Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A sell-out by the mullahs?

Socialist Organiser no. 365, 28 July 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 1,723 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Socialist Worker believe he died fighting a just war.

Socialist Organiser no. 365. 28 July 1988. Page 5 The Iranian decision to sue for peace in the Gulf War has produced an extremely bizarre response from the Socialist Last week's Socialist Worker made very strange reading indeed.

Originally the SWP had adopted a serious and sober approach to the Tran/Iraq war, defining it as "A bloody war of attrition between two sub-imperialisms fighting for local rather than global hegemony." In that there was agreement between ourselves and ete sat ithere This implied that was nothing to chose between the two regimes. The workers' and peasants' interests lay in the defeat of their own bourgeoisies"!

All that has changed. The SWP argued that once the US had become more deeply involved in the Gulf conflict then the nature of the war changed.

*The conflict is now primarily between the Khomeini regime and the US plus nearly all the Arab regimes. In these circumstances victory for Iraq is a victory for imperialism... we have no choice but to support the Khomeini regime against the US and its allies"!

But now the SWP has gone further down the pro-Iranian road. The only possible interpretation of last week's Socialist Worker is that Iran was in the right from the start, that Iran's role in the Iran/Iraq war has always beeen anti-imperialist and that, therefore by implication, the SWP's original position was totally wrong.!

This is what Socialist Worker said last week:

"When thể war began the western powers welcomed Iraq's attack on the regime which emerged from the Iranian revolution. They hoped an Iraqi victory would allow them to dominate the area just as they did before the fall of the Shah... Even with all the forces raged against Iran it would have been possible to defeat imperialism. But at every stage (ie from 1980) the interests of fighting the Iraqis and Americans were subordinated to the interests of the Mullahs who dominate the Iranian state"

It is impossible to read this and not draw the conclusion that the SWP believe the Iranian cause in the war was just from the beginning. The SWP should be honest and say they now think this, or they should drop this line of argument.

They then go on to denounce the Mullahs for holding back the 'antiimperialist' war effort by attacking the Kurds, forcing women to wear the veil and attacking the workers? movement.

"If Khomeini had mobilised the Kurds to fight imperialism rather than repressing them, if the Iranian leadership had encouraged workers to exercise control over the war against imperialism instead of intensifying their exploitation, if they had encouraged the participation of Socialişt | Iranian women and not oppressed them then the war could have been won".

This is strange indeed. If only the workers had been in power in Tehran then the war could have been won is the SWP's basic argument.

What's wrong with this is that it dresses up the Iran/Iraq war as an "anti-imperialist war" on Iran's part and then argues for socialism and workers' power not from the point of view of it being necessary for the working class and the oppressed, but from the angle that working class socialism is the most efficient and militant form of "anti-imperialism"

This is the crassest populism. It is fantasy politics.

The pioneer Russian Marxist George Plekhanov criticised this populist approach long ago when he argued that the Marxists — as opposed to the populists, or today's 'anti-imperialist' SWP "is convinced that not the workers are necessary for the revolution, but that the revolution for the workers"

In order to justify this populism the SWP adopt some mind bogglingly incoherent arguments. For example:

"The war was used as an excuse to force women off the streets and back behind the veil... if they had encouraged the involvement of Iranian women and not oppressed then, then the war could have been The SWP are distorting reality. The Islamic regime started to attack women's rights in February and March 1979, long before the start of the Iran/Iraq war.

Anyway, socialists do not advocate the liberation of women because it is the most effective way of defeating imperialism but because it is in the interests of women themselves and must be part of the socialist revolution.

Last week's Socialist turned this upside down.

Another example of this politics is the argument:

"If the Iranian leadership had encouraged workers to exercise control over the war against imperialism instead of intensifying their exploitation", and: "If he (ie Khomeini) had used the revolutionary enthusiasm and organisation to fight the war, the chances of success would have been far greater"

So the SWP advocate that the leader of the bloody counterrevolution uses revolutionary enthusiasm and organisation! And that the butcher of the Iranian working class 'encourage' workers This is fantasy on such a scale that it makes the Utopian socialists whom Marx and Engels criticised for believing that the ruling class could be convinced of the desirability of socialism appear as rational scientific socialists.

In fact, even if the SWP were right, and they are not, that Iran's war was just, under no circumstances would we advocate placing such fantastic hopes in Khomeini. It would be ABC for Marxists to insist on working class inchange of line last year, to justify their stance now. They fade out whole parts of the picture such as the Mullahs' use of the human wave of unarmed children against modern military technology or the imperialist including Israeli) sources of Iranian arms. Any spurious argument or questionable 'fact' that can be found is used to justify their support for Khomeini's war. -This is the crassest example:

However much it sticks in our gullet, imperialism dictates that we support Iran. If there was any doubt about this then the decisive argument came with the news that the Israelis had lined up with Iraq."

(SW, 28 November 1987)

So for the SWP what is decisive in assessing the class nature of a war is imperialism's attitude to the conflict and in particular it seems the attitude of the Israeli state.

Apart from being dishonest, as Israel has supplied arms to Iran, it is a typical piece of the SWP's "socialist" anti-Zionism But arguing that "Iniperialism backs Iraq therefore we support Iran" is a million miles away from Marxism.

As Trotsky used to argue, socialists do not develop their political line by saying no every time the bourgeoisie says yes. Otherwise every sectarian would be a master strategist. In assessing any war Marxists start off from the idea that -although the US and other superpowers want the war to end, a peace with victors would cause ditficulties, especially if the victor was Khomeini. They are anxious to prevent the Islamic revolution disturbing their friends in the Arab Gulf states and Saudi Arabia. Thus the basic US policy has been containment. It is to this end that US ships were dispatched to the Gulf last summer.

The "tanker war', initiated by Iraq, threatened oil exports in general; when it began to threaten Kuwaiti oil exports, the US decided something had to be done. Import trade routes are just as important, it region currently absores s6,o0c million worth of goods a year, of which half comes from the EEC and a third from the United States.

So the presence of the United States fleet in the Gulf is not for the objective of Khomeini's overthrow, as many on the left have believed Of course Reagan detests Khomeini, but the US is not at present in a position to remove him. Direct colonial conquest or a Vietnamstyle war would be unthinkably costly in a country as large, as populated and as relatively advanced as Iran — unthinkable politically and economically. To replace Khomeini, the US needs an alliance with a domestic political force. At the moment there is no one to ally with: imperialism has no alternative to Khomeini.

The best option for the US is to woo elements within the existing regime. Indeed it has no other option. The most likely alternative to Khomeini at the moment would be worse, from the US point of view -more fundamentalist, more anti-American. The best policy in the meantime is to maintain the stalemate, putting pressure on Iran to accept Resolution 598. This is what is going on now in the Gulf. Anyone who thinks it is now, or is likely to be, an all-out US-Iranian war has completely misunderstood the dynamics of the situation.

Within the policy of containment, the US is - for the moment - giving support to Iraq, and has put pressure on its allies (such as Israel) to do likewise. But the US Reagan's priority.

The US did not even aim to overthrow Khomeini let alone to subject Iran to direct colonial occupation. (And if Iran were conquered by the US we would be in favour of a fight for Iranian independence and at the same time argue for independence from the Mullahs under all conditions.

Therefore to still support Iran in the light of these facts is to accept Khomeini's 'anti-imperialism' as good coin. It is to argue that the working class should adopt Khomeini's "anti-imperialism' except fight for it more militantly than Khomeini.

But what Khomeini means by "anti-imperialism' is aggressive Iranian nationalism and Islamic fundamentalism. It is the cover behind which the mullahs attacked and murdered the Iranian left. It is at least as dangerous for Iranian workers as US or British nationalism is for workers in the US or Britain.

Socialist anti-imperialism in the industrially developing, politically independent sub-imperialist coun tries like Iran or Argentina can only mean waging the class war against your 'own' ruling class and their foreign backers.

Its aims and starting point are completely different from Khomeinite 'anti-imperialism' . In fact in Khomeini's understanding of the term socialists are imperialist, if "imperialism' includes support for women's right not to be forced to wear the veil, and 'western' ideas like Marxism and socialism.

There is no 'anti-imperialist" continuum stretching from Khomeini to the Iranian working class. There is a river of blood dividing them and the SWP are on the wrong side.

----- pull-quotes -----

Photo Kaveh C-: i (Reflex)

victory is goly i require more than that. An Iraqi victory is not

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 365

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →