The working class is central
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-06-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 22 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 22
There is a thread which links the Kinnock wing of the Labour Party with large sections of the Labour Left — a move away from the working class.
The historian Eric Hobsbawm, a longstanding member of the Communist Party whom Neil Kinnock calls "the most sagacious of living Marxists" argues for an anti-Thatcher alliance of Labour, centre parties and Tory wets. His model is the Popular Fronts which were so disastrous for the working class internationally in the 1930s.
Kinnock does not go all the way with Hobsbawm. He can see that it would be suicidal for Labour to give up the attempt to win a majority in its own right. But for sure the base he wants the Labour Party to relate to is not the working class. Kinnock's version is to trim the politics and trim again, to appeal to some elusive 'middle ground' What is the left-wing version? The view put forward by some admirers of Ken Livingstone's Greater London Council, and by some people in the 'Chesterfield movement' ', is as follows.
Manufacturing industry is in decline. The traditional working class is disappearing. More women are going out to work. Black people are a bigger proportion of the population. More and more people are working in service industries and in white-collar work.
Ergo, the working is both politically less important, and moreover politically backward. The drive for change will come from the 'new social forces' - women, blacks, lesbians and gays, other oppressed groups. Radical politics should revolve around 'empowering' and prioritising the interests of these groups.
There have been changes in the workforce and in the workplaces. But these are changes within the working class. The task is to fight for the labour movement to unite all sections of the working class, including the most oppressed - not to switch horses on to a trainbow alliance' of oppressed groups.
The "rainbow alliance' idea was popularised by the GLC after 1982. In 1981 Labour had been elected to the GLC with a clear commitment to confronting the Government and supporting workers' struggles. But in January 1982 the GLC capitulated to the courts over cheap fares.
The GLC slid away from its commitment to class struggle. It found an easier form of radicalism in championing miscellaneous oppressed groups. The GLC could fund radical projects, set up committees to increase representation for the oppressed, and so on. The Labour councillors could be liberal, benevolent administrators in pressuregroup politics - rather than working-class fighters.
Much was creditable in what was done, but to call it a socialist project is grossly misleading. Much of it was borrowed from the not-very-socialist United Stateds. For example, in the US around 300,000 companies have their policies on equality and positive discrimination for women and blacks checked as a condition for getting Federal Government contracts. The GLC acted on a smaller scale along similar lines.
The US has lots of black mayors and feminist mayors. That's better than a white male monopoly. But it's not socialism. It's an improvement. But it hasn't changed the world, or changed conditions for the majority of black and women workers in the US.
The working class is still the force which can change the world. The changes that have taken place within the working class have not necessarily weakened it. Potentially they bring new sections into struggle. Remember the health workers' strikes earlier this year? Ten or twenty years ago, strikes by nurses were practically unknown, and union organisation in hospitals was scanty.
The working class has been written off many times before. In the 1960s theorists argued that the relative affluence of some workers - car workers in particular — had bought them off and destroyed all socialist or class-struggle thinking in them. The militancy of the late '60s and early "70s soon gave the lie to that!
Before 1984 many people argued that the miners, who were now Britain's highest-paid manual workers, with mortgages, cars, videos, and holidays in Spain, would never strike again. The great struggle of 1984-5 set the record straight!
The working class has changed. The labour movement has to be transformed to take that into account. The needs of the women and black people who are entering the workforce in increasing numbers must be met. The working-class movement has to be swept clean of the sexist, racist, backward ideas that hamper it and hold it back.
Bút the working class is the only class that can transform society. The working class is weak because our movement is politically inadequate. The task is to tackle this crisis of politics, not to place hope in a rainbow alliance of the oppressed. The oppressed can best win real equality and real liberation if they are integrated into the working-class movement.
Many on the left have written off the working class over the years. The Eurocommunist wing of the Communist Parties has moved towards the liberal bourgeoisie, throwing its lot in with a section of the bosses rather than with the working class. This has led the Italian Communist Party to attack the working class from a political position to the right of Roy Hattersley.
The Maoists argued that the working class in Europe had been bought off. In France that led the erstwhile feminist Julia Kristeva to sing the praises of the United States.
Those who write off the working class lose their political bearings. We must reassert the centrality of the working class - including women and black workets! - and to fight for working-class politics in our movement.
Scan page 23
ganiser. 28 June 1988. Page 21 Gibs LA'AYUDA"
PARN LATINO SHERIC Arguments: the Third World is immense. And it means that we need not only express outrage at the poverty and misery of Brazilian society; we can develop solidarity with a movement that has the power to change things.
How could it change things? Brazil's poverty is caused by profiteers who run the country - many of them foreign, but most of them Brazilian. Brazil is locked into the capitalist system, which churns out inequality day in, day out. Capitalism must be overthrown.
It is not possible, however, for even such a huge and resource-rich country as Brazil simply to escape from capitalism on its own. Russia in the 1920s showed that 'socialism in one country' is a disastrous illusion.
Just as a socialist transformation in Britain could only be a brief episode unless it became part of a Socialist United States of Europe, Brazilian workers need to unite with workers of other countries for — at least, as a first step — socialism on a South American level. Reorganisation of the continent's natural and other resources could break the back of poverty, though links with the huge wealth of a socialist North America or Western Europe would be the best way out.
In fact there have been important steps made towards continental workers' unity. Workers' representatives from different countries have discussed a continental strategy to fight the debt crisis. In the same way, we in Britain need to link up with workers in continental Europe to fight multinational capitalism.
Debt is a big problem in the Third World, and a socialist government there would probably cancel its debt as part of a general attack on capitalism. Most of the money Brazil borrowed to make up its debt went to Brazil's rich, who often funnelled the money straight out again