Lessons of the Gulf War
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-07-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
› purge the poll- tax
*Making this decision was more
deadly than taking poison" said Ayatollah Khomeini of his government's decision to sue for peace with Iraq.
It is to be hoped that an end to the Gulf War will indeed see the old man off.
It seems that the war will end. Iraq's Saddam Hussein has been pushing his advantage very hard, invading Iran and scoring further victories. But Saddam's aim is to get the most favourable possible deal in the ceasefire talks, rather than to go for Khomeini's throat. He has taken too many risks already in the eight years of this gruesome conflict.
The 'war of words' goes on, but the gradual shift towards diplomacy is evident. The real question now is: how can either regime make the transition from war to peace while maintaining their own stability?
Iran has undoubtedly been preparing. The dominant Rafsanjani faction, which opted tor the peace settlement, has concentrated power in its own hands and seems confident it can maintain it. Certainly its rivals - principally, more hard-line fundamentalists - are not in a position to move against Katsanjanı.
Probably, once peace is secured, the dominant trend will be towards a rapprochement with the Great Satan' Washington - parSocials Organiser -0 Box 823 London SE15 4* 01-639 7965 ales date for reports: first post Mom дау or by рпопе. Monday overng.
Editor: John O Mahony Typesettrng: Upstream Ltd (TU) 01-358 13* -ublisird by Socialist Organiser PO en-923. London SE15 4T.* Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU), Registered as a newspapor at the Post Office.
Signed articles do not iracessarily reflect the view of Socialist Okaniser ticularly once there is a administration in the US.
Saddam also seems relatively secure, although Kurdish oppositionists (allied with Iran) are by no means silenced.
Of course, things could go wrong, and long-term hostilities could start up again. Early expectations for how soon peace would come have proved too optimistic. But the war does seem to be moving towards an end.
In the Iranian capital, Tehran, there was dancing in the streets. For the war has been increasingly r unpopular. If Rafsanjani's plan is to stall for time, rebuilding Iranian forces under cover of a prolonged ceasefire, he will find stiff resistance within Iran to a return to war.
Undoubtedly, the mullahs need to rebuild their military forces, which are certainly demoralised and by some accounts virtually in collapse. The 'revolutionary guards' are needed as much for internal repression as for external warfare. Question: What happens to Labour Party members who recruit people to the Labour Party to fight the poll tax. Answer: They get expelled!
This is now the fate hanging over Tommy Sheridan, a member of Pollok Constituency Labour Party and secretary of the local anti-poll tax union. Notoriously right-wing Pollok MP Jimmy Dunnachie has persuaded the Labour Party National Executive Committee (not that it needs much persuading) to launch an enquiry into alleged Militant 'infiltration' of Pollok CLP in general, and into Tommy Sheridan in particular.
But on both sides, if the transition to peace can be made smoothly, there will have to be military demobilisation for both political and economic reasons.
The Gulf war has had a lot to teach socialists. Both the Iraqi and the Iranian regimes have, at different times, declared themselves 'anti-imperialist'. Both have accused the other of 'pro-imperialism' (among other things). Yet the war has never been a contest between "imperialism' and 'the masses' , ог between 'progress' and 'reaction' Both sides have acted as miniimperialists, seeking to dominate the region, directly oppressing minority nationalities (especially, but not only, Kurds), and depriving their populations the most elementary democratic rights.
On both sides, the war was used to beat left-wing opponents into purge t The latter's crimes, according to Dunnachie, include: * Criticising in public Labour's current (do-nothing) policy on the poll tax (does Dunnachie think that Kinnock should be expelled as well for his public attacks on Labour's nuclear defence policies?). * Urging people to join the Labour Party to strengthen the campaign for non-payment of the Poll Tax (Dunnachie is, of course, totally opposed to non-payment).
Advocating de-selection of Labour elected representatives who failed to fight the poll tax (for obvious reasons, Dunnachie, himself selected as a Labour candidate by only a small majority, is less than enthusiastic about notions of democracy and accountability). * Being a "self-confessed member of the Militant tendency", and arsubmission. In Iran, the spectre of "imperialism' was used to hoodwink many leftists into believing they did have something in common - a common enemy — with Khomeini.
This was not merely naivety: it flowed from a widely-promoted view of the world. It proved, quite literally, fatal.
American imperialism is, obviously, hostile to the Iranian regime. But - a second lesson - it is not able simply to replace that regime at will with a more suitable one. It needs allies within Iran, and those it lacks.
The relationship between Iran and the US is not akin to old colonial and semi-colonial relationships. Imperial colonies always had large social layers who benefited from colonial rule and could be relied upon to help maintain it. Elsewhere, more recently, savagely right-wing regimes have looked to the US for support in conditions where the US would not need to intervene directly and militarily. Chile he poll- ti ranging a meting - on behalf of the local_ anti poll-tax union -which included ex-Liverpool councillor Tony Mulhearn as one of the platform speakers.
One motivating force behind the enquiry is hostility toward Militant. Pollok CLP recently passed a resolution declaring the "promotion of Militant to be an infringement of Labour Party rules. And the chair of Pollok CLP, Stuart MacLennan, formerly a "self-confessed" Trotskyıst hımselt, shows the same attitude towards "Militant' in the Labour Party as he does towards them in his dealings in the CPSA.
But the Labour Party right wing is also anxious to put the skids under anti-poll tax campaigning.
As the call for non-payment continues to gain ground and more Labour Party members become an example.
But in Iran there is no base, at the moment for a pro-American regime, at least not one openly and avowedly so, depending on American military support. And so the American naval intervention that began last summer was unlikely ever to aim further than a policy of containment. The subjection of Iran or even the overthrow of Khomeini, was in reality beyond their means.
And so the Gulf War which is ending now is that same reactionary war on both sides that started in September 1980. The socialist policy that best matched the requirements of the situation was unrelenting hostility to both sides in the war throughout it, from beginning to end and beyond.
Before, during and after, we must look to the downfall of Saddam and Khomeini and build solidarity with Iranian and Iraqi socialists fighting to bring about that downfall.
fight critical of the role of Labour controlled councils in administering the poll tax, so too the right wing (whose line on the poll tax is: hang on in there until the next General Election) become increasingly ruthless in its efforts to head off the burgeoning campaign against the In Kinnock's New Model Labour Party the solution they have adopted is the obvious one — call in the NEC and expel the troublemakers. And what better place to start than with an anti-poll tax campaigner who also subscribes to 'Militant's' ideas, thus enabling the anti-Militant prejudices of sections of the Labour Party to be exploited and mobilised in an attack on the involvement of any Labour Party member in anti-poll tax campaigning.
Scan page 4
Unequal opportunities Eric Hammond of the EETPU with Kate Losinska of CPSA the TUC in Brighton 1986. Photo: Andrew Wiard, Report Research from the US on the effects of the market in healthcare indicates that "competition kills patients. Medical researchers Shortell and Hughes studied data from a total of 214,839 patients on Medicare, being treated for 16 common complaints in 981 hospitals in the year 1983-4.
They found correlations between higher mortality rates and 3 main factors. Hospitals with stringent procedures for reviewing charges had death rates 6-10% higher than the average. Hospitals with strict procedures for reviewing 'certificates of need' had mortality rates 5-6% higher. Also significant was the impact Health negotiates cover for basic medical needs. Shortell and Hughes research shows that HMOs lead to pressure on hospitals to cut their costs and treat more patients as out-patients.
The general conclusions are that competition and cost control Lambeth Council has decided to give pay rises of thousands of pounds each to senior managerial staff, whilst ratting on a pay agreement with lower paid workers.
Staff in the Grants and Mortgages section, all of whom earn under €10,000 a year were due a total of £85,000 in back pay between them. Lambeth now drive hospitals to economies which rise in mortality.
The schemes investigated are very similar to those that Tory advisors would like introduced here. Will they be taking the results of this research into account?
whereas the deal with the Grants and Mortgages section was not.
Lambeth has a reputation as a 'lefty' council. It is also an equal opportunities employer. A third of the workers in the Grants and Mortgages section are black. Lambeth NALGO's deputy convenor thinks this is significant "I think Letters