Hands off our homes
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-07-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Glasgow (above) and Birmingham (right): housing in Britain today. Photos: Andrew Wiard (Report), Nigel P Clapp By Will Adams Over a thousand tenants from all over Tower Hamlets met in York Hall last week and voted unanimously to oppose any attempts to set up a Housing Action Trust on any estate in the borough.
The Government have announced plans to take 25,000 council properties in London (Lambeth, Southwark and Tower Hamlets), Sandwell, Leeds and Sunderland away from their current landlords and to hand them over to unelected Housing Action Trusts (HATs). The HATs are part of the Housing Bill, which is likely to become law before the end of the year. The Government plans to establish the Trusts at the beginning of 1989.
HATs are based on the model of Urban Development Corporations such as the London Docklands Development Corporation. They will be run by boards of businessmen appointed by Nicholas Ridley, Secretary of State for the Environment, and will be answerable to him for their actions. Their job is to do up the housing under their control and then, within 10 years, sell it off to new landlords - housing associations, tenants' cooperatives, private landlords or developers for sale to owneroccupiers.
HATs will have no obligation to carry out the wishes of their tenants. Nicholas Ridley says that HATs will 'listen to' the views of their tenants, but also makes it very clear that it will be his views that matter. The Housing Bill allows Ridley to sack the board of a HAT if they fail to carry out his wishes.
Tenants in the area affected will have no veto on whether their housing is transferred to the HAT. William Waldegrave, Minister for Housing, was asked at the press conference announcing the proposed HATs why he was not prepared to give tenants the limited right of veto they have under the so-called "Pick a Landlord" provisions of the Housing Bill - where a transfer to a new landlord can be stopped if a ballot on the issue shows a majority of those eligible to vote (rather than a simple majority of those voting) against the proposal. His reply was that there is no real choice for the tenants involved: they can stay with their Council which will not have the money to improve their homes, or transfer to a HAT which will.
This sums up the Government's approach to council housing since 1979. They have used their control on council borrowing powers to prevent councils spending the money needed on their housing stock. Now they are blaming those councils for failing to maintain their stock. They hope that tenants welcome the HATs, which come with the promise of money for major improvements.
The Government will give the HATs £125 million over the first 3 years of their existence. In his letter to the tenants in the areas involved he says that this money will mean that HATs will not increase rents before improvements are done on their homes.
Of course _tenants welcome any money that is made available for improving their homes. But f125 million is nowhere near enough to meet the needs for improvement in the proposed HAT areas. It works out at about £5,000 per flat, spread over 3 years. On Ocean Estate in Tower Hamlets, 4 blocks are to be handed over to a HAT. 3 of these blocks are severely cold and damp. The cheapest option for solving these problems is to demolish the blocks and build low-rise housing. This was last costed at £15 million in the country. So housing sold by a HAT to developers would not be sold to the people currently living there:
Rent levels on housing sold to housing associations or private landlords would be twice current council rents or more, because of the changes in housing association financing arrangements and the provisions in the Housing Bill allowing tor rents to be set at "market levels" . Again, this will be beyond the reach of many of the current tenants. Housing Benefit is unlikely to cover the full cost of increased rents.
The Tory Government wants to shift poorer people out of the inner cities and replace them with people who can afford owner-occupation and market rents. Bringing richer people into the inner cities will generate jobs - and increase the number of Tory voters, thus doing down inner-city Labour councils.
As for the people forced out of the inner cities, the Government argue they should take their chances in an unrestricted free market in housing. So, in the terms of Tory ideology, tenants form the demand side of a market where the supply in housing available for rent and the price is rent levels. The market will increase the price if demand is higher than supply. If this leads to an increase in homeless people and people forced to live in substandard and overcrowded accommodation, then hard luck.
Tom Baron, chair of the Stockbridge Village Trust (a private trust running an ex-council estate in Merseyside) spelled it out at an Institute of Housing Conference. In order to attract private money to ex-council housing, he said, a degree of "social engineering" must accompany the improvement of the stock. "If the excessive concentration of the elderly, the poor, the unskilled, the unsocial and the ethnic minorities is still seen to predominate, then the investors will not believe that the improved housing and environment will be maintained and they will not invest."
364.