, and in Slovakia, there developed a new literature in Yiddish, a new folklore, an intense cultural life and even an autonomous political life (the 'Bund' in the workers' movement).
To the extent that the Jewish masses who had emigrated to the United States found themselves socially pigeon-holed in determinate sectors of economic life, and arguments developed in the past.
The first document we are printing is the Draft Theses produced by the International Secretariat fo the Fourth International in January 1947, and probably written by Ernest Mandel. The second part, which will appear in the next issue of SO, has the political conclusions. This first part summarises the historical analyses of Jewry and anti-semitism developed by Abram Leon in his book "The Jewish Question' , and assesses Zionism and anti-semitism in 1946-7.
Forty years of hindsight reveal many flaws in the document. It underestimates capitalism's ability to revive; it overestimates the force of Arab nationalism; it underestimates the strength of the Zionist drive for a Jewish state. But on many questions of basic attitude and approach the document is a valuable check on today's debates on the left.
The document opposes Zionism. But its arguments are entirely different from those used by many anti-Zionists today in their description of Zionism in the 1940s.
geographically concentrated, this movement was extended to that countryLenin, who alone in the Second international knew how to apply a Marxist strategy to the national question, rejected all pedantry in his assessment of this current. He started from the viewpoint that the task of the revolutionary party was to integrate into the movement of proletarian emancipation all the currents of national and cultural autonomy which corresponded to the genuine aspirations of the working masses. That is why he recognised the legitimacy, from a socialist point of view, of this Jewish movement as much as of the Polish or Czech movement.
The task of the Jewish workers was to fight side by side with the workers of the country where they lived, for the overthrow of capitalism, after which complete liberty would be granted to them to organise things for their national and cultural autonomy according to their choice.
The epoch of decaying capitalism is also the epoch of the aggravated crisis of the Jewish problem.
Inflation, increased pressure from banking capital, and then the great economic crisis, ruin millions of small tradespeople and shopkeepers, and raise their hatred against Jewish competitors to extremes. The terrible unemployment among intellectual workers, and the numerous bloody explosions. increased poverty of the liberal professions in central and eastern Europe, create a particularly favourable climate for the appearance of huge mass petty bourgeois movements, which make anti-semitism one of their ideological weapons.
In the countries of Eastern Europe, these movements reflect an Byt Palestinian exodus 1967 after Six Day War. extremely profound popular cur- masses in Europe during the war. rent, which expresses itself in —The extermination of the European Jews by German imperialism In Germany the State power, is a warning for all the other which had fallen into the hands of peoples, showing them the fate the Nazi leaders, organised from which awaits them if present-day above the persecution and, later, society continues to rot. the extermination of the Jews. In this sense it was decaying capitalism Zionism was born in the which consciously put power into the hands of a band of bloody criminals, and is fully responsible of Central Europe, as a for the terrible fate of the Jewish eaction to the rise of anti-Jewish reft ve in Haifa 1949
Scan page 9
semitism at the beginning of the 20th century.
It was a typically petty-bourgeois movement, and for a long time it remained without aid from the Jewish bourgeoisie and isolated from the popular masses. In the course of the First World War, British imperialism, wanting to use Zionism as an instrument to install itself in Palestine, seemed to give it the possibility of becoming a reality, through the Balfour Declaration. After that, a slight inflow of capital and immigration began, It was not until after Hitler's coming to power, and the rapid descent into the abyss of all European Jewry, that these two flows accelerated, though at the same time they were hindered by Arab nationalist explosions and by the policy of British imperialism, which was erecting more and more barriers to Jewish penetration in Palestine, For the revolutionary proletariat, Zionism should be considered as both an utopian and a reactionary movement.
Utopian:
a) Because it considers possible a "harmonious' development of the productive forces In a "closed economy' in Palestine, in the middle of a capitalist world which is subject to greater and greater economic convulsions. The tremendous development of the Palestinian economy which would be necessary to allow the absorption of several million immigrants unrealisable in the framework of the present-day world capitalist economyb) Because it considers possible the creation of a Jewish (or binational State in the midst of the avowed hostility of 50 million Arabs, although Jewish immigraand the progressive industrialisation of the country develop the Arab population in the same proportion.
c) Because it hopes to obtain this result by relying on manoeuvres between the great powers, which in reality all only want to use the Zionist movement as a pawn in their power-politics in the Arab world.
d) Because it thinks it can neutralise anti-semitism in the world just by granting a nationality to the Jews, although this antisemitism has deep social, historical and ideological roots, which will be all the more difficult to tear up as the agony of capitalism prolongs itself.
Reactionary:
a) Because it serves as a support for British imperialist domination, giving imperialism the pretext of serving as an 'arbiter' of the JewishArab disputes, itself demanding the maintenance of the British mandate, and developing a miniature "closed' Jewish economy whose working masses have a much higher standard of living than, and different immediate interests from, the Arab working masses.
b) Because it provokes a nationalist reaction on the part of the Arab masses, causes a racial division in the workers movement, classes among both aliance and reinforces the 'holy alliance' of Arabs, and thus allows imperialism to perpetuate this conflict, as a means to perpetuate the presence of troops in Palestine.
c) Because it slows down the movement for agrarian revolution by buying land from the Arab lanlowners and developing it, thanks to foreign subsidies, as 'closed' Jewish agriculture in the midst of Palestinian Arab agriculture. Thus the position of the landowners is somewhat reinforced, land is taken away from the Arab peasants, and, most important, the Jewish masses of Palestine have no interest in fighting for the division of the land of the 'effendis' among the Arab peasants, because such division would mean the end of their land purchases.
d) Because it puts a brake on the participation of the Jewish working-class masses in the class struggle in the rest of the world, gives them autonomous aims to achieve, and creates illusions in the possibity of improving their condition in the framework of decaying world capitalism.
For all these reasons, the revolutionary workers' movement has always waged a sharp , struggle against Zionist ideology and practice. The arguments that the "socialist' representatives of Zionism advance in favour of their case are either classic reformist arguments ('the possibility of improving the situation of the Jewish masses bit by bit...'), or social-patriotic arguments ('the national question for all Jews must first be resolved before undertaking the How the question itself in 1 solution of social problems for the Jewish workers'), or the classic arguments of defenders of imperialism ('the penetration of Jews in Palestine has not only developed industry, but also the workers' movement, the general culture of the masses, their standard of living, etc'.), arguments advanced by the defenders of colonialism in every country.
Jewish presents he world After the Second World war, the particularly tragic situation of the Jews seems to be a symbol for the whole tragedy of humanity sliding towards barbarism.
After the terrible catastrophe of European Jewry, the Jews everywhere face a renewal of popular hostility towards them.
a) In Europe, two years after the "liberation' , more than 100,000 Jews continue to suffer the most infamous regime in the camps; the imperialist masters who in the course of their military operations managed to move millions of people in a few days, have not been able to find any refuge for these unfortunate survivors of the Nazi camps after 20 months of searSOCIALSI Middle East with she right s0 • M OR GAIN TIS OR Including the larsall Jeme! We for all nadent.
The way to Arab-Jewish workers' unity Why 'two states'?
INSIDE Tale HasT Lies the ching. In the rest of the continent, there are scarcely a million Jews remaining.l b) In Palestine, 700,000 Jews face an Arab world in ferment. The development of Egyptian and Syrian capitalism adds the factor of economic competition to the multiple causes of militant anti-Zionism. British imperialism and the Arab feudalists and bourgeois, for their part, will do all they can to divert the hatred of the oppressed Arab masses against the Jewish scapegoat. Thus the Palestinian Jews risk being exterminated in the general explosion which is brewing in the Middle East.
c) In the USSR, the bureaucracy used in its struggle against the opposition the anti-semitism which remained latent in the peasant masses and the backward sections of the working class. During the years of the first and second Five Year Plans, millions of Jewish tradespeople and shopkeepers were integrated into the middle and lower ranks of the bureaucracy as engineers, technicians, and cooperative directors, and into the upper layers of the collective farms. In western Russia they make up the part of the bureaucracy which is most directly in contact with the oppressed masses, and thus the masses' hatred against the parasites and profiteers of the regime is largely focused on them.
The bloody pogroms unleashed by the indigenous population at the time of the German invasion are very clear indices of the sharpening of this hatred (70,000 Jews killed in Kiev within 24 hours). A sharpening of the social crisis in Russia, and the purging of civil war, will certainly mean the extermination of the Jewish masses if the counterrevolution triumphs.
d) Finally, in the United States, the pigeon-holing of Jews into determinate sectors of the trades, commerce, and liberal professions, will create at the next violent economic crisis the sharpening of competition which will give a powerful material base to antisemitism, which is already present in latent form. The exploitation of reactionary prejudices against 'racial minorities' has long been the favourite weapon of the American fascist gangsters.
As the sharpening of the social crisis, the politicisation of the workers' movement, and the rapid decomposition of American 'democracy' engender the development of a mass tascist party in America, so anti-semitism and antinegro agitation will take on monstrous proportions. The fate of the Jews in the United States is intimately linked to the outcome of the gigantic struggle of the American working class and the Yankee bourgeoisie. A victory of the latter, through the establishment of a dictatorship, will mean, in the short term, a catastrophe comparable only to the catastrophe which Hitler's coming to power was for the Jews of Europe.
Revenge': post from SE15 4NA 365.
----- pull-quotes -----
DEPARTU HIS NAY
Europe, anti-semitic movements like that of mayor Lüger in Vienna
Democracy, not revenge!
'Democracy, Not for 20p plus 13p Box 823, London