Pakistan: for a
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-07-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
"regard participation in the system of separate racial representation in rany shape or form" as impermissible.
This "inflexible principle" was also an error. It was vital to distinguish between "participation in elections by the people who accept racial discrimination... and participation... in order to exploit them the interests of the liberatory struggle."l In principle, Mandela was solutely right. Unfortunately the occasion was not.
Instead of pursuing demands for a pound a day and the end to the pass laws coming from within the anks of the unions and instead of ›ursuing the militant anti-pass campaigns of the women's federation, government had arrested 156 political leaders following the adoption of the Freedom Charter, charg ing them with participation in a treasonable conspiracy, inspired by international communism, to overthrow the state by violent means.
The trial dragged on for over four years, the last of the defendants being acqutted in 1961... It served its purpose, however, in exhausting the financial and mental energies of the movement at a crucial time.
The court gave considerable space for political statements. Mandela reasserted his commitment to universal adult franchise, his distance from Communism and his non-racialism: "we are not antiwhite, we are against white supremacy"
After his release, Mandela was heavily involved in the mass actions which followed the Sharpeville shooting. This was a tumultous time in South African history, when tens of thousands of workers went on strike and took to the streets.
The Congress Alliance was not prepared for this level of working class militancy. It either left it to its own resources or made inappropriate calls for Days of Mourning and stay-at-Homes which drew workers back from initiatives already taken. In 1961, for example, Mandela was still approaching the United Party, offering support to their opposition to the declaration of a Republic.
When the ANC finally called a had severed the possibility of cooperation.
The ANC turned to armed struggle in the form of a sabotage organisation, Umkhonto We Sizwe (Spear of the Nation). Although it broke through the bounds of pacifism and legality, its guerrillaist orientation cut against the mass organisation of workers. Instead reliance was to be placed on small groups of armed men infiltrating into the country.
Mandela, known as the Black Pimpernel, was picked up and tried for incitment to strike illegally.
Mandela was convicted only to reappear on sabotage charges at the Rivonia trial. Here he declared that "violence by the African people had become inevitable" and that "without violence there would be no way open to the African people... All lawful modes of expressing opposition... had been closed by legislation. There was no choice, it was a question of "submit or fight'"
Violence was to be kept to the minimum, sabotage against property not terrorism against persons.
The object as far as he was concerned was not communism or a classless society, but rather the attainment of democratic rights: "I regard the British Parliament" , he said, "as the most democratic insitution in the world and the independence and impartiality of its judiciary never fail to arouse my admiration"
Mandela never explored the parPakistan's ruler, General Lia, has sacked the coun try's civilian government and dissolved the Parliament chosen by 'nonparty' elections.
If he keeps his promise to abide by the constitution, he must hold elections open to the political parties by 29 August. Ten:
of thousands demonstrated in Lahore 13 July demanding that Zia set a date for these The biggest opposition party is the Pakistan People's Party. Under the leadership of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto it ruled Pakistan from 1970 to 1977 with a populist and nationalist policy, including extensive nationalisations and some welfare measures and land reform. In 1977 it was overthrown by a military coupToday the PPP is led by servative policy. Ali Asgahr and Amjad Mirza argue that Pakistani workers need not the PPP's vague promises, but their own workers' party.
Benazir Bhutto and the Pakistan People's Party say that they are poised for a *historic challenge to President General Mohammed Zia Ul Haq" which will "put an end to the martial law years" and provide a solution to "economic and social hardships"
The PPP aims to mount this electoral challenge with a number of possible alliances. The PPP may fight the general election with an electoral pact with the other parties in the Movement for Restoration of Democracy in Pakistan (MRD). However, this is unlikely, as a comprehensive division of electoral constituencies would be needed taking into account the relative strengths of each of the eleven parties. Negotiation of such an electoral pact would also necessitate negotiations as to which party would fight the highest number of winnable seats and thus be the majority party in the National Assembly.
A second possibility is an electoral pact with the Jamat e Islami and elements of the exparliamentary Muslim League. The fact that this is being considered as a serious possibility by the PPP really exposes it as a party bound on a course of out-and-out opportunism and the reduction of the populist slogans of the late Zulfikar Ali Bhutto of "food, clothing and shelter", , which had such an echo among the masses in the seventies, to an evasive and indecisive: "you adapt policies to achieve certain ends'!
Jamat e Islami is an extreme right-wing strike breaking party. It is a willing tool of the American imperialists, and acted as the intermediary between the army and the Americans at the time of the 1977 coup. The Muslim League has shown itself for three years now as a willing tool for Zia until its dismissal on the 29 May 1988 Benzir Bhutto is even talking about cooperation with Zia. "The promised elections pose no threat to the president" because "the constitutional changes have legally indemnified him against prosecution.
The populist anti-American tinge of Z.A. Bhutto's later days as leader of the PPP has been replaced by an appeal to the Americans for *moral support more than anything else" , and the reduction of the relationship between Zia (and what he represents) and the Americans to a mere arms transaction. Benazir Bhutto urges the US to use this as a bargaining counter to convince Zia of the folly of his ways: When you give money, you have the right to ask who you are giving it to"
The reasons for the shedding of this populist image of the PPP are many.
Firstly, there has been definite falling away of popular activity and unrest during the years of the martial law regime, starting with the failure first of all to mount any kind of succesful campaign during the trial and after the execution of Z.A. Bhutto himself. Then there were the two periods of stabilisation of the martial law regime itself.
The first of these resulted from the Russian intervention in Afganistan. It so disorientated and strengthened he parise of zand strengthened regime as a policeman and pawn of the West in the region. Pakistan received additional military and financial aid. The conditions for mounting a successful campaign and mobilising the masses subsided.
The second period of stabilisation was that following the non-party based elections of 1985 when the martial law regime succeeded in giving itself a civilian face after the election attracted (it is widely held) a 50% to 60% poll.
In elections for the municipal councils the PPP has suffered severe reverses. This has been accompanied by the defection from the party of senior figures such as Jatoi (a former chief minister of Sind province during the Bhutto regime) and Mustafa Khar (a former Governor of Punjab province under Bhuto).
A serious rift in the PPP over the party's attitude to the US threatens its unity and may lead to further splits in the party.
The party's political impotence in fighting Zia and the weakness of the party structure itself have undermined its broader support amongst the masses, with the consequent shedding of its populist message, and left the PPP seeking electoral alliances of a completly unprincipl ed nature as a means to an electoral victory at any costs.
----- pull-quotes -----
"Mandela was never able to investigate the reasons for the terrible defeats of the 1960s."
Bhutto's daughter Benazir, with a markedly more con-