Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Designer communism

Socialist Organiser no. 364, 21 July 1988 · scan p. 9 · about 514 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

*Rouge Baiser' isn't all that disappointing when you're watching it. It's rather cleverly made. Paris in the fifties looks pretty good, with its Left Bank jazz clubs and baguettes for breakfast.

The film is like a prolonged Levi 501s commercial; lovely to look at and packed with symbols. Only the symbols don't mean much, they're just designer accessories.

*Rouge Baiser' is supposed to be about a young Parisian girl growing up as an ardent Communist in the fifties, and what happens to her when she falls in love with a cynical Paris-Match photographer. Yet it never really connects with its subject. The scenes don't knit together to form a story. Some scenes seem significant and then go nowhere. The film is weightless emotionally and politically; nothing's at stake.

Nadia's Communism is like received religion, accepted and embraced unthinkinglv. She idolises Stalin the way teenagers worship pop stars, as elusive, unattainable gods. Her enthusiasm for demonstrations and marches is more a "shock the bourgeois' adolescent rebellion than anything serious and considered. It's politics is fun. Her parents and all her friends are Communists so Nadia is too.

When Nadia's photographerboyfriend challenges her ideas, she doesn't have any arguments to beat him with. Her politics simply evaporate, as if that were a phase she was going through.

Russia-worship is back in fashion now, with the rise of Gorbachev. All the designer Communists will Radical chic love 'Rouge Baiser'. The clothes are pretty much the same as what people are wearing now, and the politics are similar — hate America, love Russia.

Gorbachev's admirers hail him as a great reformer and ignore the real tyrannies still existing in the Soviet system. So too do Nadia's family and comrades ignore the realities of Stalin's Russia. Even when a former comrade returns to tell of the horrors of Stalin's labour camps, they don't want to believe him. Nadia's mother believes him, but doesn't want to face the truth. Telling people will just deprive them of all hope, she says.

That attitude was wrong then and is still wrong. Covering up the Soviet Union's crimes only helped Stalin continue. The way to give hope is to call things by their real names, not support distortions and falsifications. That way, the fight can be in the open. Cover-ups only lead to cynicism and disillusionment.

Nadia's eventual reaction against her youth group comrades is healthy. The baby bureaucrats have dopted the norms of the debased and corrupted Communist Party. Anyone who disagrees with the Party line is a degenerate deviationist, good only for expelling as an example. Nadia is right to reject their absurdities. Yet she rejects them only to embrace cynicism, which is no better.

The stifling atmosphere of the Communist Parties in the '50s bred cynicism. It never educated the members to be thinking, questioning people. It demanded obedience. Good militants were broken by the experience, ending up cynical and disgusted with politics for good. Nadia isn't wiser at the end of *Rouge Baiser' she's just exchanged one blind alley for another. Les Hearn's

----- pull-quotes -----

Belinda Baiser".

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 364

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →