Is Militant's programme socialist?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 26 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 26
Be need a socialist answer to the Policy Review. We need to win the labour movement to socialist ideas so that the movement can offer a real alternative to the Tories.
The Militant tendency is the best-known of the groups claiming to do that work of organising for socialism. So, does Militant have the answers?
Let's judge by experience. More than any other would-be Marxist tendency, Militant has had the chance to put their theories into practice — when they had a leading role in Liverpool City Council, in 1983-6.
It was a bad experience. It was not just that Liverpool lost. Victory does not follow automatically from correct politics, and even the most blameless leadership can be defeated in a struggle. And anyone can make mistakes.
There were far deeper problems in Liverpool. In 1984, Liverpool council did mobilise a mass workers' movement - but then, at the height of the miners? strike, they accepted a compromise agreement with the Tories - a deal which, according to Derek Hatton's autobiography, was specifically designed to break any potential Liverpool-NUM united front! Militant then declared this a 95% victory.
By then, they were already at loggerheads with the city's Black Caucus over the appointment of Samson Bond, a Militant supporter, as Race Relations Officer. They argued that the opposition from the Black Caucus was based on the vested interests of the local race relations industry'.
Even if this were so, it was ridiculous to pick that moment when the greatest possible unity needed against the Tories — to make a stand on that issue. Again, Hatton's autobiography makes it clear that the appointment of Bond was a political decision taken by Militant.
It revealed a bureaucratic streak that runs very deep in Militant's politics — something that will be familiar to anvone who has ever visited Labour Party Young Socialists conference as an oppositionist. Old techniques of boss politics were given a new, Marxist gloss. Opponents of Militant found themselves very summarily dealt with.
Militant's whole strategy for socialism is, indeed, highly bureaucratic. They call for a 'socialist Labour government', as if just voting Labour and appealing for socialism could create such a thing, without the labour movement being transformed. This government will nationalise the top 200 monopolies, with control on the basis of one-third representation from the government. one-third from the TUC, and one-third from the unions in each enterprise.
On this basis, Militant argues, the powers-that-be could be defeated. Popular, working-class support for the government would ensure its success and By Gerry a peaceful transformation of society.
Militant used to carry a weekly back page /What We Stand For' column which argued for nationalisations to be "carried through an Enabling Act in Parliament"
This programme is quite explicitly for socialism from above, to be achieved by a radical Labour government. It equates socialism with nationalisation. It is essentially a more radical version of the traditional Labour Party approach. Its fundamental flaw is that it looks at everything from the wrong end.
For socialism to be possible, a powerful movement of workers must be created which takes control over every aspect of life. Such a movement has to Flash Harry Hatton be built from below. Its focus must be rank-and-file action. Socialism will be achieved when the working class take: over the workplaces, the housing estates, and is able democratically to run society.
It will not do that through a Westminster-type Parliament an assembly elected once every five years, insulated from day-to-day democratic control, and geared into a big, bureaucratic, unelected state machine. A more radical, grass-roots democracy will be needed, which is rooted more firmly in local communities and workplaces, and which replaces the old bureaucratic and military structures.
A socialist strategy therefore has to be based above all on working-class struggle in the workplaces and communities.
Of course, Parliament is very impor tant. We need socialist MPs. Some of the far left, like the Socialist Workers' Party, downgrade the importance of Parliament in the perceptions and concerns of working-class people.
But socialist MPs have to be part of a strategy based outside Parliament, and relying on the strength of rank and file workers.
Militant are not unaware o f the cencrality of extra-Parliamentary struggles. Yet the weight they give to such notions as an 'Enabling Act' can only undermine any sense of their priority.
Militant do criticise the model of the USSR and other states where a nationalised economy exists under a police state. But they still, somehow, consider that sort of system to be a great step forward. Indeed, they see it as the only possible next step forward in most of the Third World. They supported the USSR's military occupation of Afghanistan on the grounds of the tremendous social progress they thought it would produce.
Militant see nationalisation as the core of socialism regardless of who does the nationalising. And their scheme of the "Enabling Act' raises a further question.
The idea that, if an Enabling Act were passed, the British ruling class would keel over and do nothing to defend its interests, is utterly absurd. The ruling class will do whatever they can to defend their interests, including violence on a huge scale.
Socialists must warn the workers' movement about this, and argue for workers to be prepared to • defend themselves. Yet Militant argues that peaceful transition to socialism is possible — one in which the ruling class does not resist, or not much.
With foolish optimism, they insist that the working class is so strong that the capitalists will not even dare to put up a fight! With equal blandness, Militant says that 'the hammer blows of events' will radicalise workers, always driving them to the left. So long as Militant is there, with its carefully-preserved 'Marxist programme' , the workers are bound to be pushed towards it.
This bland "compulsory optimism' is no better than an upside-down version of the habitual defeatism of journals like Marxism Today. And it leads to bureaucratic passivity. "The programme is always the music of the future. Now there might be too many risks, and since the future will always be better than the present, the risks are not considered worth taking.
This mentality affected the struggle in Liverpool. Socialist Organiser commented in September 1985: "Victory is inevitable in the long term; so why take risks now? If the situation is favourable now, it will certainly be more favourable in the future. And it makes no sense to risk positions, prestige and propaganda platforms for the sake of "ephemeral' struggle.
"So Militant have tried to maintain a delicate balance: on the one hand giving Liverpool a profile as a fighting, socialist council; on the other trying to make sure they keep the council in office and themselves in the leadership of the council"
That delicate balancing act finally led to a fiasco. Militant's bureaucratic socialism from above is no alternative, in the long run, to Kinnockite new realism.
Scan page 27
The emancipation of the working class i emancipation of all human beings witho distinction of sex or race.
stressed the class struggle as the history and. in particular, the class 7 therefore it is impossible for us to to eliminate this class struggle from the movement of the working class must be the institutions £10). Special offer: complete run of back numbers (nos.1-5), plus sub for nos. 7-12, for £7 Is also LIBERTY ut Karl Marx The emancipation work of the working class itself."
Mars and fogel te Bets Sectonge i879 КОДО АрГІТМУ 82 institution: numbers (institution Name Address LE Send me: 1 I enclose: 1 Send to W payable to One ye ; £10). Special (nos. 1-5), plus $ £15).
Vos.7-12 'L, PO B Socialist •kers st • Nos.7-12 10/ £15 (de ox 823, LI Organiser. chev Ir 2S.7 CC for Kowale What's wrong Bens's socialist manifest * Scottish Assembiy blete DS.
Scan page 28
y we need a conference of Constituency Labour Parties The party rank and file must make their voice heard Labour Listens, says Neil Kinnock. But Neil Kinnock clearly listens only to the opinion polls and the Tory press:
Labour activists want a leadership that listens to the labour movement. That's why Wallasey Constituency Labour Party is calling a conference of Constituency Labour Parties in the run-up to this year's Blackpool Conference.
The initiative was announced at the Chesterfield Socialist Conference at a meeting with representation from 25 CLPs.
Even Kinnock loyalists have been badly jolted by his attack on unilateralism.
And at this year's conference the NEC will propose a constitutional change requiring future leadership challengers to first get the support of 20% of Labour MPs, instead of the present 5%. This means gi ving the Parliamentary Labour Party: an effective veto over Party member s' rights to choose the Leader and Deputy Leader of the Party.
The NEC is also moving to increase the already considerable - and increasingly regularly used — powers of the NEC and Party leadership to impose candidates on local parties.
The leadership challenge of Tony Benn and Eric Heffer has blown the whistle on all this, and given the left the signal to reorganise.
Party members far too often still feel isolated in the face of Kinnock and Hattersley's relentless move to the right. That's why we need the conference called by Wallasey.
It is especially important now that the Labour leaders have published the Policy Review documents, with only a vague promise that they will be open to some form of amendment.
Speaking to Socialist Organiser, Wallasey CLP secretary Richard Aplin explained that he is booking a venue for the conference in the North West sometime in September. A letter will soon be sent out to CLPs asking for support, sponsorship and help in organising the conference.
"There could not be a more important time for CLPs to get together. We need the strongest possible grassroots campaign to defend unilateralism, Clause 4 and party democracy. If we organise now then I am sure we can mount a successful defence.
"I would urge all CLPs to attend the conference we are helping to organise in September. If you want more information, contact me at 108 Seaview Road, Wallasey,
----- pull-quotes -----
The area ronicass Subscribe to Workers Liberty!
ON AND ON AND ONZ WORKERS'
WORKERS' struggie between the bourgeoisie LIBERTY
WORKERS LIBERTY
WORKERS' LIBERTY
Wh we