Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A very British threat

Socialist Organiser no. 364, 21 July 1988 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 2,263 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

I hope Neil Kinnock was watching 'A Very British Coup'. He might have picked up a few pointers from Ray McAnally's left PM Perkins. First, that being decisive comes over a lot better than windy waffle; and second, that taking a clear class line wins votes. It's worked for Thatcher, hasn't it?

*A Very British Coup' was good telly. There should be more programmes like it. But politically, it was a bit of a muddle.

Author Chris Mullin is right that a left wing Labour government would be destabilised by the ruling class and its state organs of power — the police, MI5, the army. Surprisingly, he doesn't bring in the House of Lords, the monarchy, or the courts. Mullins story comes unstuck in his depiction of the opposition to Perkins; in his conception of the labour movement; and in the issues he thinks the Establishment would get het up about.

Perkins's opposition seems to consist of a nutter with a computer, a career civil servant, the American government and a Murdoch-style newspaper magnate. It's true that the Americans would not be best pleased by a Perkins-style Labour government. The CIA certainly had a hand in destabilising the Australian Labor government in 1975. Yet it was a true-blue Australian who finally pulled the plug. Similarly, Perkins would have met his greatest opposition from the British ruling class and not only, or even mainly, from behind-theP.M. Perkins scenes conspirators.

Mullin's view of socialism and the labour movement is also flawed. If the labour movement was strong enough to get itself a left-wing Labour government, it would also be strong enough to defend it and fight for it. But the movement is completely lacking — not a single worker is sighted, apart for a few union bigwigs in the TUC. Perkins seems to carry the whole movement on his own brawny shoulders. Browne, the career civil servant is bothered about Perkins, not because Perkins is a socialist -Browne is used to dealing with socialists - but because Perkins has got brains. He is not a bungler or a fool. The way Mullins has written it, Perkins is different from Harold Wilson or Neil Kinnock because he is smarter. He secondguesses his opponents all the time, so he's one step ahead.

But if all socialism depends a smart Prime Minister, it would seem a bit ineffectual, wouldn't it? A bit feeble?

For all Perkin's speechifying, his programme is hardly radical. Mullin seems to think nuclear disarmament is the key issue for the left, and the one issue the ruling class would fight to the death on. They probably would resist a move to take Britain out of Nato. But they'd fight longer and harder to defend their property from a Labour raid.

Perkins doesn't put them to the trouble of defending themselves. His programme is to be financed by Kremlin gold, not by seizing the wealth of the big corporations. Economics is never mentioned. No word of taking over the means of production, nothing. What kind of socialism is this?

Why did Chris Mullin write his book? He wants to warn us that Labour governments will meet with strong resistance from the ruling class, even to the point of dismissal and coups d'etat.

That is an important truth, one well worth stating. We've seen the damage Thatcher has inflicted on the labour movement in her three terms — and the ruling class is feeling confident. Her attacks are nothing to what we'd see if they really felt threatened. The thin shell of democracy would be broken. All the might of the state and its institutions would come down with a crash → the police, the army, the courts — to break the labour movement.

But a socialist movement could still beat them, could reduce the whole apparatus to nothing. The main thing is not to overestimate our opponent's strength.

A Very British Coup' makes that mistake. It's pessimistic. Reforming governments seem doomed to fail, because the state is just too strong. But the living movement that swept Perkins into No. 10 could have kept him there, and could have defeated the state that tried to crush it. The movement would first have to face the fact that legislation alone can't bring socialism. Speeches, referendums and smart Prime Ministers can't do it; only mass rank-and-file action can.

Perkins did have a good word of advice for those who forsake principles for expediency. "Tried middle of the road once - got knocked down by traffic from both directions'.

It'll take more than a Perkins to bring socialism. But it'd be a start if we could get the Labour Party out of the middle of the road. As Perkins says, it's not a safe place to be in.

of a warming trend.

Further evidence of past weather has come from studies of tree rings. These are layers of new growth put on each year, and their thickness corresponds to the quality of that year's climate. Information is available for thousands of years past and for one region, North Carolina, it indicates that the climate went through wet and dry spells, each lasting an average of 30 years. Frequently the change was an abrupt one.

On this evidence, North Carolina could be at the start of another long dry spell as part of the normal pattern, without any greenhouse effect yet being noticeable.

Other human activities are affecting the atmosphere, too. Most readers will have heard about the threat to the ozone layer from aerosol propellants (chlorofluorocarbons - CFCs). Once again, it is difficult to point to an effect and say that it is due to the destruction of the ozone layer.

The current rise in skin cancer is easily put down to the post-war habit of light-skinned people going to hot coun tries for their holidays.

But there are many theories about just what is happening to the ozone ayer. According to one idea, the total amount of ozone will remain the same, so there won't be an increase in skin cancer from the extra ultra-violet light reaching the Earth's surface. But the distribution of ozone in the atmosphere will change, leading to cooling of the upper atmosphere and war ing of lower layers. This will cause disruption of the wind and weather systems.

Yet another interesting theory sug gests that pouring extra nutrients into the sea (due to acid rain dissolving metals from the soil or from agricultural pollution) may be partly to blame for "blooms' of algae, such as killed many fish in Scandinavian waters recently. These blooms could absorb massive amounts of co from the air, thes counteracting the greenhouse effect!

