Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Full employment is possible!

Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s, 28 June 1988 · scan pp. 24–25 · about 986 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 24 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 24

By Everyone agrees that tackling I unemployment must be central to Labour's challenge employment is utopian.

Maybe, they say, British capitalism can be coaxed and nudged down to one million unemployed rather than three million; but that's all. Labour's leaders now want to scrap even Labour's previous promise to get unemployment down to one million over five years.

In the 1950s and early '60s Labour's right-wingers used to say that modern capitalism — the 'mixed economy' -could guarantee fairly full employment, and so there was no need for socialism. Now they say that no system can give full employment... and so there is no point in trying socialism.

Why unemployment should become inevitable, they don't say.

Some Tories say that workers have priced themselves out of jobs. Wages are too high.

But unemployment was lower when wages were rising fast in the 1950s and '60s. Since around 1970 real wages have stagnated or fallen in the US and risen very slowly elsewhere, but unemployment has multiplied.

If you compare different countries, usually the ones with higher wages have lower unemployment. Britain has lower wages than the US, West Germany, Japan or Sweden.

Unemployment is not caused by high wages. Both unemployment and pressure to reduce wages are caused by capitalist crisis.

A lot of people say that unemployment is caused by new technology. But capitalism has been introducing new technologies continuously ever since the steam engine, and on the whole employment has expanded rather than declined.

Detailed studies can find only a few thousand job losses, among the millions in Britain in recent years, caused by new technology. In fact productivity in the advanced capitalist countries is rising rather slowly. Unemployment mostly reflects lower production, not higher production with fewer workers. And if you compare different countries, those with most new technology, like Japan and Sweden, generally have lower unemployment.

The most idiotic theory of all is that people are unemployed only because they are too lazy to get jobs. How does this explain the hundreds of applications that firms have often had even for low-paid, dead-end jobs? And was it something in the water, or in the atmosphere, that made workers throughout the advanced capitalist countries suddenly start to turn idle around the end of the 1960s?

The real reason why millions are unemployed is because the economy is run for profit and not for human need.

Under the present economic system — capitalism — the aim of production is to expand capital, the accumulated wealth of the ruling class. Workers get jobs if it is profitable for the bosses, and not if it isn't.

Employment therefore expands and contracts in line with the pulse-beat of profits, investments and markets.

In boom periods each capitalist strives for an increasing share of an expanding market. New investment projects are rushed through. Speculation spirals.

But not every capitalist can have an increased share. Eventually the expansion falters. Investment is halted. Projects already underway are revealed to be unprofitable. The slump spreads from the credit system through the investment industries to every sector of the economy.

As workers lose their jobs, the capitalists who previously sold goods to those workers lose their markets. And those capitalists, in turn, sack more workers. The system spirals downwards.

People go short - because "too much" has been produced!

The slump levels out only when enough capital has been written off, and wages have been reduced sufficiently, for profits to be restored. A new boom starts — and with it the seeds of a new slump.

In the Third World, the rapid destruction by capitalism of the traditional economy in the countryside has generated huge and rising unemployment for decades. In the advanced capitalist countries, it was a bit different in the '50s and '60s.

A new framework allowing the rapid expansion of world trade after World War 2, and the growth of a wave of new industries, made booms strong and slumps shallow. Masses of new workers were drawn from underdeveloped countries and regions; more and more women were drawn into wage-work.

Capitalism always made sure that there was a slight surplus of workers over jobs - otherwise workers' bargaining position would be too strong - and in slumps the surplus became bigger. But the real turn for the worse came after the late '60s, when the framework of international finances set up after 1945 began to break down.

Under capitalism men and women do not control our own social life. We are tossed around by economic forces, of human construction but beyond human control - supply and demand, profit and investment, credit and liquidity.

So capitalism, internationally at least, has no way to restructure itself except The US is no longer super-dominant. New industrial powers have arisen. Previously central industries like cars and steel are in decline; new ones are emerging. The system knows no other way to adjust to these changes other than by the travail of trade wars, slumps, and deindustrialisation.

The remedy? We must take control of the means of production we have created and run them by democratic planning for need. We must replace the crazy patchwork of national rivalries with a cooperative international system. In place of the rat race, we must run society on principles of solidarity.

The National Health Service is short of staff. Record numbers are homeless. There is a big backlog of repairs to be done on houses, schools and hospitals.

There are plenty of jobs to be done. A planned programme of public investment could make sure that they are done.

We can start now with a fight for workers' control, for unity of the employed and unemployed, for work-sharing without loss of pay, and for training and re-training at trade union rates of pay.

Scan page 25

Organiser. 2 1988.I 'age ir Laund abour Mu

----- pull-quotes -----

to the Tories. Yet Labour's leaders now argue that anything like full

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 362–363: Socialism for the 1990s

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →