Cleveland: who will listen to the children?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-07-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Cleveland: Higgs was not major culprit' been bad siastic way the doctors went ples sature of the me by the government's star ly that no physts hat the sport w Muddie as leak reveals child abuse inquiry finding. i became clear last being over- a cartier thi ar-old son was diagnosed tass year as Social workers exonerated fore inquiry report were wrong WOMAN'S Despite the Butler-Sloss report, all the TV coverage, the plethora of articles in the press, we still do not seem to have got to the bottom of what happened in Cleveland. Bits of the jigsaw seem to be missing.
How many children were abused? How many themselves verbally. backed up the medical indications? How many mothers believed the diagnosis? And how many in the back of their minds did have doubts. about the behaviour of their husband, or some other male adult: doubts they couldn't face?
Most of this we'll never find out. What is for sure is that there were children who did say they'd been abused. There were mothers who were grateful to Dr Higgs and believed her diagnosis. But these cases received little prominence in the reporting around the affair. All the individual case histories we have seen have been of families who vehemently insisted they're children hadn't been abused.
Now to be wrongly accused of abusing your own children must be a nightmare. To have your children taken away in such circumstances must be nothing short of heartbreaking. No-one can fail to be moved by the families' accounts of their suffering. But that gets us nowhere. It's cheap journalism which doesn't get us any nearer the truth.
A few weeks ago New Statesman/New Society published a long and hairaising account by a mother of her discovery that her 3 year old daughter had been abused What should Children: at risk?
by her husband's father. She gave detailed descriptions of the changes in her previously happy and welladjusted child's behaviour - her nightmares, her demands to be touched on her vulva, her displaying of her genitals to all and sundry, her alternate aggression and withdrawal. mer's events are notning new, anu The woman told her husbandwho didn't believe her. She saw psychologists, doctors — who didn't believe her, who accused her of being a screwed-up hysteric.
Eventually she told a friend involved in child therapy - who believed her and found her help. This woman didn't live in i in real crus as successive govern- 10100 Cleveland, and the events happened 2 or 3 years ago. But to read such an account gives balance to the picture and sets the events in Cleveland in a real context, the context where child abuse is still something that many professionals think happens rarely, or only in 'dysfunctional' families. Certainly not in ordinary middle class homes.
So what have we come out of the whole affair with? Well, cynically it's given a bunch of Fleet Street hacks easy copy for almost a year.
HMI HI ordinated. But do we really think the government is going to provide the necessary resources?
The real donkey work is going to be left to the voluntary agencies — incest survivors groups, Childline etc - the very groups who haven't been consulted or listened to during the whole affair. As for the abused children and the mothers, isolated and unsupported who have to deal with the abuse at the sharp end, who see their children physically and emotionally fall apart before their eyes, well no-one wants to listen to them. They're left out of the official equation, treated as objects of policy, rather than as key actors. After all, they're not professionals.
in the wake ofthe Hips Wyan ipment of the too doc vere taken from their familie ort of document potental victims af venus But while The 14-day inquiry is es -e or wilify the same it inal can le to their dedication and