It is hardly a comforting thought that we may avert disaster by perpetrating another. Despite the enormous uncertainties in the scientists' models, we have to take them seriously. Therefore, we must urgently find ways are among those 1 am not too anxious to see tested!

364. 21

Scan page 10

on socialism Martin Thomas "SOCIALISM in Britain today is surely at rock-bottom", writes Eric Heffer. "The flame of socialism, however, is not out because the class society which created it continues to exist...

Socialism has not been snuffed out. It is present in everyday life among industrial workers, in the tenants' movements, in unemployed centres etc.... It needs to be fanned into a new life with a great campaign for Socialism"

Eric Heffer has made one big contribution to that campaign for socialism by challenging Roy Hattersley for the deputy leadership of the Labour Party. This pamphlet is another contribution.

In his introduction, Tony Benn writes: "Eric is a grass-roots trade unionist with long years of experience on the shopfloor, and a socialist with a deep compassion and a vast knowledge of socialist history and theory, on which he has been able to draw in this collection"

Eric Heffer's great advantage over most of the left in the Labour Party is simple: he knows what socialism is, and he knows who must make it.

He is not deceived by the claims of the USSR and similar states to be socialist. "As a socialist, as someone who passionately believes that we cannot create a just and sane society without publicly owning our industries, under democratic management and control, I also passionately believe that it can only be achieved with real success if we ensure that free institutions exist with free elections, freedom of speech and freedom to worship according to one's choice.

Socialists cannot have double standards. We must defend the rights of working people to have free trade unions and political rights in South Africa, in Chile, in Turkey, in Pakistan, in the Philippines, in Iran, in East and West Africa. But we must defend and support the right... in the so-called socialist countries to freely organise independent free trade unions, with genuine democratic rights.

Socialism nowhere can be achieved without democracy. The twin concepts of socialism and democracy are indivisible. The struggle in Eastern Europe for democracy is also part of our struggle for socialism"

And Eric Heffer knows that the liberation of the working class must be the task of the workers themselves. "Despite all that is said by Marxism Today and Guardian writers, the working class is not dead. It is still there, with its history and fighting capacity, and it is from that premise that we must begin to redevelop the socialist movement in Britain".

Eric Heffer also argues that socialism must be international. Unlike Socialist Organiser, he favours British withdrawal from the EEC; but he also insists: "Europe's problems cannot be solved except on a European basis... What is needed is for European socialists to put forward policies that can do two things, as long and medium term objectives. In the long term, the aim must be a United Socialist States of Europe; in the medium term, a nuclear-free Europe from the Polish-Soviet border to the Atlantic...

Labour, in considering its alternatives to the EEC, must argue for a type of European Free Trade Area covering the whole of Europe..."

Eric Heffer looks to working-class struggle to create socialism, rather than the sort of rainbow alliance' of miscellaneous oppressed groups favoured by some on the left. But that does not mean ignoring the concerns of specially oppressed sections of the working In a section of the pamphlet which forms a powerful reply to those left-wingers who have shied away from backing Heffer because he is supposedly 'not good on women's issues', he outlines his ideas for a "women's manifesto'. They include a major programme to provide free and integrated child care facilities for all who want them; the promotion of positive action programmes to deal with discrimination in employment; action to deal with the sexist and degrading the medig, Portrayal of women in *I support Party policy on the issue of abortion. I believe there should be changes in the law to give women the right to choose whether or not they have an abortion, and to ensure that abortion facilities are available, free within the National Health Service, on an equal basis throughout the country. I have voted against attempts to restrict the 1967 Abortion Act, and I voted for Jo Richardson's Abortion Facilities Bill in 1981'.

Remember that Roy Hattersley abstained on the Alton anti-abortion Bill!

Opposing witch-hunts, Eric Heffer argues strongly for all socialists to get active in the Labour Party and to form an organised network of local Socialist Groups. "There are those who would argue that the time has come to set up a new Socialist Party. That I believe is wrong. A new Socialist Party may at some future date be necessary, but the time is not yet, and it may never be necessary, especially aS long as the trade unions are afrevolution' as exemplified in the regimes in the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe, China and Cuba, then such a society is not worth having and not worth living in... To impose power without a democratically elected base is the prelude to the end of democratic rights which have been fought for and defended against the forces of reaction".

I would argue that the Bolsheviks in 1917 did have a "democratically elected base" - the most democratically elected base that has ever existed - in the workers' councils or soviets; and that Stalinism did not flow at all "inevitably from that revolution. But in any case Eric Heffer's position is not quite as pacifist as it first appears.

*In Britain a socialist Labour Party would be faced with all the powers of the old ruling class who would do all they could to halt ty has ever given up its power and privileges cheerfully, out of the goodness of their hearts...

One often hears that violence has never been part of Labour's tradition. That is true, but whether we like it or not, violence forced on the workers at times has made Governments look into issues..."

This pamphlet is well worth reading, both for the ideas it argues, and for the way it argues them. Whether he is taking issue with Roy Hattersley, with Stalinists, with cold-warriors, or with the SWP, Eric Heffer always presents the opposing arguments fairly and deals with them seriously. That should not be unusual in the labour movement, but it is: too many are the people who rely on bombast, demagogy and alliteration instead.

All the issues dealt with in this pamphlet are important; re-establishing in the labour move-

----- pull-quotes -----

of stopping the altering of the world's CO, and ozone layers. These predictions

reviews 'Forward to Socialism', by

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 364

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →