Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

SWP tells lies

Socialist Organiser no. 364, 21 July 1988 · scan p. 8 · about 1,433 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

"We don't tell lies to the working class", said SWP speaker Phil Taylor, introducing a session at 'Marxism '88' summer school. Either he was lying or there were no working class people in the audience.

'Marxism '88" was billed as a week of debate and discussion organised by the Socialist Workers Party. It contained neither debate nor discussion.

SWP leaders threw SO supporters out of the school for no good reason and used lies, slander and sub-political abuse to attack anyone who challenged their political line. A lot of the lies, slander and abuse were directed at Socialist Organiser. Here are some examples. The culprits are prominant SWP members.

Lie: "Socialist Organiser are hypocrites when they talk about fighting the witch-hunt. In Liverpool they joined the Liverpool Labour left and supported the witch-hunt of Militant" . (Maureen Watson).

Fact: Socialist Organiser have never supported the witch-hunt of 'Militant' • We have always voted against and vehemently denounced the expulsion from the Labour Party of Militant supporters. We have organised and taken part in campaigns to defend 'Militant' from the witch-hunters.

We have been highly critical of the politics of 'Militant" and their leadership of Liverpool City Council. We have also been highly critical of Derek Hatton for his "flash Harry' life and lifestyle.

Only somebody who believes that WC have no right to criticise "Militant' can possibly believe that this adds up to support for the SO supporters did attend two or three meetings of the Liverpool Labour left to argue for our politics - including our opposition to expulsions.

The SWP are the last people to WE SWP Guru Tony Cliff give us lessons on fighting witch-hunts in the Labour Party. Yes, Sw the only thing which could bring has opposed the witch-hunt; at the peace to the region, a democratic same time, it has advised Labour secular state of Palestine in which left-wingers not to fight the witch- all religious equal rights." Thes The SWP explains hunt but instead to save Kinnock the trouble of expelling them and that the way to win this democratic quit the party first! secular state is to extend the PalestiMilitant supporters were violent- nian uprising into a pan-Arab ly ejected from IS (forerunner of workers' revolution. the SWP) public meetings in Liverpool in the early "70s. Their crime state', imposed by Arab might was asking awkward questions. against the unanimous oppositon of Lie: "Socialist Organiser has the the Israeli Jews be democratic? same policy for the Jews as Hitler How could it be maintained by and Stalin" - (John Rose) anything less than the Arabs doing Fact: It is obscene even to equate to the Jews what Israel is doing today to the Arabs in the West Bank Stalin with Hitler in relation to the Jews, let alone to equate us with and Gaza? Why, if we have a either. The Nazis killed six million workers' revolution across the Jews during the Holocaust. whole region, is it impermissable Roughly 1½ million escaped from for the Israeli Jews to have a small the Nazis to the USSR. There they niche of their own? Socialists want to see all national prejudices, taced prejudice, discrimination, and sometimes violent intolerance, hostilities, and feelings of but nothing comparable to the separateness fade away: but why Holocaust. You can say Stalin and should we not grant the Israeli Jews Hitler had the same policy towards the same rights as any other nation, the Jews only if you think it makes that their union with other nations no difference whether Jews are should be voluntary rather than slaughtered or survive. forced?

As for Socialist Organiser: we oppose anti-semitism; we support the right of the Israeli Jews to their own state; we support the right of the the SWP leaders are not Jew-haters. Palestinian Arabs to their own state and their struggle against oppression by Israel. How is that like thinking them through. Hitler, or even Stalin?

Mike Simons explained it in Socialist Worker of 16 January: an in its reign of terror against the independent Palestinian state is no good because "it would be a Callinicos). phoney state with no power, no resources and unable to decide clear distinction between the Israeli foreign policy independent of Jewish nation (and their right to a Israel" . Why? Doesn't that depend state of their own) and the policies on the struggle? If the SWP think the Palestinians can't muster the uprising of the Palestinian people, strength to make their own state we are for the withdrawal of Israeli really independent, how do they think the Palestinains can conquer Gaza, we are for the creation of an anti-socialist bureaucracies. gays.

*There is no support in Israel for Lie: "Socialist Organiser has a two-state position on Ireland" (Chris Bambury).

Fact: Socialist Organiser argues would have for a united Ireland with federal autonomy for the mainly protestant areas. You can read this in our Where We Stand" column every week. The SWP is a lot nearer a 'two-state' position than us. It How can this 'democratic secular blithely sloganises about "Troops Out Now' without any proposals to deal with the Catholic/Protestant communal conflict other than generalities about socialism. The SWP leaders must know that this version of "Troops Out' would certainly lead to full-scale civil war and bloody repartition. They cannot possibly believe what Socialist Worker sometimes implies - that British withdrawal would automatically undo the entire heritage of centuries of British domination of Ireland, including the communal conflict.

In Socialist Worker of 9 July Paul Foot wrote that troops out might 'chaos Produce "chaos" but "the might produce a unity in a labour movement which has been The SWP call the revolution they for so long successfully divided" want, "socialist'. It sounds more Through civil war to comradeship? chauvinist than socialist to us. No, Even if Paul Foot believes this, the SWP's political leaders are not so They are just people who use foolish. radical sounding slogans without The SWP leaders do not want full-scale civil war and repartition.

Lie: "*Groups (meaning Socialist But they are irresponsible enough to Organiser) support the Israeli state mouth slogans which mean that -just_ because the slogans sound Palestinian people' (Alex good.

To tell lies about your political Fact: Socialist Organiser makes a opponents is a sure sign of political bankruptcy. In the '30s the Stalinists perfected the lie as a political method. Now the SWP of the Israeli state. We support the have embarked on the first steps of the same road. But why?

What the SWP says today about forces from the West Bank and Iran and Palestine flies in the face of its basic theory and political independent Palestinian state. tradition. The SWP's forerunner, We want Labour Party and trade the Socialist Review group, started out in 1950 on the basis of refusing to support North Korea against US imperialism as other would-be Trotskyists did. In the '50s and '60s, one of its chief political badges tendency was its opposition to "Third Worldism', which often went as far as downright disdain for Third World struggles. It has continued the same attitude into the '80s, though (without explanation) developing quite different theories to underpin it: see Nigel Harris's recent book, "The End of the Third World'!

In 1982 the SWP was one of very few would-be Trotskyist groups who (like us) rejected the 'antiimperialist line of supporting Argentina in the South Atlantic war, and instead explained that Argentina's role in the war was imperialistic like Britain's, though on a different scale. In 1980 the SWP opposed both sides in the Iran/Iraq war, though the recentness of Iran'S 1979 revolution made many would-be Trotskyists back Iran. On Palestine/Israel the SWP's current line has a longer history; but even there the insistence on the immovably reactionary nature of the Israeli working class is new, and in 1967 the SWP (then IS) favoured self-determination for the Israeli Jews within a socialist federation of the Middle East.

What's going on? For the SWP, what it expounds as theory has always been one thing, what it uses as day-to-day practical politics another. As Tony Cliff once put it (in an argument over the SWP/IS's shift to opposing British entry into the EEC, in 1971), "Tactics and principles contradict each other"

Often the SWP "line" is put together in the same sort of way that bourgeois parties package their "message" . The first requirement is that the line sounds good and suits organisational needs. Squaring it theoretically is a job for scribblers to mop up afterwards.

At present the SWP wants to sell

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 364

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →